Best of the best: we name the top 150 players in metro local footy
The local footy season came to an early finish this year but there was no shortage of star players. We name the best of the best from 2021, with the top 40 ranked.
Local Footy
Don't miss out on the headlines from Local Footy. Followed categories will be added to My News.
The local football season came to a premature end but at least we got back on the park after the wipe-out of 2020.
There were plenty of superb performers across the metropolitan leagues.
And we’re celebrating them with the top 150 local players of 2021.
Local Footy’s scribes have picked the very best from Southern, Eastern, Northern, Essendon District, Riddell District, Western Region and VAFA – excluding VFL-listed players.
We’ve narrowed it down to a top 40 for the season with the remaining 110 in alphabetical order.
SEASON 2021’s BEST PLAYERS 31-150
Kane Barbuto, Keilor
The reigning Reynolds Medal winner continues to produce outstanding performances week after week. Remains a key cog in the Keilor machine that finished equal on top of the EDFL Premier Division ladder this season but second on percentage behind Strathmore. Clearly a favourite among the umpires, can he make it back-to-back league B & Fs?
Chris Barton, Kilmore
Was leading the NFL Division 3 Coaches’ MVP voting when it was taken behind closed doors after Round 13. The hard-nosed midfielder is also dangerous forward of the ball, kicking 19 goals in 12 matches.
Dylan Belo, East Ringwood
A fierce, relentless competitor, Belo added another team-of-the-year honour to the CV this year, slotting in at fullback. Has etched his name as one of Division 1’s top defenders in the Eastern league, backing up a 2019 season where he finished runner-up for the ‘Roos’ top honour.
James Belo, East Ringwood
Another big year from the classy ex-Coburg midfielder with a team-of-the-year gong, named on the ball. On a run of successive club best and fairest awards and in contention for another this season, following seven appearances in the best from 11 starts and 22 goals.
Josh Bench, Altona
Added class to the Vikings’ midfield this season after making the move from Albion, helping his new club to the top of the table. Spent three seasons on Williamstown’s VFL list, is an interleague and Vic Metro representative, and claimed the Western Jets’ best and fairest in 2012.
Rohan Bewick, Old Xaverians
Has brilliance bursting out of his boots and it was all on show in Round 1 of the season when he slotted 10 goals against St Bernard’s. Unfortunately injuries kept the left-footer to only four more games. Bewick played 103 AFL matches for Brisbane from 2011-2018. He’s a matchwinner at local level.
Reuben Blackmore-Moore, Banyule
All class in the Bears’ engine room, Blackmore-Moore kicked 10 goals in 12 appearances and earned seven mentions in the best. Stood tall in the big games with best-on-ground performances against flag rivals Diamond Creek and Eltham.
Nathan Blair, Romsey
The former VFL midfielder continues to light up the RDFL. Blair played nine of Romsey’s 10 matches in 2021 and was named in the best in seven of them, including best-ons against Melton Centrals (twice) and Diggers Rest. Averaged a goal a game as well.
Steven Boyall, Wallan
After winning an EDFL premiership with Craigieburn in 2019, Boyall slipped seamlessly into Wallan’s midfield this season. Only played eight of 10 games but was named in the best in seven of them.
Stephen Brewer, Caroline Springs
Still tearing it up in the midfield for the Lakers at 37 in the WRFL’s Division 1, after 260 senior games across multiple competitions – including a flag with Port Melbourne. Stood out this year, too, finishing third in the WRFL’s MVP, as voted on by the coaches.
Tom Brindley, Greensborough
Started the season with a rush and was leading the Coaches’ MVP voting after seven rounds. The 20-year-old has played forward, back, midfield and even pinch-hit in the ruck and is sure to be on several VFL clubs’ radars for 2022. If he can put on a bit of muscle will be extremely hard to stop in the future.
Ashlin Brown, Hoppers Crossing
The Warriors skipper produced another solid season, catching the eye of WRFL Division 1 coaches with 10 votes in the MVP. Has long been a dominant force in the competition with three consecutive team of the year gongs and in the frame again this year, one would think.
Matt Burkett, Romsey
Mr Consistency, Burkett played nine matches, kicked at least one goal in eight and was named in the best in seven, including best-on-ground performances against Wallan, Woodend-Hesket and Western Rams.
Danko Bzenic, Avondale Heights
The former Coburg and Richmond VFL forward starred in his long-awaited return to Avondale Heights. Bzenic booted 21 goals and was picked in the best on seven occasions, including a trio of best-ons against Avondale, Greenvale and Glenroy. A classy mover and a danger no matter where he picks up the ball.
Victor Carboni, Aberfeldie
Has improved in each of his three seasons at senior level and is now firmly entrenched as one of EDFL Premier Division’s very best. Scored a mention in Abers’ best in seven of 11 appearances, second only to the legendary Nick Meese. The pair have formed a tremendous tandem in midfield.
Liam Cavanagh, Strathmore
The key defender hit a purple patch mid-season, named in Strathmore’s best two players in wins over Maribyrnong Park, Greenvale, Pascoe Vale and Avondale Heights and best-on in the three-point loss to Aberfeldie. A remarkable season given Cavanagh doubles as Coburg coach in the South Eastern Women’s league.
Jackson Clarke, West Preston-Lakeside
A brick wall across half-back for West Preston-Lakeside. Clarke marshalls a defence – together with Max Dreher, Nathan Valladares and Ethan Penrith – that gave up just 47 points per game this year, clearly No. 1 in NFL Division 1. Clarke himself was named in the best nine times in 12 matches, equal most in the competition with Jesse Donaldson.
Scott Clarke, Maribyrnong Park
Took on the Marby captaincy this season and enjoyed another impressive season in defence. Expect a second straight Team of the Year nod after being named in the Lions’ best in seven of 11 appearances. Will hope to break through for a club best-and-fairest win as well after consecutive runners-up finishes.
