The Phantom’s captain anaylsis: Grundy, Fyfe and Dangerfield the obvious options but don’t forget about Rory
With the second week of SuperCoach fast approaching, The Phantom looks at all of the captain options for Round 2. PLUS review The Phantom’s answers to reader questions.
SuperCoach
Don't miss out on the headlines from SuperCoach. Followed categories will be added to My News.
- The Phantom’s Round 1 Trade Talk
- Every Round 1 SuperCoach score
- By The Numbers: Power fight back at the contest
With the second week of SuperCoach fast approaching, The Phantom looks at all of the captain options for Round 2.
Review The Phantom’s answers to reader questions in the comments below.
THE PHANTOM’S BEST OPTIONS
Brodie Grundy (Coll)
v Richmond, Thursday night
In his past four matches against the Tigers, including last year’s preliminary final, Grundy has posted scores of 146, 157, 115 and 135. And last week’s score of 81 wouldn’t have looked as bad if it weren’t for six clangers. The Phantom is expecting Grundy to bounce back, making him the perfect Thursday night VC option.
Rory Sloane (Adel)
v Sydney, Friday night
Adelaide’s co-captain was huge with 155 points against the Hawks in Round 1 and, while he miss last year’s clash through injury, Sloane has scored 140 and 137 in his past two home-and-away matches against the Swans. The threat of George Hewett is there but he hasn’t gone to him in the past. There’s 60 per cent chance of rain in Sydney on Friday night and we know the 29-year-old thrives in the tough conditions. A great point-of-difference VC option.
Patrick Cripps (Carl)
v Port, Saturday afternoon
Cripps is always a great option, given there’s really no one in the competition who can stop him. The Carlton star tallied 21 contested possessions and 126 points last week and boasts a career SuperCoach average of 117 against the Power. If you’re looking at Cripps, try to VC him into a Saturday night or Sunday captain option.
Patrick Dangerfield (Geel)
v Melbourne, Saturday night
Geelong are back at home and Dangerfield loves playing down at the Cattery, averaging 127 SuperCoach points in his past seven matches at the venue. Melbourne will be out to make amends for last week’s loss to the Power but expect Dangerfield, who’s posted scores of 126 and 138 in his past two home-and-away matches against the Demons, to thrive on a red-hot midfield contest.
Jack Macrae (WB)
v Hawthorn, Sunday
While Macrae’s career average against the Hawks is only a modest 94 points, expect him carry on with his ball-winning ways against a Hawthorn midfield who gave up 76 disposals and 292 points to Crows Rory Sloane and Matt Crouch in Round 1.
Nat Fyfe (Freo)
v Gold Coast, Sunday
A huge 147-point performance in Round 1. Scores of 160, 148 and 157 in his past three against the Suns. If you’ve got Fyfe, he’s your captain in Round 2.
SMOKIES
Jake Lloyd (Adel)
v Adelaide, Friday
The play-making defender is averaging 127 points in his past seven matches at the SCG and it’s unlikely the Crows will target Lloyd directly with a defensive forward.
Zach Merrett (Ess)
v St Kilda, Saturday
He’s copped it all week, as has his team, after a disappointing Round 1 performance against the Giants. But Merrett has tallied 36 disposals or more in his past three matches against the Saints, posting SuperCoach scores of 121, 120 and 100. It would be a brave VC call but you might consider it if you’ve got Fyfe to fall back on in the final game on Sunday
Tom Rockliff (Port)
v Carlton, Saturday
Speaking of big calls, if you really want to go to left-field with your VC this week, you could consider Rockliff if you’ve got him. He tallied 29 disposals and 92 points against the Blues last year and in his last encounter with Carlton as a Lion he tagged Bryce Gibbs. But in 2016, Rockliff posted scores of 206 and 159 against the Power’s Round 2 opponent. Hmmm.
BY THE NUMBERS
Average past three v opponent
Nat Fyfe (Frem) 153
Brodie Grundy (Coll) 140
Rory Sloane (Adel) 131
Zach Merrett (Ess) 123
Clayton Oliver (Melb) 120
THE PHANTOM’S CALL
I’ll be going with Grundy as VC on Thursday night before relying on Dangerfield as C on Saturday night if Grundy fails again.
Originally published as The Phantom’s captain anaylsis: Grundy, Fyfe and Dangerfield the obvious options but don’t forget about Rory
5 tips for the best shot at winning your footy tipping competition
To dominate your footy tipping competition in 2025, it’s not just about the teams you pick — it’s about how you approach the game. Avoid the common pitfalls and follow this winning strategy.
Five defenders you MUST consider in SuperCoach, including one big sleeper
Stuck with who you should pick in your SuperCoach defence? Check out these five options in this FREE guide – including a bona fide superstar coaches are sleeping on.