Mick Malthouse questions why St Kilda traded for Dan Hannebery after he struggled at Sydney
Why would you spend so much time going after a player who will not only NOT start the season but one has to wonder just how many games he will play over his five-year contract. Enter Saints and Dan Hannebery.
AFL News
Don't miss out on the headlines from AFL News. Followed categories will be added to My News.
St Kilda continues to shoot itself in the foot.
Think back to 2015 when Collingwood put talented, but injury-prone midfielder, Nathan Freeman on the trade table after exhausting all avenues to get him on the park.
I can only assume the Saints sought expert advice on whether they could do more than Collingwood — with all the resources and facilities it has — to have him fit enough to debut and string some games together.
SAINTS: HANNEBERY NEEDS TO BE ‘REBUILT’
TRADING PLACES? KELLY WILL ASK CATS AGAIN
Through no fault of his own, that failed to happen, and after just two AFL games Freeman was delisted last year.
I really feel for the kid, but I do wonder what the recruiters at St Kilda are thinking when they again take on a player who was let go because his club could no longer get the best out of him.
Sydney knew Dan Hannebery had issues. They knew that he had been blessed with talent, but lacked speed and played a physical game which had taken its toll on his body.
The Saints went hard at Dylan Shiel and Devon Smith, but missed out. They continued to pursue a big “name” and chased Hannebery, who will not only NOT start the season for them, but one has to wonder just how many games he will play over his five-year contract, and more importantly, how well he will play when he does.
While St Kilda has made some average decisions, its opponent this weekend has had no say in its own destruction.
Gold Coast resides in a foreign AFL environment. The Suns’ plating list has been torn apart and their bones picked clean by scavengers wanting the best deal for themselves. As a result, a club that was supposed to be a highly competitive finals prospect has never finished higher than 12th in its eight seasons.
I feel for both coaches for different reasons. Alan Richardson begins the season on the back foot with a long list of injuries and outs, and Stuart Dew is left to virtually start over with what remains of his team.
The clash is a battle to avoid the wooden spoon. One team will come away with an invaluable four points, while one will come away with nothing but the prospect of a long, long year.
WHERE GIANTS, BOMBERS ARE ‘NOT GOOD ENOUGH’
Victorian clubs haven’t exactly spared Greater Western Sydney either. The Giants knew that salary cap advantages would have to be trimmed and they would eventually be forced to sacrifice talent. The more astute clubs had those players inked in years ago.
This is D-year for GWS.
The club’s injury curse seems never ending. Surely there has to be an answer and a remedy for this. It can’t keep happening.
The Giants don’t seem to know if they want to be a very defensive team or an all-out attacking side. They blow big leads, or at other times get hammered early and show no resistance.
They’ve played finals every year since 2016, but the preliminary final against the Bulldogs was perhaps the one that got away.
For all their talent, the player pool below the 15th or 16th player is borderline good enough, which creates a juggling act for coach Leon Cameron and the match committee because against the best opposition these players are exposed.
Jeremy Cameron, Stephen Coniglio, Callan Ward, Toby Greene, Josh Kelly, Phil Davis and Heath Shaw can’t do it all on their own, and the wonderful depth this club once had is now playing elsewhere.
I fear the time has come and gone for GWS. Hopefully it doesn’t end up like Gold Coast.
The Giants’ opponent today is just as frustrating.
You get the impression Essendon has been a wonderful side for a long time, but the reality is that it hasn’t won a final since 2004.
The Bombers are star studded and John Worsfold has done a wonderful job in getting the team back on even keel since the disaster of the drug scandal, so how can we continue to support the theory that the club is scarred by what took place many years ago now.
The significance of this game is not just the four points, but what direction the clubs are heading in.
Both teams run on talent and adrenaline from the first bounce until the opposition starts to squeeze them and a lack of resilience and sticking to the game plan becomes evident and lets them down.
Too often players from both these clubs hang their heads when the chips are down. It’s not good enough. Their leaders have to set and maintain the standard.
With enviable manpower there are so many questions to be answered. How many goals will Jeremy Cameron need to kick? Can Tom Bellchambers hold down the ruck? Will Toby Greene stand up? Can Joe Daniher get fit, return to the team and stay fit?
There is no doubt that this needs to be an action year for both GWS and Essendon.
MY FAITH IN KANGAS, FYFE’S QUESTIONABLE CALL
North Melbourne was unlucky not to make the finals last year, while Fremantle has been on a downward spiral since its 2013 Grand Final appearance.
North will again have an impact on the top eight and should squeeze into the September mix.
As much as it chased and missed out on some big names, it’s recruiting has been good, securing Jared Polec and Jasper Pittard, both needed for their speed off the backline.
It will need Ben Brown to be as productive as last year (61 goals from 22 games) and more assistance for him across the ground will be required, given that Jarrad Waite, a good foil, has retired.
The Kangaroos rely heavily on their wonderful captain Jack Ziebell and Shaun Higgins, but North has a team of goers and will collect some big scalps this season. Twelve wins should be enough to make the final eight.
Fremantle is only treading water.
The Dockers’ greatest player, Matthew Pavlich, retired at the end of 2016.
Aaron Sandilands is 36 and leaves a big hole to fill when he isn’t fit, which is too often. He’s played just 26 off a possible 66 games in the past three years.
David Mundy and Stephen Hill are club stalwarts but they can’t go on forever. So that leaves questions over the bona fide abilities of Michael Walters and captain Nat Fyfe.
Walters has been outstanding, but I have reservations about whether Fyfe can be the complete player Fremantle needs him to be to lead it out of the wilderness.
I like to think that players prioritise their life to get maximum results for the club. But when your captain chooses to play AFLX and THEN have elbow surgery, I become suspicious about where his loyalties and priorities lie. I would think Ross Lyon would have been fuming at that decision.
Side note: what is AFLX anyway?
Fyfe is excellent one-on-one, he is productive at stoppages, but he is deplorable in his defensive work. When his opponent spreads they know they can get him because he has little interest in working hard the “other” way. He too often makes the wrong choice with his disposals, and the team needs him to finish off by scoring goals when he has easy shots.
Jesse Hogan is another mystery. With Melbourne, his great stamina gave him license to wander out of the forward line. But the Dockers will need him to be one of two focal points closer to the goal square. He has recognised issues that will not be easy to overcome. The football world should be encouraging and supporting him.
Fremantle’s depth is far from significant when it comes to making an assault on the eight.
Depth and consistency will hurt most clubs this year because there are not enough great players to fill all the ranks, so an ounce of luck injury-wise will be needed.
Of the six sides I have mentioned I have the most faith in North Melbourne making the eight, because of its consistency.
Sunday is a big day, but for three sides, Monday will be even bigger.
AFL’s round 1-16 Thursday night blockbusters revealed
The AFL has answered the calls of footy fans by scheduling Thursday night football in almost every round for 2025. See which games are scheduled for the first 16 rounds.
Cats v Dogs: Smith to face former side in blockbuster clash
Geelong is set for more big games in 2025, and one of them is a bumper match-up between Bailey Smith and the Western Bulldogs.