Daniel Cooper, South Croydon
The zippy mid/forward found plenty of the ball in his 10 matches this season, where he featured in the best on seven occasions, along with 10 goals to his name. The former Doncaster Shark capped off a strong year with a team-of-the-year honour, with a spot on the wing.
Jason Cooke, Macedon
The star forward only played the eight games this season but still booted the fourth most goals in the EDFL with 29. Amazingly consistent, Cooke kicked at least three majors in seven appearances and finished the season with a bag of eight against Woodend-Hesket.
Sam Critchley, St Kevin’s
Took over the captaincy of his club this year, another accolade for a decorated player. Among the best intercept defenders in VAFA Premier and he can also be damaging as a forward. Had a stint in the VFL with Williamstown.
Blair Cronin, Oak Park
Returned to Oak Park from Tullamarine and produced an outstanding EDFL Division 2 season to help the Kangaroos claim 10 wins from 11 games and finish second on percentage behind Moonee Valley. Cronin booted 29 goals in his 10 games, including five majors in the stirring last-start win over the Fog.
Luke Davis, Aberfeldie
The three-time premiership skipper led Aberfeldie’s defence with aplomb as it conceded the second fewest points in EDFL Premier Division. Made a bolting start to the season, earning mentions in Abers’ best in the opening five rounds. Was best afield when Abers triumphed against Strathmore in one of the games of the season.
Matt Dea, Uni Blacks
Blacks signed Dea ahead of 2020 but had to wait 12 months to see him run out. The former Tiger and Bomber didn’t disappoint, taking six listings in the best to help his team to a 10-1 record.
Chris Deluca, Port Melbourne Colts
Tough left-footer who was a quality player in the WAFL, figuring in Subiaco’s 2014-15 premierships. Linked with Colts in 2019 and with his left-foot kicking and toughness around the ball he was quick to make his name in Southern, winning the club best and fairest and coming third in the league medal. Took six mentions in the best in nine matches this year.
Matthew Dick, Macedon
Some might say the Bowen Medal favourite, Dick is a dominant force in Macedon’s midfield and a serious goal threat when resting forward. Booted 13 majors, equal second for the Cats, in nine matches.
Luke Duffy, East Malvern
Top-notch midfielder who was a leading Gippsland player before hitting the Southern scene. Kicked eight goals and had 40 possessions against Highett this year.
Chris Deluca, Port Melbourne Colts
Tough left-footer who was a quality player in the WAFL, figuring in Subiaco’s 2014-15 premierships. Linked with Colts in 2019 and with his left-foot kicking and toughness around the ball he was quick to make his name in Southern, winning the club best and fairest and coming third in the league medal. Took six mentions in the best in nine matches this year.
Julian Dobosz, Caulfield Grammarians
The former Tasmanian and VFL player kept backmen busy with 24 goals from 10 matches this season and his best performances came against strong teams Old Xaverians, Old Brighton and Uni Blues. Booted 53 goals in 12 matches to help lift his club to the Premier B flag in 2019.
Lynden Dunn, West Coburg
While it wasn’t enough for West Coburg to break into the EDFL Division 1 top four, Dunn produced a stellar debut season for the Saints. The former Melbourne and Collingwood star kicked at least two goals in nine of 10 matches and usually saved his best for the big teams, kicking six against Westmeadows and four against East Keilor.
Will Edwards, Caulfield Grammarians
Edwards was appointed captain of Grammarians this year and he led the side with strength and style. Fit and hard, the inside midfielder was named in the best seven times this year. Edwards won the best and fairest in the premiership season of 2019.
Michael Ercolano, West Preston-Lakeside
Too much to say 2021 was Ercolano’s best season in red, white and blue? The midfielder was excellent in 2018 but arguably stepped it up a notch in 2021 with six mentions in the best in 12 games, including 10-vote and nine-vote performances late in the year that saw him jump to fourth in the NFL Division 1 Coaches’ MVP voting before it went behind closed doors at the end of Round 13.
Nick Evans, South Croydon
Was among the Bulldogs’ top performers this season where he had no trouble finding the footy, highlighted by 32 touches and 13 rebound-50s in Round 4 against Rowville. Spent time on the wing but was also handy in defence, earning a spot in the Premier Division team of the year.
Alex Federico, West Preston-Lakeside
The young midfielder continues to impress for the two-time reigning NFL Division 1 premiers, seemingly having the ball on a string at times and delivering with pinpoint accuracy. Perhaps not as good as his sensational 2019 – nobody’s perfect – but remains one of the most damaging players in the competition.
Braden Ferrari, Hoppers Crossing
The defender is rated not only at the Warriors, but across the Western Region comp. He’s a three-time league representative, dual Team of the Year rep and also played for Vic Metro in 2016. Spent a season on Werribee’s VFL list in 2015, and finished top-five in the WRFL’s MVP this season after playing all 12 matches. Former Western Jet.
Patrick Fitzgerald, Montmorency
The star forward notched 40 goals – second most in NFL Division 1 – in a shortened year to continue his incredible streak. Fitzgerald has kicked at least 40 goals in eight straight seasons. An incredible feat. He booted bags of five four times, including against heavyweights Greensborough and North Heidelberg, and was goalless just once.
Patrick Flynn, Macleod
In the conversation as the best ruckman in NFL Division 1 and rewarded Macleod was an excellent debut season. Fully recovered from a serious ankle injury that derailed his 2019 with Lower Plenty, Flynn returned to top form this season and was named in the best six times in 12 matches, including best-on in big wins over Greensborough, North Heidelberg and Montmorency.
Josh Freezer, Old Melburnians
There are few better key defenders in local football than the OM captain, who knows when to deny opponents the ball and when to supply it to teammates. Freezer can call on the experience of six years at Essendon VFL, from where he was promoted to play in the NAB Challenge as a top-up. He won the OM best and fairest in 2018 and was the VAFA representative captain a year later.
Dean Galea, Keilor
The strong-marking spearhead is in the veteran class – it’s 10 years since he played in Port Melbourne’s 2011 VFL premiership – but he continues to be a handful for the best backmen. Had 20 goals from six matches this season. He’s piled them high since joining the Essendon District competition.
