AFL Finals 2016: our experts look into the crystal ball to see how September will play out
PATRICK Dangerfield a near unanimous Brownlow pick and the premiership race down to three. We look into the crystal ball to see how September (and one day in October) will play out.
Expert Opinion
Don't miss out on the headlines from Expert Opinion. Followed categories will be added to My News.
BRING on the finals.
Our experts have looked into the crystal ball and had a crack at how September (and one day in October) will play out.
Patrick Dangerfield is an almost unanimous Brownlow Medal pick while the premiership race looks to be a race in three with Sydney, Geelong and Hawthorn the popular picks.
Check out our predictions and have your say.
MARK ROBINSON
PREMIER: Sydney
There’s not a team in better nick than the Swans and if they can hold that form they will be difficult to beat. Home finals help. So do Franklin, Hannebery, Kennedy, Parker, Heeney ... the the list is very impressive.
RUNNER-UP: Hawthorn
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Lance Franklin (Sydney)
MR SEPTEMBER: Lance Franklin (Sydney)
SPRING SURPRISE: Steve Johnson (GWS)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
RISING STAR: Caleb Daniel (W.Bulldogs)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Scott Pendlebury (Collingwood)
CRYSTAL FORM (from pre-season predictions)
PRE-SEASON TICK - Geelong top four
PRE-SEASON CROSS - Collingwood eighth
DERMOTT BRERETON
PREMIER: Hawthorn
The Hawks have come back to the field a bit this season. And the field has come up to them and caught them but the field still hasn’t definitively overtaken them. In the final broad-stroke analysis, no one plays the MCG better than the Hawks.
RUNNER-UP: Sydney
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Sam Mitchell (Hawthorn)
MR SEPTEMBER: Cyril Rioli (Hawthorn)
SPRING SURPRISE: Charlie Cameron (Adelaide)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
RISING STAR: Christian Petracca (Melbourne)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
CRYSTAL FORM
TICK - GWS to make first finals series
CROSS - Port Adelaide, Fremantle and Richmond in the eight
JONATHAN BROWN
PREMIER: Adelaide
The Crows are flying. Too good in too many areas and blessed with multiple goalkicking options. The backline was a worry earlier in the year but has improved significantly. Rory Sloane attacks the best opposition midfielder each week and consistently comes out on top.
RUNNER-UP: Sydney
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Rory Sloane (Adelaide)
MR SEPTEMBER: Taylor Walker (Adelaide)
SPRING SURPRISE: Charlie Cameron (Adelaide)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
RISING STAR: Callum Mills (Sydney)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Joel Selwood (Geelong)
CRYSTAL FORM
TICK - Essendon spoon
CROSS - Port Adelaide fourth
DAVID KING
PREMIER: Geelong
History teaches us that the top two from the home-and-away season generally make the Grand Final. Both healthy, in great form and have genuine star factor. The experience and composure of the Cats’ back six will prove the difference. It will be “Dangerfield Week”. Brownlow Medal, premiership and Norm Smith Medal.
RUNNER-UP: Sydney
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
MR SEPTEMBER: Corey Enright (Geelong)
SPRING SURPRISE: Sam Naismith (Sydney)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
RISING STAR: Callum Mills (Sydney)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Lance Franklin (Sydney)
CRYSTAL FORM
TICK - GWS making first finals series
CROSS - Fremantle premier
PATRICK DANGERFIELD
PREMIER: Geelong
RUNNER-UP: Sydney
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Joel Selwood (Geelong)
MR SEPTEMBER: Joel Selwood (Geelong)
SPRING SURPRISE: Sam Menegola (Geelong)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Luke Parker (Sydney)
RISING STAR: Caleb Daniel (W.Bulldogs)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Josh Kennedy (West Coast)
SHANE CRAWFORD
PREMIER: Hawthorn
Everything Hawthorn has done this year has been about peaking at the right time. That time is now, and Clarko’s men are well placed to make it four in a row. They need everything to go right from here, but if they get to the big dance, look out.
