Brisbane move to equal top spot after hanging on to defeat Melbourne
The Demons were charging home, only for a score review stoppage to halt their run down an open wing. Did it ultimately cost the club an upset win against the Lions? Coach Simon Goodwin has weighed in.
AFL
Don't miss out on the headlines from AFL. Followed categories will be added to My News.
Brisbane has reaffirmed its premiership credentials and moved to equal top spot on the ladder with a hard-fought four-point win over Melbourne at Metricon Stadium on Sunday night.
The Lions looked to have the game sewn up at the last change until the Demons booted the only three majors the last term, and when Jake Melksham banged through his third late in the quarter he cut the margin to two points.
They didn’t get any closer, however, and will be disappointed with the amount of gettable set shots they missed throughout the night.
Brisbane earned a vital four points with the 7.11 (53) to 7.7 (49) win.
Lachie Neale was at his prolific best after being allowed to roam as he pleased, with Jarryd Lyons, Hugh McCluggage and Dayne Zorko all causing problems for the Demons.
Star Dees ruckman Max Gawn dominated Lions Archie Smith and Oscar McInerney in the air, and Jack Viney, Christian Petracca and Clayton Oliver had their moments, but weren’t as influential on the contest as their opponents.
If in doubt, handball to Jake Melksham 💯#AFLDeesLions pic.twitter.com/4FsPL0HSCL
— AFL (@AFL) July 26, 2020
DID SCORE REVIEW STOPPAGE COST DEES?
Melbourne coach Simon Goodwin has questioned the use of the score review system after his side’s four-point loss to Brisbane on Sunday night.
The Demons kicked the only three goals of the final term to reduce the deficit to single figures when defender Jake Lever took a mark on the goal line and played on, before the goal umpire asked for the grab to be checked.
The ball was brought back to the goal line after the review, which robbed the Dees of a golden opportunity to try and produce a counter-attack to kick the match-winner at the opposite end.
While at pains to point out that the call didn’t cost his team the game, Goodwin said post-match that the system is far from perfect.
“I’m not quite sure how the score review works,” he said.
“We’ve got this fancy ‘ARC’ system, but it halted (our) momentum in the game and I don’t think that’s what it was brought in for.
“Clearly we were out and had an opportunity (to clear the defensive half).
“It’s not why we lost but it certainly didn’t help and hopefully we’ll get the ‘ARC’ system (working) better.
“It’s nice and fancy but it’s not doing much.”
Godwin was also disappointed in his own players in the final stages.
Young forward Bailey Fritsch gave away a 50m penalty for not giving the ball back to the Lions quick enough with less than two minutes to play with the ball in the Demons’ forward half.
“We speak about discipline all the time, it’s about doing the right thing at the right time, all the time,” Goodwin said.
“Good teams are disciplined and we’re constantly educating our players and making sure our behaviours are in check.”
COMEBACK DEMON HAS AN UNHAPPY HOMECOMING
Harley Bennell has been on a footy rollercoaster since he was Gold Coast’s second ever draft pick in 2010.
It’s been that long, some might even forget he was a Sun.
The gifted yet injury-prone midfielder’s last game at Metricon Stadium came in the Suns’ 37-point loss to Port Adelaide back in round 22, 2015, and his return as a Demon wasn’t fun either.
Bennell didn’t give the stats keepers much to do after starting on the interchange bench and blew a golden chance to hit the scoreboard late in the third quarter to get his team to within eight points.
Charlie Cameron did what Bennell couldn’t less than a minute later to make matters worse.
Kayo is your ticket to the 2020 Toyota AFL Premiership Season. Watch every match of every round Live & On-Demand. New to Kayo? Get your 14-day free trial & start streaming instantly >
LIONS TURNED SHARKS FOR GAWN
With Stefan Martin (back) missing for the Lions, Melbourne looked to have a clear advantage going in, and big Maxy relished the battle against his far less experienced opponents.
McInerney’s brain fade in the opening minutes of the second term didn’t help his side, when a silly 50 penalty allowed Gawn to find Bailey Fritsch for his second major of the night.
The Dees couldn’t capitalise on Gawn’s immense presence at stoppages and around the ground however, and it was Brisbane’s ground level stars who were more damaging.
Melbourne’s hitout numbers (44-18) looked good on paper, but the Lions’ were outstanding at the clearances (35-22) and it was a major factor in the result.
RAYNER THE ROCKET WILL RUE HIS SLIPPERY MITS
If the loss wasn’t bad enough for Gawn, he was used as a stepladder by Cam Rayner midway through the second quarter.
The young Lion launched himself into orbit thanks to the use of a knee fair and square in the back of Gawn’s head, and the big man took a while to get up.
Unfortunately for Rayner, he couldn’t hold onto what would have been a clear mark-of-the-year winner.
We don’t blame him, from that height it was a long way down.
When the nominations are released on Monday and he thinks about the serious hanger that got away, Cam will be a disappointed kid.
Was this the mark of the year that never happened? 👀#AFLDeesLions pic.twitter.com/3nzXOs9lbG
— AFL (@AFL) July 26, 2020
NO NEALE HARD TAG
Simon Goodwin decided against a minder for Brisbane ball-magnet Neale and at quarter-time, he might have been seriously rethinking that call after the Lion started with nine touches and two centre clearances.
Viney paid attention to Neale for most of the night and found his fair share of the Sherrin for the Dees, but his opponent’s impact negated much of his hardness around the contest.
In fairness to Goodwin, the Lions have multiple on-ballers in prestige form, so it must have been a tough decision when he contemplated whether or not to send someone to Neale, Zorko, or McCluggage.
In the end he backed his own midfielders, and although Petracca, Oliver and Viney were fine contributors, they lowered their colours.
Neale finished with a game-high 33 disposals.
MELBOURNE 2.2 3.3 4.6 7.7 (49)
BRISBANE 2.2 5.5 7.6 7.11 (53)
GOALS
Melbourne: Melksham 3, Fritsch 2, Viney, Jones
Brisbane: Cameron 2, Bailey, Hipwood, McCarthy, Rayner, Zorko
BEST:
Melbourne: Oliver, Gawn, Viney, Petracca, Melksham, May
Brisbane: Neale, Lyons, Zorko, McCluggage, J. Berry, Bailey
INJURIES:
Melbourne: Nil
Brisbane: Daniel Rich (hamstring)
REPORTS: Nil
Votes
3. Lachie Neale (Brisbane)
2. Clayton Oliver (Melbourne)
1. Jarryd Lyons (Brisbane)
INJURIES
Melbourne: TBC
Brisbane: Rich (hamstring)
MORE AFL NEWS:
AFL Rich 100: Who are the AFL’s highest-earning stars? See the players ranked 1-100
The Tackle: Mark Robinson’s likes and dislikes from a jam-packed Round 8
Clayton Oliver cops fine for striking, Tom Hawkins overturns suspension at AFL tribunal