Josiah Garisto, Avondale Heights
Garisto has been a model of consistency for the Heights this year, impressing as an intercept defender. Named in the best in six of 12 appearances, Garisto saved his best for the EDFL Premier Division’s big guns, starring against Aberfeldie (twice), Pascoe Vale and Maribyrnong Park.
Tom Gleeson, Coburg Districts
Finished second in the EDFL Division 2 goalkicking, five goals behind Hadfield’s Mark Sabatino, but arguably had the better season given the Hawks forward kicked 27 of his goals against Jacana while Gleeson only faced the struggling Jags once. Gleeson’s biggest haul of 11 goals came against finalists East Sunbury.
Josh Grabowski, East Keilor
There’s goalkicking midfielders and then there’s Grabowski. Not many on-ballers are finishing second in the league goalkicking charts but that’s exactly what the Cougars star did this season. Kicked goals in 11 of 12 appearances, including five bags of five or more. A mid-season purple patch saw him kick six in three straight games.
Alex Greenwood, Vermont
The 2021 team of the year member has been a crucial cog in the Eagles’ engine room across two premiership campaigns, and this season was no different as his club finished minor premier. Played all eight games and figured in the best in six of those. One of the comp’s most underrated stars.
Tye Hall, South Morang
A dominant season in midfield having recovered from a ACL injury suffered in the 2019 preliminary final. Hall was a key figure in South Morang’s dominant season that saw them finish minor premier with just one loss for the season.
Kieran Harper, Uni Blues
Harper played 40 AFL games for North Melbourne, and has played many good games since crossing to Blues in 2016 as a goalkicking half forward. Was judged best in the finals series that culminated in the 2019 premiership. He’s a class act.
Sam Hayes, Cheltenham
One of the Southern league’s best defenders, capable of playing on opponents of all shapes and sizes. Happy to defend but also likes to take a bounce and a dash. Tipped to be selected in the Division 1 team of the year.
Dion Hill, East Keilor
The dominant forward in EDFL Division 1 with 56 goals in 12 matches to edge teammate Josh Grabowski. Hill was remarkably consistent booting at least five goals in eight matches, including against premiership rivals Tullamarine and Westmeadows. Booted a season-high seven against Rupertswood.
Tim Jenkins, St Albans
The Saints champion is as revered as any out west, boasting a football CV bursting with personal accolades. Named in the WRFL’s Division 1 team of the year seven times across the past decade to go with three club best and fairests. Consistency comes to mind when describing the midfielder/forward – this season he was named among the best in seven of the 12 games.
Steven Kennedy, Altona
Champion midfielder continued on his merry way on 2021 and is as important as any to the Vikings’ line-up. Named in his side’s best on five occasions of his eight matches this season as Altona finished on top of the ladder. A best and fairest winner across two comps, WRFL and the Ballarat league.
Jason Kenneth, Westmeadows
At just 19 years old, Kenneth has made a seamless transition to senior football. Named in the Tigers’ best in six of his 11 matches, the young ruckman saved arguably his best for last with a best-on-ground performance against Airport West in the final game of the season.
Tom Key, Lower Plenty
Was running second in the NFL Division 2 Coaches’ MVP voting behind teammate Josh Turner when it went behind closed doors after Round 13. Capable of winning games in midfield or up forward, kicked an equal team-high 25 majors in 12 appearances and earnt nine mentions in the best.
Max King, South Croydon
The ex-Melbourne rookie is as mobile as 200cm ruckmen come, and so important to South Croydon. Played nine matches with one of his standout performances coming in Round 2 against Blackburn, hauling in a whopping 61 hit-outs to go with 10 clearances. Also booted four majors against Vermont’s tight defence later in the season. He’s a difficult match-up – opposition big men know they’re in for a tough day when pitted against King. Was in the mix for the Eastern league Premier Division team of the year at season’s end, making the extended squad.
Aaron Kite, Glenroy
A goalscoring machine. The Roys finished second-last in points scored this season but Kite still managed to boot 29 goals – fourth in EDFL Premier Division – from 10 appearances. Kicked goals in every match and dined out on Essendon Doutta Stars with nine goals in two contests and seven in two games against Maribyrnong Park.
Matthew Kreymborg, St Paul’s
Powerhouse midfielder and forward who missed a lot of the season through injury. When he and others returned, the Doggies got their bark back. Has won two Southern league Division 1 medals and regularly been a matchwinner.
Jack Langford, Banyule
After being named at centre half-back in the 2019 NFL Division 2 Team of the Year, finished 2021 as the competition’s joint leading goalkicker – alongside Diamond Creek’s Ryan Pingree – with 29 majors. Was goalless just once in 12 matches and named in the best eight times.
Charles Le Fanu, North Heidelberg
One of the recruits of the season having crossed from Northcote Park. Le Fanu was a rock in defence but also played a key role in midfield, which earnt him seven mentions in the best in 10 matches.
Mykelti Lefau, St Kilda City
The big fellow may not be the best player in local football, but you could advance an argument that he’s the most adaptable. At 194cm the former Casey VFL player can play any position on the field. He did some ruck work in the VFL but City settled him at half forward this season. Lefau is superb in the air but it’s his sharp work at ground level that sets him apart from most other big men.
Will Lewis, Old Brighton
Gun key forward who is certain to get calls from VFL clubs in the next few weeks. Booted 36 goals in 2019 and 33 from 11 matches this year, including a bag of nine against Uni Blues and five against Old Melburnians.
Jordan Lisle, Balwyn
The former Port Melbourne co-captain added another dimension to the Tigers’ attack in his first season, helping take the heat off veteran Jeff Gobbels, with 20 majors from nine appearances. The ex-AFL name earned selection at centre half-forward in the team of the year. Premiership player with the Borough in 2017.
Brent Macaffer, Eltham
The Panthers skipper continues to be a dominant force in midfield in NFL Division 2. Despite a bit of controversy this season, Macaffer’s ability to win clearances and then burn off opponents with his elite tank makes him one of the stars of metro footy.