RUNNER-UP: Geelong
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Jack Gunston (Hawthorn)
MR SEPTEMBER: Josh Kelly (GWS)
SPRING SURPRISE: Aliir Aliir (Sydney)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
RISING STAR: Callum Mills (Sydney)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Eddie Betts (Adelaide)
CRYSTAL FORM
TICK - Hawthorn to win the flag. Still confident that will happen
CROSS - Fremantle minor premier, Harley Bennell the Brownlow Medal
JON RALPH
PREMIER: Geelong
My pre-season pick and I can’t find a good reason to go elsewhere. Imagine a week that starts with Patrick Dangerfield’s Brownlow Medal speech and finishes with him being handed the Norm Smith and a premiership medal.
RUNNER-UP: Sydney
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
MR SEPTEMBER: Luke Parker (Sydney)
SPRING SURPRISE: Steve Johnson (GWS)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
RISING STAR: Jacob Weitering (Carlton)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
CRYSTAL FORM
TICK - Six of eight finalists
CROSS - Richmond sixth, Carlton wooden spoon
MICHAEL WARNER
PREMIER: Sydney
Lance Franklin’s nine-year, $10 million deal was worth every cent and Sydney’s pay-day comes Grand Final day. Deepest midfield, scoring power and the game’s No.1 ranked defence.
RUNNER-UP: Adelaide
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Dan Hannebery (Sydney)
MR SEPTEMBER: Lance Franklin (Sydney)
SPRING SURPRISE: Aliir Aliir (Sydney)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Dustin Martin (Richmond)
RISING STAR: Caleb Daniel (W.Bulldogs)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
CRYSTAL FORM
TICK - Geelong top two
CROSS - Richmond. Enough said
JAY CLARK
PREMIER: Geelong
As much as we bang on about ‘‘Dangerwood’’, Harry Taylor holds the key. He is just about unbeatable in the air at the moment and can stop Lance Franklin on the biggest day. Harry can next month stamp himself as perhaps the third greatest key defender of the modern era (behind Matthew Scarlett and Josh Gibson). Some cognac, anyone?
RUNNER-UP: Sydney
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Harry Taylor (Geelong)
MR SEPTEMBER: Joel Selwood (Geelong)
SPRING SURPRISE: Sam Menegola (Geelong)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
RISING STAR: Callum Mills (Sydney)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Scott Pendlebury (Collingwood)
CRYSTAL FORM
TICK — Geelong second
CROSS — Fremantle fifth
SAM EDMUND
PREMIER: Sydney.
In form, healthy and settled at the right time, which history says is at least half the battle. Home finals have to help. Also boast the biggest collection of contested-ball bulls, and they only get bigger and stronger in the cut and thrust of finals football.
RUNNER-UP: Geelong
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Luke Parker (Sydney)
MR SEPTEMBER: Lance Franklin (Sydney)
SPRING SURPRISE: Aliir Aliir (Sydney)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong). If not, there should be a national inquiry.
RISING STAR: Callum Mills (Sydney)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
CRYSTAL FORM
TICK - Six of eight finalists
CROSS - Fremantle third
SAM LANDSBERGER
PREMIER: Geelong
The Cats’ 8-2 record against fellow finalists looks ominous, they won’t have to budge from the MCG and they are still flush with seasoned finals stars.
RUNNER-UP: Sydney
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Harry Taylor (Geelong)
MR SEPTEMBER: Cyril Rioli (Hawthorn)
SPRING SURPRISE: Jack Fitzpatrick (Hawthorn)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Marcus Bontempelli (W.Bulldogs)
RISING STAR: Caleb Daniel (W.Bulldogs)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
CRYSTAL FORM
TICK - Marcus Bontempelli Brownlow, hopefully
CROSS - Fremantle seventh
GLENN McFARLANE
PREMIER: Sydney
Been on Hawthorn all the way through, but switching to Sydney - just. The Swans are the in-form team going in. Would be a cracking contest if the Swans and Hawks meet in the big one.
RUNNER-UP: Hawthorn
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Lance Franklin (Sydney)
MR SEPTEMBER: Dan Hannebery (Sydney)
SPRING SURPRISE: Callum Mills (Sydney)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
RISING STAR: Callum Mills (Sydney)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
CRYSTAL FORM
TICK - Dangerfield to win the Brownlow. Get in the queue
CROSS - Fremantle and Collingwood in the eight
SCOTT GULLAN
PREMIER - Geelong
Recruited the right players to have another tilt with stars still around who know how to win the big one.
