NewsBite

The lost players that keep list managers up at night ... so who has your club lost to rivals?

THEY can be the players that can end careers, that keep list managers up at night. More than 180 players are on their second or third club at the moment and there might be a few people regretting letting them go.

The players that got away.
The players that got away.

THEY are the players that can end careers, those that are let go before blossoming at a new environment.

List managers wake up in the middle of the night in cold sweats, hoping that what can be an agonising decision doesn’t come back to haunt with a best on ground in a Grand Final.

Often coaches can be the catalyst of such moves as they grow impatient for success, in the knowledge that the sack is never far away from their own necks.

FREE AGENT: EDDIE WEIGHS IN ON PIES’ LYNCH MEET

RETENTION: DOES AFL NEED COLA TO SAVE SUNS?

SIGNING COUP: McGOVERN STAYS TRUE TO EAGLES

Remarkably reigning premiers Richmond currently have just two players in Matt Dea and Brett Deledio at other clubs, and for different reasons neither has hurt the Tigers since leaving.

Alternatively expansion team GWS has 27 former players currently on the books of rival AFL clubs, and there are more than 180 players in total on either their second or third team.

As a Team of Century member and four-time premiership player with Hawthorn in the 1980s, Gary Buckenara was never in a position where he could have been shipped of to another club, but in a later life as a recruiting manager for the Hawks he saw the other side often enough.

Sydney captain Josh Kennedy. Picture: Phil Hillyard
Sydney captain Josh Kennedy. Picture: Phil Hillyard
Josh Kennedy during his time at Hawthorn.
Josh Kennedy during his time at Hawthorn.

“I guess Josh Kennedy was one at Hawthorn. The Hawks didn’t want him to go but in the end it was done and he’s now captain. He’s one they would look back on and say maybe we were a bit premature,” said Buckenara.

“And then there are times when you don’t want to lose a player, such as Carlton when they had to give up Josh Kennedy to the West Coast Eagles to get Chris Judd.

“They are really hard decisions. Do you let a 27-year-old with three or four good years left in him go to get a draft pick to use on a young kid who may give you 10 years?

ONES THAT GOT AWAY

Nathan WilsonPhil DavisJake Lever
Jeremy HoweJake CarlisleShaun Burgoyne
Adam TreloarCallan WardBryce Gibbs
Shaun HigginsLance FranklinJack Gunston
Eddie BettsJarrad WaiteGary Ablett
Stef MartinPatrick DangerfieldTom Mitchell
Tom ScullyDevon SmithToby Nankervis
Josh Caddy

“Some guys develop later than others and coaches are very quick to make calls on young players, too quick I think.

“Ruckmen and raw key forwards usually get longer because they often take longer, although a lumbering key forward in today’s game is going to struggle the way it’s played.”

Buckenara looks at Gold Coast losing players like Josh Caddy, Charlie Dixon, Jaeger O’Meara and Dion Prestia as a product of an environment that needs to be improved.

Dion Prestia in action for Gold Coast.
Dion Prestia in action for Gold Coast.
Jaeger O’Meara in action for Gold Coast.
Jaeger O’Meara in action for Gold Coast.

“The go-home factor is a big thing because of the environment at the Gold Coast where some of their young players haven’t developed, whereas at a club like the Sydney Swans they flourish.

The NEAFL competition isn’t as strong as the WAFL and SANFL and that can stifle development although Sydney seems to overcome that. Whatever they are doing to develop their rookies should be looked at closely by some of those other northern clubs.”

Every AFL club now employs our own version of the pro scout, a person hired specifically to look for a player they consider to be under-performing at a level beneath the AFL.

Find the right one and you have potential gold.