Tom Maloney, Norwood
Heralded as one of the boom signings heading into this season – and the premiership Box Hill Hawk certainly lived up to the hype. Proved his worth as a clearance king and contested possession machine, consistently good all season across eight matches (six times in the best).
Michael Mannix, Wallan
Described, perhaps biasedly, by coach Dan Nolan as one of the best leaders in local footy, Mannix is also one of the most influential players in the RDFL. Primarily a half-back flanker but with a well-honed taste for goals, he booted 13 in 10 games this season.
Ned McKeown, Macleod
The star defender returned from a year up north with Ovens and Murray club North Albury and reminded the competition why he is a three-time NFL Division 1 team of the year player. Was named in the Kangas’ best six times in 12 appearances and another Team of the Year honour looks likely.
Ben McNiece, Northcote Park
The former Essendon defender returned to his junior club and made an immediate impact. Whether through midfield or off half-back, McNiece was superb in a team that ultimately went winless in 2021, earning eight mentions in the best in his 11 games.
Victor Micaleff, East Keilor
The Cougars’ main man in midfield, Micaleff can rack disposals up with the best of them and doesn’t mind a goal either. Was named in the best six times in 12 matches this season with a standout performance against West Coburg as East held off the Saints by just seven points.
Darren Minchington, De La Salle
The smooth-moving midfielder had the impact De La was expecting, being consistently among their best players, most prominently against Uni Blacks. Minchington headed to the Ammos after a 32-game AFL career at St Kilda and Hawthorn that began when he was rookie listed by the Saints in 2012.
Josh Minogue, Heidelberg
After one VFL game for Williamstown in 2019 committed to Heidelberg full-time for 2021 and the Tigers reaped the rewards. Minogue finished the season with 32 majors – fifth most in NFL Division 1. Not just a dangerous forward, can also be thrown back as an intercept-marking defender.
Max Mitchell-Russell, Port Melbourne Colts
On the verge of picking up a VFL deal after an excellent season as a big backman for Port Melbourne Colts. He had been a forward but the switch to defence has brought him confidence and recognition. Colts assistant coach Jason Clarke calls him a “star on the rise’’. “Has all the tools as (a) defender. Great kick, quick, agile, can take a nice marks and reads the game wonderfully well,’’ he said.
Zach Molloy, Whittlesea
Copped an eight-goal lesson from Sam Lloyd in Round 3 but responded superbly. Kept Shane Harvey goalless in a shock win over North Heidelberg, held Ahmed Saad to three goals later in the season and showed his intercept-marking skills in the win over Montmorency. On the VFL radar for 2022.
Ryan Morrison, Noble Park
Named at centre half-back in the EFNL Premier Division team of the year, Morrison was as solid in defence as there was out east this season after returning from a stint at Rowville. Usually the man to rebound the Bulls out of defence and into attack, as he led a sound back six which conceded just 628 points – ranked fourth overall.
Josh Mould, Werribee Districts
The midfielder has been a regular feature in the Districts’ best players since crossing from Wyndhamvale at the end of 2018 – including seven of his 12 matches this season. Formerly listed with Werribee (VFL) and the Western Jets, and is a former Under 19 representative of the WRFL.
Aaron Mullett, Mooroolbark
The ex-AFL Kangaroo and Blue has just earned a second consecutive team of the year nod in the Eastern league’s second tier, after making the move back to local level in 2019. It’s remarkable considering the battles he’s had with injury across the past two campaigns, no less than this year where was struck down with a season-ending shoulder injury with a few games left. Topped the Mustangs’ goalkicking again with 29 from nine appearances following on from 47 in ’19.
Curtis Murfett, St Paul’s
Murfett is a much-honoured young footballer and it would be a surprise if he doesn’t land another Doggies’ best and fairest this year. Runs hard to reach contests, wins the ball and gets it to grateful teammates … and then he goes again. Sets himself high standards and invariably attains them.
Robin Nahas, North Ringwood
The former AFL Tiger and Kangaroo slotted in perfectly in the Eastern league’s top-flight as playing-coach of the Saints this season, racking up the possessions while providing his side plenty of speed and run on the outside. Super addition and a driver behind North Ringwood’s resurgence. Named in the team of the year in the back pocket.
Joel Naylor, Hurstbridge
Arguably the recruit of the year in the Northern Football League. Hurstbridge plucked Naylor out of RDFL outfit Romsey and he returned a sensational tally of 36 goals – equal third in the competition. Kicked bags of five against Bundoora and North Heidelberg and six against Heidelberg to underline his talent.
Beven Newell, Moonee Valley
The former Coburg VFL-listed big man enjoyed an outstanding return season after playing for Hillside in 2019. Newell was named in Moonee Valley’s best eight times – the most in EDFL Division 2 – and booted 23 goals in his 11 matches.
Liam Ogden, Pascoe Vale
The midfielder was a model of consistency in his second season at the Panthers. Ogden was named in the best an impressive nine times in 12 matches, including best-afield displays against Keilor, Maribyrnong Park and Avondale Heights. If he can add a few more goals to his game, will be among the league’s very best.
Cam O’Shea, Uni Blues
The former Port Adelaide and Carlton defender gave Uni Blues excellent service this year, first off half back, then on the ball. He joined Blues for what turned out to be a premiership year in 2019. O’Shea will be 30 before the 2022 season but he remains fit and eager about his football.
Andrew Panayi, Werribee Districts
Gave opposition defenders plenty of headaches this season in attack with 34 goals from 12 matches, helping his side to a 9-3 finish and second spot. The dangerous forward was named in the WRFL’s ‘Team of the Decade’ from 2010-19, he represented Vic Metro in 2015 and the WRFL on three occasions, and has also been named in the team of the year three times. Listed with Footscray in the VFL across 2017 and ’18.
Brenton Payne, Hoppers Crossing
The former AFL rookie turned it on again in front of goals this season with 43 majors from 12 matches – and he was on track to better his 2019 return of 61. “He just knows how to find the footy and reads the flight of the ball a lot better than others,” coach Steve Kretiuk said of Payne this season.
