NewsBite

Plea for royal commission after veteran son takes his own life

Eight resolutions from The Daily Telegraph’s Save Our Heroes Summit will be put to the federal Veterans’ Minister as pressure mounts on Scott Morrison to call a royal commission into the veteran suicide crisis after NSW backed an inquiry on Wednesday. READ THE RESOLUTIONS

A royal commission into veteran suicide 'should have already been called'

The NSW government has thrown its support behind growing calls for a royal commission into the veteran suicide crisis after six grieving mothers of dead ­heroes pressed the Prime Minister to call the inquiry in Canberra on Wednesday.

Acting NSW Veterans’ ­Affairs Minister Geoff Lee told The Daily ­Telegraph’s Save Our Heroes Summit in Parliament House on Wednesday: “The system is ­broken. The NSW government is committed to supporting this call for a royal commission. Clearly we must do better.”

His call was echoed by Australia’s most decorated hero Ben Roberts-Smith who told the gathering: “It’s been a long time coming. It is something that is needed.”

L-R: Glenda Weston, Colleen Pillen, Jan Hewitt, Ben Roberts-Smith, Julie-Ann Finney and Nikki Jamieson. Picture: Toby Zerna
L-R: Glenda Weston, Colleen Pillen, Jan Hewitt, Ben Roberts-Smith, Julie-Ann Finney and Nikki Jamieson. Picture: Toby Zerna

The Daily Telegraph Save Our Heroes Summit was called to give voice to six courageous mothers whose sons took their own lives after leaving the Defence Force.

They also met with Prime Minister Scott Morrison for more than an hour to tell of their loss — a grief that has been shared by more than 500 families of other Diggers who have killed themselves since 2001.

Prime Minister Scott Morrison holds a meeting with the six mothers who told of the horrendous treatment of their veteran sons. L-R: Jan Hewitt, Karen Bird, Nikki Jamieson, Scott Morrison, Colleen Pillen, Glenda Weston and Julie-Ann Finney meet with Prime Minister Scott Morrison on Wednesday<s1/> <s1>. Picture: Adam Taylor</s1>
Prime Minister Scott Morrison holds a meeting with the six mothers who told of the horrendous treatment of their veteran sons. L-R: Jan Hewitt, Karen Bird, Nikki Jamieson, Scott Morrison, Colleen Pillen, Glenda Weston and Julie-Ann Finney meet with Prime Minister Scott Morrison on Wednesday . Picture: Adam Taylor

Julie-Ann Finney, who has collected 250,000 signatures calling for a Royal Commission since her Navy poster-boy son Dave took his own life in February, said the Prime Minister told her he “has not ruled out a Royal ­Commission”.

She welcomed the NSW Government’s backing and said: “I am really glad they are going to support a Royal Commission and ack­nowledge that more needs to be done.”

An emotional Ms Finney said she did not want another mother to have to suffer what she had after her son called for help.

Julie-Ann Finney understandably became emotional talking about her hero son. Picture: Jonathan Ng
Julie-Ann Finney understandably became emotional talking about her hero son. Picture: Jonathan Ng

The response from the Australian Defence Force was “we will ruin your career and we will get rid of you,” she said.

“They signed up to serve our country,” she said.

“The Australian Defence Force has taken Australia’s bravest. They were not broken people.”

Dave Finney supported other ‘brothers’ who were suffering from PTSD after returning from combat.
Dave Finney supported other ‘brothers’ who were suffering from PTSD after returning from combat.
Ms Finney has pushed for an inquiry since her son Dave Finney took his life in February this year. Picture: Jonathan Ng
Ms Finney has pushed for an inquiry since her son Dave Finney took his life in February this year. Picture: Jonathan Ng

But mother Glenda Weston said their sons came home broken.

Her son private Bradley Carr took his own life on Anzac Day. “It was not a ­coincidence he chose that day.

“He went away to fight a war and he was still fighting it in his head when he came home.”

She was joined in her grief by Nikki Jamieson, the ­mother of private Daniel Garforth, Colleen Pillen, mother of private Michael Powers and Jan Hewitt, mother of private Brock Hewitt.

