NewsBite

Playing with fire: Australia asked to join patrol in South China Sea

AUSTRALIA’s role in the South China Sea has been brought starkly into focus with Indonesia’s call for joint military patrols even as Beijing’s warships exercised off the coast of WA.

Indonesian President Joko Widodo has announced he will raise the “very important” prospect of joint naval patrols with Australia in the South China Sea during a state visit to Sydney this weekend.

It is his first visit to Australia since being elected in 2014.

But the idea has prompted a warning from former Australian Defence Force chief Sir Angus Houston, who said we should avoid supporting any move to blockade Beijing’s controversial artificial island fortresses being build throughout the strategic Asian waterway.

The ports, airfields, barracks and anti-aircraft defences are being built in defiance of international law in an effort to enforce sovereignty over seas also claimed by Malaysia, Philippines, Vietnam and Indonesia. More than $5 trillion in trade passes through the area each year.

“In terms of the question about freedom of navigation within the 12-mile limit, I don’t think we need to do that, I think that could provoke a military response and I don’t think that would be a good idea,” he told the National Press Club.

His comments followed a call earlier this week by US Admiral of the Pacific Fleet Harry Harris for a stronger response to Beijing’s island-grab.

“(We’ll) co-operate where we can, but we’ll be ready to confront where we must”, he said.

“We’re approaching an inflection point in history ... We’re certainly not approaching anything resembling the end of history.”

HMAS Anzac berthed at the buoy in the Hong Kong harbour as part of a South East Asia deployment. *** Local Caption *** HMAS Anzac and her crew of 191 personnel are deployed to South-East Asia to participate in a number of exercises and activities including Exercise Komodo, Bersama Shield and Indonesian Fleet Review. HMAS Anzac is the first in class of the Anzac Class frigate and is capable of operating in a multi-threat environment. Anzac is fitted with an advance package of air surveillance radars, hull mounted sonar and electronic support systems that interface with state-of-the-art Evolved Sea Sparrow Missiles and Ship Launched Torpedoes. The ship can embark a multi-role Seahawk helicopter to enhance anti-submarine, anti-surface warfare and Search and Rescue capabilities. Embarkation of a helicopter also provides the ship with the capability to deliver air-launches torpedoes. In 2014, Anzac was the third Anzac Class Frigate to complete the Anti-Ship Missile Defence upgrade program, which also provides an enhanced sensor and weapons systems capability. The upgrade showcases Australian design and integration capability, with new Phased Array Radar technology designed by CEA Technologies in Canberra, upgrades to combat systems performed by Saab Systems in South Australia, and platform integration design by BAE Systems in Victoria.

LENGTHENING SHADOW

At stake in this weekend’s talks is Indonesia’s ownership of waters generally regarded as being outside the southern boundaries of the South China Sea.

Indonesian and Chinese vessels clashed repeatedly in waters around the Natunas Islands last year after Beijing asserted it was part of its traditional territory.

DELVE DEEPER: ‘You will suffer more’ - China warns of war

Indonesia considers the islands — and the valuable fishery and natural resources around them — as its own sovereign territory.

“If there is no tension I think it’s very important to have patrols together,” Widodo told The Australian. “We will discuss this with PM Turnbull.”

The request comes shortly after Beijing demonstrated its growing military reach.

The People Liberation Army reported a task force of three ships, including two advanced guided missile destroyers and an underway replenishment ship, passed through Indonesia and into Indian Ocean waters between it and Australia.

EXPLORE MORE: Wargames show China will be a tough fight

The task force conduced military exercises near shipping lanes in Australia’s maritime approaches.

The ships went on to complete similar manoeuvres in the South China Sea shortly before the arrival of a US aircraft carrier battlegroup earlier this week.

A satellite image shows what CSIS Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative says appears to be anti-aircraft guns and what are likely to be close-in weapons systems (CIWS) on the artificial island Fiery Cross Reef in the South China Sea in this image released on December 13, 2016. To match EXCLUSIVE SOUTHCHINASEA-CHINA/ARMS Courtesy CSIS Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative/DigitalGlobe/Handout via REUTERS ATTENTION EDITORS - THIS IMAGE WAS PROVIDED BY A THIRD PARTY. EDITORIAL USE ONLY. NO RESALES. NO ARCHIVE.

RHETORIC RISING

One of the United States top military commanders in the region, Admiral of the Pacific Fleet army Harris, told a conference earlier this week that the Asia-Pacific region faced four challenges to its security:

RAND Corporation wargames produce the above projected outcome for any conflict with China, as its military continues to upgrade and expand, in 2025.
RAND Corporation wargames produce the above projected outcome for any conflict with China, as its military continues to upgrade and expand, in 2025.

North Korea, China, Russia and Islamic State.

On the South China Sea, Admiral Harris said the United States would not let the shared assets and waterways there to be shut down.

Beijing has created seven island fortresses in the Spratly Islands in recent years, built up from islets and reefs. Their claims that these artificial islands represent sovereign territory was ruled illegal by an international court of arbitration last year.