Paul Pattison, Balwyn
Proved himself to be a find for the Eastern league Premier Division powerhouse through the midfield this season. The former Casey name played all nine games for the Tigers – named in the best in five of those – as the club finished third. Earned selection in the team of the year.
Nick Pavlou, Old Brighton
The onballer attracts a tag most weeks but still gets his 30-plus possessions. Won the Tonners’ best and fairest in 2019 when he played every game and averages 31 touches. Highly rated by all Premier coaches.
Blake Pearson, Norwood
The hard-at-it midfielder and former Port Melbourne gun set the Eastern league alight in his first season in the comp – setting the tone with a five-goal performance on debut. Had no trouble finding the pill or the goals (13 from eight matches), but also brought others into the game through his many score involvements. One of the recruits of the season.
Jase Perkins, Port Melbourne Colts
How do you stop a fellow who’s so strong in the air, but so nimble on the ground? Perkins is just that and it’s brought him close to 1000 goals in senior football, a lot of them kicked at Deer Park in the Western Region. Copped an injury year on his return to the Colts but he wound up with 40 goals from seven outings, including two hauls of 10.
Matthew Perri, Wallan
The evergreen goalmachine booted 46 majors in 10 matches this season with a season’s best eight on three occasions – against arch rival Diggers Rest, Riddell and Western Rams. A danger on the lead or below the knees and can kick them from anywhere.
Chris Phelan, Doncaster East
Has been a star for the Lions since crossing from the WAFL ahead of the 2019 season, and he continued to show his class in the Eastern league’s Premier Division this year. Season was highlighted by a whopping 75 disposals combined across rounds 9 and 10 – which included 41 disposals against Berwick followed up by 34 against Doncaster. A team-of-the-year honour capped off a great campaign.
Anthony Prestia, Tullamarine
Another fine season for the Tulla playmaker. Prestia proved to be a danger around the contest and on the outside, kicking 20 goals in 11 appearances. Was consistently in the Demons’ best players to help the club finish the EDFL Division 1 season in second.
Nick Riddle, Greensborough
The general of the Borough backline. His nomination can probably be shared with teammates Michael Croxford, Billy Bedford and Jack Johnson. Played nine of 12 matches this season and was named in the best five times as he shut down the opposition’s best forward every week.
Brodie Romensky, Maribyrnong Park
An outstanding start to the season and even more impressive finish. Romensky was in Marby’s best in the first three games of the year, including a best-afield performance against Essendon Doutta Stars and then finished with five straight games in the best, best-on-ground in the final two matches of the season against Avondale Heights and Stars.
Conor Ross, St Kevin’s
Defender who tends to be underrated outside his club. St Kevin’s insiders regard him as one of the side’s most important players. Athletic, has closing speed and can play on tall and small forwards. Wore the Big V in 2019.
Sam Rowe, Doncaster East
The big forward stood up with 22 majors from eight appearances in his first season at Zerbes Reserve after finishing up an AFL career which included a long stint with Carlton and a season on St Kilda’s list. Season was highlighted by a bag of eight against Doncaster in Round 2.
Ricky Schraven, Wallan
Has hardly missed a game in his three seasons at Wallan and continues to be a dominant force in midfield and in attack. Only the three mentions in the best for the Magpies this season but his influence was immense.
Hamish Shepheard, Bundoora
After a 12-month wait Bulls fans finally got to see the former Fremantle-listed big man in the flesh and boy did he deliver. Was rated best-on-ground in the stirring win over Greensborough in Round 10. A hot favourite for No. 1 ruck in the NFL Division 1 team of the year.
Jack Sims, St Albans
Gun midfielder and so dangerous around goal. The Saints captain stood out again this season, where he was named in the best on eight occasions of his 12 games – and in the top couple on the ground five times.
Lachlan Smart, Deer Park
The classy forward was a welcome addition to the Lions after putting pen to paper ahead of 2020. In his first season at the club, he kicked 23 goals from 12 matches, following on from a return of 65 goals for Sunshine in the previous three campaigns.
Mitch Smart, Bentleigh
It’s rare to see the big fellow out of the list of best players for the Demons. He’s constantly in the play, going up for hit-outs, then looking to get involved with a tackle or block. Seems a certain selection for the team of the year and he should poll well in the league medal (he finished fifth in 2019).
Matt Smith, Heidelberg
Committed full-time to Heidelberg after spending 2019 with Collingwood’s VFL team and produced a brilliant campaign. A contested ball-winning bull, few teams figured out how to stop Smith around the clearances. Surprisingly, was only named in the Tigers’ best three times.
Tim Smith, South Belgrave
The ex-Melbourne and Casey Demon topped the Eastern league Division 2 goalkicking with 33 majors from 10 appearances, including bags of five against Mulgrave, Knox and Boronia. Made the Division 2 team of the year at centre half-forward in his first season back in the league.
Todd Stevenson, Keilor
The star utility put together another eye-catching campaign despite missing a month in the middle of the season. Started out with three goals against Strathmore and four goals against Aberfeldie before going down but returned and finished strongly, named in the best in Keilor’s finals two games.
Max Tessari, Caroline Springs
Has become one of the Lakers’ top midfielders in recent seasons since graduating from the Under 19s – and this season could very well have been a breakout. Eight times he finished in the best of 12 matches. One to watch in 2022.
Nathan Thomas, Bundoora
A brilliant season by the underrated half-forward-midfielder. Thomas booted 11 goals in 12 appearances and was named in the Bulls’ best six times, including a pair of best-ons. Was in the top five for NFL Division 1 Coaches’ MVP votes at the halfway mark of the season, highlighting his influence on the Bulls’ rise up the ladder.
Josh Turner, Lower Plenty
Despite missing two games was leading the NFL Division 2 Coaches’ MVP after Round 13 with four best-on-ground performances. A dominant force in midfield for the Bears and should feature heavily on the league’s best-and-fairest medal night.