RUNNER-UP: Hawthorn
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Steven Motlop (Geelong)
MR SEPTEMBER: Jake Stringer (W.Bulldogs)
SPRING SURPRISE: Nakia Cockatoo (Geelong)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
RISING STAR: Caleb Daniel (W.Bulldogs)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Joel Selwood (Geelong)
CRYSTAL FORM
TICK - Patrick Dangerfield Brownlow
CROSS - Richmond top eight
GRANT BAKER
PREMIER: Sydney
The Swans are a good chance to play their first two finals in Sydney. They are the top eight side least affected by injuries. And they are pretty good.
RUNNER UP: Adelaide
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Josh Kennedy (Sydney)
MR SEPTEMBER: Lance Franklin (Sydney)
SPRING SURPRISE: Jake Stringer (W.Bulldogs)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
RISING STAR: Caleb Daniel (W.Bulldogs)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
CRYSTAL FORM
TICK - Left Fremantle out of my eight
CROSS - ... and Sydney.
LAUREN WOOD
PREMIER: Sydney
The form team all year and we know the Swans know how to get it done in September. Kurt Tippett is back and Buddy is ready to fire. Any defence they face will have to look out.
RUNNER-UP: Hawthorn
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Luke Parker (Sydney)
MR SEPTEMBER: Lance Franklin (Sydney)
SPRING SURPRISE: Aliir Aliir (Sydney)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
RISING STAR: Callum Mills (Sydney)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
CRYSTAL FORM
TICK - Hawthorn right up there again
CROSS - Richmond in the eight.
REBECCA WILLIAMS
PREMIER: Sydney
Minor premiership and strong lead-in form into September with stars on fire. Best-placed side to end the Hawthorn streak.
RUNNER-UP: Hawthorn
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Josh Kennedy (Sydney)
MR SEPTEMBER: Lance Franklin (Sydney)
SPRING SURPRISE: James Sicily (Hawthorn)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
RISING STAR: Caleb Daniel (W.Bulldogs)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Joel Selwood (Geelong)
CRYSTAL FORM
TICK - Geelong finishing top four
CROSS - Richmond making finals
ELIZA SEWELL
PREMIER: Sydney
With Lance leading the way, Kurt Tippett back and that incomparable midfield, the Swans are at the height of their powers. A solid backline has become impenetrable with the elevation of Dane Rampe to the absolute top rank, Gary Rohan gives the hyper-speed X-factor and I really like what “Gentleman” George Hewett brings.
RUNNER-UP: Geelong
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Lance Franklin (Sydney)
MR SEPTEMBER: Lance Franklin (Sydney)
SPRING SURPRISE: Sam Menegola (Geelong)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
RISING STAR: Callum Mills (Sydney)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
CRYSTAL FORM
TICK - Dangerfield’s Brownlow. C’mon, he’s over the line
CROSS - Fremantle, Collingwood and Richmond all in the eight
GILBERT GARDINER
PREMIER: Sydney
Adelaide ticks a lot of boxes but it’s impossible to ignore Sydney’s form, versatility and strength on every line. The Swans boast the Mariana Trench of midfields, while the backline is almost impossible to score against. As for scoring, they’ve got that in spades behind superstar Lance Franklin and goalkicking smalls Isaac Heeney, Gary Rohan and Ben McGlynn.
RUNNER-UP: Adelaide
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Luke Parker (Sydney)
MR SEPTEMBER: Taylor Walker (Adelaide)
SPRING SURPRISE: Charlie Cameron (Adelaide)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
RISING STAR: Callum Mills (Sydney)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
LEO SCHLINK
PREMIER: Sydney.
A team for almost every contingency — wet, dry, interstate or at home — the Swans’ stellar season has been built on discipline, workrate and class. Armed with lethal talent on every line, they are the benchmark and the team to beat.
RUNNER UP: Hawthorn
NORM SMITH MEDAL: Luke Parker (Sydney)
MR SEPTEMBER: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
SPRING SURPRISE: Aliir Aliir (Sydney)
BROWNLOW MEDALLIST: Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong)
RISING STAR: Callum Mills (Sydney)
ALL-AUSTRALIAN CAPTAIN: Kieren Jack (Sydney)