“Freedom, justice and the rules-based international order hang in the balance and the scale won’t tip of its own accord or simply because good people wish it so,” he said.

“They (Beijing) can choose to disregard the rules-based security order that has served all nations — including them — so well for decades or they can contribute to it as responsible stakeholders.

“I hope for the latter, but I have to be prepared for the former.”

Working with allies in the region — including Australia — will help the US “beacon of light” continues to “shine” and allow “good to overcome evil”, he said.

“Our country must maintain credible combat power, in concert with like-minded allies and partners, to preserve unimpeded access to all the shared domains — sea, air, land, space, and cyber,” he said.

170215-N-PP996-197 PACIFIC OCEAN (Feb. 15, 2017) The Arliegh Burke-class guided-missile destroyer USS Michael Murphy (DDG 112) passes by a foreign flagged fishing vessel during an Oceania Maritime Security Initiative (OMSI) boarding mission. The OMSI program is a secretary of defense program leveraging Department of Defense assets transiting the region to increase the Coast Guard's maritime domain awareness, ultimately supporting its maritime law enforcement operations in Oceania. Michael Murphy is on a scheduled western Pacific deployment with the Carl Vinson Carrier Strike Group as part of the U.S. Pacific Fleet-led initiative to extend the command and control functions of U.S. 3rd Fleet. (U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 3rd Class Danny Kelley/Released)

ALL THE WAY ... WITH TRUMP?

“In terms of ... the idea of blockading the islands, I wouldn’t support that,” former defence chief Sir Angus Houston told the National Press Club. “I think that will invite a sharp response from the ­Chinese.”

He has previously said it is already “too late” to stop Beijing from taking ownership of the South China Sea.

But the idea of just such a blockade has reportedly been bandied about in President Trump’s innermost circle of advisers.

Current Secretary of State Rex Tillerson said last year that the US would possibly “stop” China from accessing their artificial islands.

And the idea has gained renewed momentum with news that missile and gun emplacements on Beijing’s South China Sea artificial islands — first spotted in December — are now nearing completion.

According to images published by the Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative, the structures are being installed on Fiery Cross Reef, Mischief Reef and Subi Reef in the Spratly Islands.

“This indicates they are not reactions to the political cycle in Washington, but rather part of a steady pattern of Chinese militarisation,” the Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative think-tank states.

The weapons appear designed to protect extensive military-grade, armoured hangars and airfield installations.

Defence analysts fear it is only a matter of time before a force of fighters, bombers and surveillance aircraft are deployed to the islands to enforce Beijing’s claims over the surrounding waters.

This handout photograph taken and released by the Presidential Palace on October 6, 2016 shows Indonesian President Joko Widodo sitting in the cockpit of Sukhoi Su-30 aircraft during a military drill on the remote Natuna islands. The Indonesian Air Force on October 6 held a major exercise around its island in the South China Sea where there have been clashes with Chinese vessels in waters claimed by Beijing. / AFP PHOTO / PRESIDENTIAL PALACE / AGUS SUPARTO / RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE - MANDATORY CREDIT

FRIENDS IN NEED?

Ties between Indonesia and Australia have been rocky in recent years.

The execution of Australian drug smugglers and Canberra’s policy of turning back asylum seeking boats has resulted in repeated outbursts of heated rhetoric.

But China’s growing ambitions may draw the two neighbours closer together.

Relations took an upswing in 2015 once Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull took office. But it experienced fresh strains last month when Indonesia suspended military co-operation with Australia over allegations of ‘offensive’ training materials being found at an Australian army base.

The idea of a joint patrol, however, is being touted as a demonstration of our closer ties.

“This visit is very important for us because it shows how close we are as neighbours,” Indonesia’s foreign ministry spokesman Arrmanantha Nasir said.

In response, Prime Minister Turnbull said that the “bilateral relationship with Indonesia is vitally important to both countries and has never been stronger”.

President Widodo had originally planned to visit Australia, but civil unrest in Jakarta forced its cancellation.

He will be in Sydney on Saturday and Sunday for the state visit, accompanied by several cabinet ministers. Prime Minister Turnbull will also hold a private dinner with the Indonesian leader and his wife.

170203-N-HD638-487 PACIFIC OCEAN (Feb. 3, 2017) The aircraft carrier USS Carl Vinson (CVN 70), left, participates in a replenishment-at-sea with the dry cargo and ammunition ship USNS Charles Drew (T-AKE 10). The Carl Vinson Carrier Strike Group is on a western Pacific deployment as part of the U.S. Pacific Fleet-led initiative to extend the command and control functions of U.S. 3rd Fleet. (U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 3rd Class Matt Brown/Released)

Add your comment to this story

To join the conversation, please Don't have an account? Register

Join the conversation, you are commenting as Logout

Original URL: https://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/special-features/in-depth/playing-with-fire-australia-asked-to-join-indonesia-patrol/news-story/986e51a21b30a8af16d4a6d5a7c91ded