Tristan Tweedie, Norwood
Has built a reputation as one of the EFNL Premier Division’s top defenders, and he lived up to the billing again this year, named in the Team of the Year. No job is too big for the former East Ringwood Roo, as he led a back six which conceded just 477 points – a mere 22 points behind only minor premier Vermont. Ultra-reliable.
Dillon Viojo-Rainbow, Werribee Districts
The former Carlton man has made waves in local football after his stint in the big-time wrapped up in 2016. Played in Port Melbourne’s 2017 VFL flag before serving a pivotal role in attack in Doncaster East’s 2018 flag where he was named best-afield. Earned a shot with Footscray in ’19, linking with the Districts the same year. Played every game this season.
39: Josh Wallis, St Kevin’s
Consistent and courageous customer who went back to St Kevin’s as a full-time player this year and out of the middle grabbed nine mentions in the best from his 10 games. That will put him in Woodrow Medal contention. Wallis had been on the books at the Footscray Bulldogs, where he played 45 VFL matches. At 24 he’s got a lot of good football ahead of him.
Lucas Walmsley, Dingley
Dingley watchers will tell you 2021 wasn’t Walmsley’s best year. But he’s still a player opposition teams know they need to quell to have any hope of defeating the Dingoes. With his remarkable running ability “Noodles’’ has been one of the best SFNL players of the past decade, featuring in a bunch of flags and winning a league medal.
Tom Waters, Lancefield
Still arguably the No. 1 ruckman in the Riddell District competition. Waters returned to Lancefield this season to take on coaching duties and continues to be a force to be reckoned with.
Campbell Wearne, Essendon Doutta Stars
A standout season in midfield for the Stars saw Wearne named in the club’s best nine times in 12 matches, including five times in the top two. Finished the season in superb form, earning mentions in the best in the final five games.
Dylan Weickhardt, Cheltenham
Weickhart may not be the flashiest or most flamboyant player on this list, but he’s a cussed competitor and consistent in everything he does. It was Chelt’s lucky day when they signed him from Sandringham, where he was vice-captain and much respected in VFL ranks.
Kyle Weightman, Strathmore
Unbelievably produced his best goal haul in a shortened season, kicking 32 majors in 11 games. Remarkably consistent, Weightman booted at least two goals in every match with a high of five in a best-on-ground display against Craigieburn. Was named on the bench in the Premier Division team of the year in 2019, but expect him to be upgraded to on-field for 2021.
Brodie White, Craigieburn
In a dark season for Craigieburn, White was a shining light. Was named in the Eagles’ best in six of 10 appearances, three of which were best-on-ground performances. Finished the season with back-to-back best-ons against Strathmore and Greenvale and will be better for the experience in the EDFL’s top flight.
Jake Williams, De La Salle
Injury restricted Williams to only four senior games this year. But he’s got more than enough honours to land on this list, most notably a pair of Woodrow Medals as the Premier best and fairest. The left-footer made a good impression at Collingwood VFL before returning to De La in 2015.
James Wilsen, South Croydon
The former Box Hill and Frankston VFL defender crossed from Montrose to Cheong Park ahead of this season and slotted in seamlessly. Made the move forward to help cover the absence of Jake Tucker, and it paid off, kicking 28 goals from 10 games, including a bag of five on Anzac Day. Full forward in the team of the year.
Nick Wood, St Kevin’s
The son of former league star Bryan Wood, Wood can play inside and outside, is strong, has speed, sparkling skills and he’s tough. Featured in the 2015, ’17 and ’18 premierships, won the 2014 best and fairest, served as captain and represented the VAFA in 2018 and ’19.
Lachlan Wynd, Rowville
Made a name as one the most exciting young forwards in the Eastern league this year, kicking 23 majors from seven matches in his debut season. The wiry and agile tall was rewarded with a spot in the team of the year at half-forward, and has previously been touted as being on VFL club Box Hill’s radar for 2022. “He’s got a real appetite to do well,” Rowville coach Ben Wise says.
Tyson Young, Greenvale
Left Airport West to remain in EDFL Premier Division and rewarded Greenvale with an impressive season. Used predominantly forward of the ball this season and returned 25 goals in 12 matches, including a season-best six against Maribyrnong Park, but showed he’s also more than capable chasing the pill. Was outstanding in losses to Keilor (twice) and Strathmore.
AND NOW FOR THE TOP 40 …
40: Taylor Hine, Diggers Rest
Finished the season with three straight best-on-ground performances as he rediscovered his best form. Capable of influencing a game from all three parts of the ground, expect the former AFL man to feature prominently on Bowen Medal night.
39: Travis Tuck, Berwick
The ex-AFL Hawk produced an excellent season for the Wickers in their inaugural Eastern league campaign, named in his side’s best in six of the seven matches he played. At 34 he hasn’t slowed down, taking in a team-of-the-year honour.
38: Luke Jarrad, Strathmore
A commanding presence across half-back for the Mores, the former SANFL star reads the play superbly and rebounds with authority. Since joining Strathmore in 2017, Jarrad has been picked in the team of the year and logged top-five finishes in the Reynolds Medal each season. Don’t be surprised if he features prominently again in 2021.
37: Tom Bell, Greensborough
The reigning Rosbrook Medal winner was a matchwinner in midfield and in attack for Greensborough in 2021. Bell booted 16 goals and was named in the best six times in 12 appearances. He looked to be warming up just in time for finals, with arguably his best performance in what would be the final game of the year, slotting four goals against North Heidelberg.
36: Kyle O’Connor, Keilor
The ex-Geelong VFL midfield-forward has made an immediate impact at his new club. After finding his feet in EDFL Premier Division, O’Connor went on a tear starting with a best-on-ground performance against Aberfeldie in Round 5, the first five straight games in the Blues’ best and seven of eight before the season was called off.