Delisted, trade and free agency loses

Adelaide
Charlie Cameron, Patrick Dangerfield, Phil Davis, Jack Gunston, Ricky Henderson, Sam Kerridge, Jake Lever, Jarryd Lyons, Shaun McKernan, Bernie Vince, Harrison Wigg, Matthew Wright
Brisbane
James Aish, Jack Crisp, Sam Docherty, Josh Green, Pearce Hanley, Lachie Henderson, Matthew Leuenberger, Billy Longer, Jared Polec, Michael Rischitelli, Jack Redden, Tom Rockliff, Josh Schache, Elliot Yeo
Carlton
Tom Bell, Eddie Betts, Dylan Buckley, Jeff Garlett, Bryce Gibbs, Shaun Grigg, Billy Gowers, Lachie Henderson, Nick Holman, Sam Jacobs, Josh Kennedy, Mitch Robinson, Zach Tuohy, Jarrad Waite.
Collingwood
Dayne Beams, Nathan Brown, Jon Ceglar, Nathan Freeman, Michael Hartley, Lachlan Keeffe, Paul Seedsman, Heath Shaw, Dale Thomas, Marley Williams, Jarrod Witts
Essendon
Jake Carlisle, Stewart Crameri, Michael Hibberd, Bachar Houli, Josh Jenkins, Jake Melksham, Alex Morgan, Paddy Ryder
Fremantle
Harley Balic, Michael Barlow, Matt de Boer, Hayden Crozier, Chris Mayne, Sam Menegola, Dylan Roberton, Alex Silvagni, Lachie Weller
Geelong
Mitch Brown, Josh Caddy, Allen Christensen, Joel Hamling, Shane Kersten, Darcy Lang, Steven Motlop, Dawson Simpson, Travis Varcoe, Nathan Vardy, Josh Walker
Gold Coast
Gary Ablett, Harley Bennell, Josh Caddy, Charlie Dixon, Tom Hickey, Brandon Matera, Trent McKenzie, Jaeger O’Meara, Dion Prestia, Adam Saad, Matt Shaw, Zac Smith, Mav Weller
GWS Giants
Taylor Adams, Paul Ahern, Jake Barrett, Tom Boyd, Josh Bruce, Tomas Bugg, Sam Frost, Curtly Hampton, Jack Hombsch, Will Hoskin-Elliott, Matthew Kennedy, Jed Lamb, Pat McKenna, Caleb Marchbank, Cam McCarthy, Anthony Miles, Jonathan O’Rourke, Andrew Phillips, Jarrod Pickett, Lachie Plowman, Devon Smith, Jack Steele,James Stewart, Jacob Townsend, Adam Treloar, Dom Tyson, Nathan Wilson
Hawthorn
Jed Anderson, Kyle Cheney, Lance Franklin, Sam Gibson, Billy Hartung, Brad Hill, Luke Hodge, Josh Kennedy, Jordan Lewis, Sam Menegola, Shane Savage, Matthew Suckling
Melbourne
Dom Barry, Kyle Cheney, Lynden Dunn, James Frawley, Jeremy Howe, Stefan Martin, Tom Scully, Jimmy Toumpas, Jack Trengove, Jack Watts
North Melbourne
Ryan Bastinac, Aaron Black, Sam Gibson, Levi Greenwood, Aaron Mullett, Cam Pedersen, LIndsay Thomas, Daniel Wells,
Port Adelaide
Brendon Ah Chee, Logan Austin, Shaun Burgoyne, Jarman Impey, Ben Jacobs, Matthew Lobbe, Cameron O’Shea, Danyle Pearce, Aaron Young, Jackson Trengove
Richmond
Matt Dea, Brett Deledio
St Kilda
Jamie Cripps, Brendon Goddard, Mark Hutchings, Tom Lynch, Ben McEvoy, Rhys Stanley
Sydney
Shane Biggs, Lewis Jetta, Jed Lamb, Tim Membrey, Tom Mitchell, Sam Murray, Toby Nankervis, Sam Rowe
West Coast
Brad Ebert, Matt Rosa, Scott Selwood, Callum Sinclair, Koby Stevens
Western Bulldogs
Stewart Crameri, Ryan Griffen, Joel Hamling, Jarrod Harbrow, Shaun Higgins, Nathan Hrovat, Liam Jones, Sam Reid, Koby Stevens, Jake Stringer, Callan Ward

Add your comment to this story

To join the conversation, please Don't have an account? Register

Join the conversation, you are commenting as Logout

Original URL: https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/more-news/the-lost-players-that-keep-list-managers-up-at-night-so-who-has-your-club-lost-to-rivals/news-story/a52ce1ff1553e0e6e9477a46b78afe0f