Nikki Jamieson, mother of Daniel Garforth, at the summit on Wednesday. Picture: Jonathan Ng
Nikki Jamieson, mother of Daniel Garforth, at the summit on Wednesday. Picture: Jonathan Ng
Daniel Garforth with his mum in 2013. He took his life, aged 21, in 2014.
Daniel Garforth with his mum in 2013. He took his life, aged 21, in 2014.
Colleen Pillen, mother of Michael Powers, and Jan Hewitt, mother of Brock Hewitt at the summit. Picture: Jonathan Ng
Colleen Pillen, mother of Michael Powers, and Jan Hewitt, mother of Brock Hewitt at the summit. Picture: Jonathan Ng

MORE FROM THE SUMMIT

Louise Roberts: Why we must listen to the mothers of dead soldiers

Soldier forced to march while on suicide watch, summit told

GALLYER: FACES OF THE FORGOTTEN

Ms Hewitt, whose son Brock died this year, said: “We are here being the voices of our sons because they are not here.”

Former Major General and ex-senator Jim Molan said: “If we are going to fix this problem we have got to know the facts.

“If there is time to strike, the time to strike is now.”

Colleen Pillen’s son, Michael John Powers took his life in 2017, aged 29.
Colleen Pillen’s son, Michael John Powers took his life in 2017, aged 29.
Ms Hewitt with her son Brock who died this year.
Ms Hewitt with her son Brock who died this year.

Keynote speaker James Brown, former NSW RSL President, agreed and sent a message to the PM: “The ­opportunity is now, you’ve never had so much support behind you to fix this system.”  

He said what was required was strong, decisive leadership and a Royal Commission.

Mr Brown thanked Mr Morrison for meeting the mothers.

“Now we need your strong and sustained leadership on this issue for the rest of your Prime Ministership,” he said.

“Australia’s living veterans need your help.

“Stay home from that next overseas commemoration service you get invited to.

“The veterans you need to hear from are in Holsworthy, not Hamel. If you want to connect with the veteran’s community don’t fly to the Western Front, drive to Western Sydney.”

Ben Roberts-Smith VC MG, Victoria Cross recipient and James Brown retired captain and Afghanistan and Iraq veteran at The Daily Telegraph’s Save Our Heroes Summit. Picture: Jonathan Ng
Ben Roberts-Smith VC MG, Victoria Cross recipient and James Brown retired captain and Afghanistan and Iraq veteran at The Daily Telegraph’s Save Our Heroes Summit. Picture: Jonathan Ng

Resolutions from the ­summit, which will be put to federal Veterans Affair Minister Darren Chester, included an overhaul of complicated benefits schemes and an end to the cruel practice of ­unleashing lawyers on vulnerable veterans.

PRESSURE MOUNTS ON PRIME MINISTER

Addressing the summit on Wednesday, former army officer James Brown also said it was high time for the federal government to take the helm on veteran suicide.

“The veteran sector is crying out for strong and sustained national leadership. A lack of leadership is at the heart of everything we’re talking about today.”

Ben Roberts-Smith, Australia’s most decorated veteran applauded the state’s pledge but said a formal announcement was critical.

“I think it’s fantastic. It’s a long time coming, it is something that has needed support from the state governments to get the federal government to finally act on it. The issue needs to be dealt with. We need a royal commission to find out what is going on.”

Victoria Cross recipient and Afghanistan veteran Ben Roberts-Smith pictured with the mothers of the young veterans who have taken their own life since serving for our country. L-R Jan Hewitt, Glenda Weston, Julie-Ann Finney, Colleen Pillen and Nikki Jamieson. Picture: Toby Zerna
Victoria Cross recipient and Afghanistan veteran Ben Roberts-Smith pictured with the mothers of the young veterans who have taken their own life since serving for our country. L-R Jan Hewitt, Glenda Weston, Julie-Ann Finney, Colleen Pillen and Nikki Jamieson. Picture: Toby Zerna

Julie Anne Finney called on the Prime Minister to take real action.