35: Liam Buxton, Vermont
Massive on return to the Eastern league this season, with the former Casey big man proving his worth as one of the premier ruckman and as a strong option up forward. Helped himself to stacks of hit-outs, contested marks and score involvements, while also hitting the scoreboard with 11 goals. Named on the bench in the team of the year, coming up against stiff competition for the ruck spot, which went to Doncaster’s Jake Spencer.
34: Simon White, Doncaster East
The former Carlton defender turned out another consistent campaign, standing out for disposals, rebound-50s, marks and intercept marks in the Lions’ first season in the Eastern league’s top division. Looked at home in Premier Division, too, earning team of the year honours. Dual premiership player with the Lions and club captain.
33: Matthew Watson, Pascoe Vale
The pre-eminent forward in EDFL Premier Division. Watson topped the goalkicking charts with 40 majors in 12 outings. Held off the scoresheet just once in 2021 and that was his only outing with less than two goals, highlighting his consistency. Kicked a season-high eight majors against Craigieburn.
32: Brent Stillman, Keilor
Was brilliant in his first season at Keilor but might have topped it this year. Stillman was named in the Blues’ best in eight of 12 appearances and was rated best-on-ground four times, including three in the last five games. Given Keilor’s unbelievable depth can we consider him underrated?
31: Will Hams, Old Xaverians
Regarded as one of the best running players in VAFA Premier. Joined Xaverians from Box Hill Hawks, having previously played 13 AFL games for Essendon from 2013-16. Was credited with having 50 touches for Xavs in a match in 2019. There is time and a touch of class about everything he does.
30: Zac Clarke, Doncaster East
The ex-AFL Docker and Bomber proved to be more than a handful for opposing ruckmen in his first season in the Eastern league. In Round 1 against Blackburn he helped himself to 70 hit-outs and 10 clearances, and he regularly brought in big numbers thereafter. Stiff competition in the division when Clarke misses out on a gig in the team of the year, but he was consistently good.
29: Jack Stephens, Uni Blues
Stephens arrived in the VAFA with a handsome reputation made in the SANFL (2019 state captain, two-time premiership player with Sturt, team-of-the-year selection … it goes on). And he lived up to it with some slashing displays from centre half back, his intercept marking exceptional. Was named in the best 10 times from 11 matches and is tipped to beat a hot field for the best and fairest. What a star.
28: Jesse Donaldson, Montmorency
Not sure Donaldson has played a bad season in his 10-plus years at Montmorency. The influential skipper was among the Magpies’ best nine times in 12 games and added 13 goals. Was leading the NFL Division 1 Coaches’ MVP voting when it went behind closed doors so there might be some silverware on offer later this month.
27: Jack Dorgan, Hoppers Crossing
The classy midfielder has been a top addition to Hoppers after putting pen to paper following 2019. Kicking is one of the major weapons to Dorgan’s arsenal, previously rated as one of the best kicks in the VFL during his time with Williamstown, where he played 54 games in eight seasons. Equal runner-up in the WRFL Division 1 MVP.
26: Marcus Stavrou, Old Xaverians
The ex-Eastern Ranges and Northern Blues player was named captain of Xavs this year and led the way as a never-beaten midfielder. Stavrou performed with distinction in the 2019 finals and was looking to do the same this year for a team that had annexed the top of the ladder before Covid blew the final siren on the season.
25: Viv Michie, Collegians
The onballer has rarely played a poor game in Collegians colours and he showed the way again in 2021. The former Fremantle and Melbourne player won the Lions’ best and fairest in 2018.
24: Scott Greenhough, Deer Park
The ruckman finished equal runner-up for the WRFL’s Division 1 MVP, after another imposing season for the former Collingwood VFL name. Named in Deer Park’s best in 10 of the 12 matches he played as he served as one of the Lions’ driving forces behind another top-four finish.
23: Matt Wetering, Springvale Districts
Star key forward who is being pursued by VFL clubs (Essendon invited him to train during the year). Won the Division 2 league medal in 2019 and booted 64 goals from 12 games this year. “He’s got the leap, he’s got the quickness, he’s got the hands, he’s got the goalkicking,’’ Caulfield Bears coach Chris O’Keefe said of Wetering. “He’s almost the complete package down there, to be honest.’’
22: Harry Hill, Old Brighton
A Tonner from top to toe, an exceptional clubman, captain and an outstanding onballer with lots of dash and determination. It’s rare to see Hill out of the OB best. Won the best and fairest in 2017 and ’18, was runner-up in 2016 and ’19, and was at the heart of the 2017 premiership in B section.
21: Charlie Haley, Balwyn
He’s as mercurial as forwards come in the Eastern league, and this season was no exception, topped off with a team of the year nod in the forward pocket after 30 goals from seven matches. Season was highlighted by a bag of 10 against Rowville to go with six in his last outing, against South Croydon. Not hard to work out why they call him ‘Headline’ Haley.
20: Kris Pendlebury, Balwyn
Continues to be the general down back for Balwyn, evidenced again this year with selection at full back in the team of the year. At age 35, he’s still tough to beat one-on-one with his fantastic fist and aerial skills. Dual premiership player with the Tigers after stints in the VFL with Bendigo, Collingwood and Werribee.
19: Sam Lloyd, Bundoora
The biggest name to join the Northern Football League this season and he didn’t disappoint. The former Richmond and Western Bulldogs forward split his time between midfield and forward and finished with 36 goals – equal third on the charts – helping Bundoora jump up the ladder after a tough 2019. Sadly would have missed finals had they been played with a serious wrist injury.
18: Tom Jok, St Kevin’s
Jok could have gone to any state league club in the country after being let go by Essendon, where he played one AFL match in 2019. He chose to return to Skob, where he figured in the 2017-18 premierships. So adaptable and athletic, Jok can play any position on the ground. And he does it very well.
17: Brede Seccull, Old Haileybury
The midfielder returned to the Bloods this year after a decorated stint in the state leagues, where he won best and fairests in the SANFL and VFL and captained Sandringham. Was named in the best in eight of his 11 games. “He’s waaaaay too good for Premier B,’’ an opposition assistant coach said of the right-footer.
16: Brett Eddy, Caulfield Grammarians
The former AFL player booted 25 goals from nine games in first season with the Fielders, 13 of them coming in two outings against Old Trinity. Eddy joined the VAFA from Vermont in the Eastern league, where he was a premiership player, leading goalkicker and competition best and fairest.
15: Ahmed Saad, West Preston-Lakeside
Despite missing a couple of games through suspension, the star goalmachine still topped the NFL Division 1 charts with 54 majors in 10 appearances, 14 clear of second place. Finished the season with a bag of 11 against Hurstbridge, one of six hauls of five goals or more.
14: Marley Williams, Port Melbourne Colts
The former Collingwood and North Melbourne AFL half back kicked off as a Colt with a best-afield performance in Round 1 against St Kilda City. Had seven more mentions in the best as he made his pace and spearing left-foot kicking count in Southern Division 1.
13: Jesse Tardio, North Heidelberg
A barnstorming season by the Bulldogs’ star midfielder. Tardio would arguably be Rosbrook Medal favourite if not for a run-in with the NFL tribunal. However, that shouldn’t take away from a brilliant season. Had the ball on a string most matches and bookended his campaign with best-on-ground displays against Macleod in Round 1 and Montmorency in Round 12.
12: Gus Borthwick, Old Melburnians
The brick-hard Borthwick is respected at all VAFA Premier clubs as one of the best midfielders in the amateurs, his strength and hands making him a formidable presence around the ball. Took his club’s best and fairest in 2019. Did well during his stop with Collingwood in the VFL too.
11: Ayce Cordy, Uni Blues
Former Western Bulldogs big man Cordy joined the Blues in 2018 after a stint at Williamstown. He won the Woodrow Medal in his first season and again in the second, as well as the best and fairests and captaining the club to the 2019 premiership. Cordy was quieter this year as he battled injuries, but he was still the best ruckman in the competition. Ayce? He’s an ace of the VAFA.
10: Jackson Sketcher, Noble Park
The dashing right-footer continued as one of the Bulls’ most crucial players this season, as he featured among the league’s best for contested possessions, clearances, inside-50s and disposals. He’s a big reason why the Bulls enjoyed a lift into the top rungs of the Premier Division ladder, finishing the shortened season in second spot. Played every game this season, and his consistency won him a spot in the team of the year.
9: Nick O’Brien, Strathmore
The former Bomber averaged close to 50 possessions this season, a staggering achievement even for one of the best ball-winners in local football. O’Brien will be hoping to break through for a Mores best-and-fairest win after finishing runner-up the past two seasons and go one better in the Reynolds Medal after a second place in 2019.
8: Nick Graham, Spotswood
The former Carlton midfielder was crowned the Western Region league’s Division 1 Coaches’ MVP for season 2021, earning the votes of five senior coaches. He finished four votes clear, in a season where Spotswood finished sixth with a 6-6 record. Took out the Morrish Medal in the TAC Cup in 2012 before 48 games with Carlton from 2012-18.
7: Lachie Johns, Vermont
The captain was a standout in the Eagles’ pursuit for a third consecutive flag, with the dual premiership skipper not only finding plenty of the ball, but having an impact on the scoreboard, to be named consistently in the best. In fact, of the seven matches he played of Vermont’s eight, he finished in the top players on six occasions. Couple that with the dynamic onballer’s 16 goals, and he mounts a strong case to be one of the top vote-getters in this year’s Chandler Medal. Named in the team of the year.
6: Dan Robinson, Old Xaverians
In his first full season with Old Xavs, midfielder Robinson was quick to put down his authority on the VAFA, featuring in the best seven times and regularly going past the 30-possession mark. It was no surprise given that he played 25 AFL games for the Sydney Swans and was with North Melbourne VFL in 2019.
5: Kwame McHarg, Port Melbourne Colts
It didn’t take long for the speedy and brilliantly skilled midfielder and half forward to show Southern watchers why he was regarded as a champion of the Western Region. A league medal was among the many awards he won at Deer Park and he’s among the favourites for the Southern league Division 1 best and fairest. The Colts named him their best player six times and he took four others mentions too. A champion of local football.
4: Jake Spencer, Doncaster
The ex-Melbourne ruckman took all before him in his first Eastern league season at the Sharks. Shouldering most of Doncaster’s rucking, he led the competition for hit-outs – more than often to advantage – and his influence around the ball was profound. Racked up the clearances and contested possessions. Ruckman in the Premier team of the year, beating several gun names for the spot.
3: Nick Meese, Aberfeldie
As Sandy Roberts’ famous line goes, ‘what more can you say’. Meese returned to local football full-time in 2021 after a decorated VFL career and produced a season of absolute class. Surely the EDFL Premier Division Reynolds Medal favourite after earning 10 mentions in the best from 12 outings – the most in the competition. He’s more than a ruckman. He’s a mountain.
2: David Mirra, Collegians
The former Box Hill Hawks captain, VFL champion and Hawthorn defender had an outstanding first season for the Lions in VAFA Premier. They were bowled over with injuries and wins were elusive, but Mirra helped maintain spirits and standards. He’s expected to win the best and fairest.
1: Kyle Martin, Noble Park
What more can be said about the Bulls champion? The former Magpie tore the competition apart this season, recording back-to-back weeks of 50+ disposals and a string of games where he hauled in more than 35. Remained one of the competition’s best for contested possessions and clearances, and he rarely wasted a disposal. The dual premiership Bull has won the best and fairest in 11 of his past 12 seasons of football – and he looks on track to make it 12 from 13 this year. Named in the centre in the Eastern league’s team of the year.
Join the conversation
Power House eyes premiership push
After a disappointing end to the 2024 season, Power House is aiming to be towards the pointy end of the VAFA Division 3 ladder once again. Here’s how they plan to do it after a busy off-season.
Read more
Family draws Spicer to Stars
A family connection helped Fitzroy Stars land ex-AFL forward Phoenix Spicer and coach Neville Jetta believes it can have a longer-lasting impact.
Read more