“I’m really glad they’re going to support the royal commission and have acknowledged that more needs to be done. It’s awesome but now I hope the federal government is going to follow suit.”

From left moderator Sharri Markson with Glenda Weston, mother of Bradley Carr, Julie-Ann Finney, mother of Dave Finney, Nikki Jamieson, mother of Daniel Garforth, Colleen Pillen, mother of Michael Powers and Jan Hewitt, mother of Brock Hewitt at The Daily Telegraph’s Save Our Heroes Summit. Picture: Jonathan Ng
From left moderator Sharri Markson with Glenda Weston, mother of Bradley Carr, Julie-Ann Finney, mother of Dave Finney, Nikki Jamieson, mother of Daniel Garforth, Colleen Pillen, mother of Michael Powers and Jan Hewitt, mother of Brock Hewitt at The Daily Telegraph’s Save Our Heroes Summit. Picture: Jonathan Ng

RELATED NEWS

Minister backs Save Our Heroes Summit

‘It’s vital’: Veteran backs Save Our Heroes Summit

VC heroes want action on veteran suicide

Karen Bird, whose son, Afghanistan veteran Jesse Bird, died two years ago, broke and consumed by “a loss of hope”, said the help he should have been afforded was withheld from him.

The 32-year-old had pleaded with the Department of Veterans’ Affairs for ­financial assistance and five days later he took his own life surrounded by paperwork from the DVA notifying him his claim for permanent impairment, which he had been fighting for two years, had been rejected.

Veteran Jesse Bird. Picture: Supplied
Veteran Jesse Bird. Picture: Supplied
Jesse Bird, while in combat in Afghanistan in 2009.
Jesse Bird, while in combat in Afghanistan in 2009.

He had warned the department he was suicidal and under severe financial stress. Ten days after he died, the department transferred $4551 to Mr Bird’s account.

Ms Bird has thrown her support behind the Telegraph’s Save Our Heroes­ summit at NSW Parliament House.

“The purposefully complex claims process drained Jesse of any hope of help and a better future,” she said.

Karen and John Bird are the parents of former soldier Jesse Bird who died by suicide after serving in Afghanistan. Picture: Aaron Francis
Karen and John Bird are the parents of former soldier Jesse Bird who died by suicide after serving in Afghanistan. Picture: Aaron Francis

“There must be a complete overall of the needlessly complex legislative framework that currently hampers the streamlining of veteran entitlements and impedes DVA from acting responsibly in their duty of care towards veterans and their families — with particular attention to be given to those who are the most vulnerable frontline combat personnel.”

At the heart of Mr Bird’s case was the department’s rule that accepted mental health conditions had to be ­“permanent and stable” before compensation would be granted.

Medical assessments had deemed that Mr Bird’s conditions did not meet this threshold.

Ms Bird said she was deeply troubled by Defence and the DVA’s responses to an ongoing inquest in Victoria into her son’s death.

“The unbridled use of public money to defend and protect the brands of the ADF/DVA equates to an abuse of power,” she said.

Funeral of Jesse Bird. Jesse was a former soldier and tragically took his own life in 2017. Picture: Jake Nowakowski
Funeral of Jesse Bird. Jesse was a former soldier and tragically took his own life in 2017. Picture: Jake Nowakowski

She has called for Defence and DVA to work together in a way which has eluded the two organisations but has been recommended by various reviews.

“If they don’t, as they haven’t this century, the end result is what we have today — and the human cost is growing,” Ms Bird said.

The summit will give a voice to five bereaved mothers who have called for a royal commission into more than 500 military suicides.

Virgin Australia is flying the veterans’ mothers to Sydney while the AHA will provide their accommodation.

Lifeline 13 11 14

Originally published as Plea for royal commission after veteran son takes his own life

Add your comment to this story

To join the conversation, please Don't have an account? Register

Join the conversation, you are commenting as Logout

Original URL: https://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/plea-for-royal-commission-after-veteran-son-takes-his-own-life/news-story/ccbb65a9d411ec5393d0b4d53415e1b0