NewsBite

Senator Claire Chandler unable to answer question on who is calling for ban of trans women in single sex sports

A senator pushing for transgender people to be banned from women’s sport was stumped over a key question during a heated ABC interview.

Clubs should be allowed to operate 'single-sex sports' without fear of legal retribution

A Tasmanian senator pushing for transgender people to be excluded from women’s sport has been unable to name a single sporting organisation in the state who has called for the change.

Under a proposal introduced to parliament earlier this month, senator Claire Chandler wants the Sex Discrimination Act to be amended so it would not be unlawful for a sporting club to ban a person from a team based on their biological sex.

In a sensational grilling on ABC Radio Hobart, Senator Chandler was repeatedly asked to clarify who in particular is calling for the change.

“I’m not going to get into specifics,” she said.

Tasmanian senator Clare Chandler has been unable to name a single sporting club in her state to have called for the contentious changes. Picture: Richard Jupe
Tasmanian senator Clare Chandler has been unable to name a single sporting club in her state to have called for the contentious changes. Picture: Richard Jupe

When asked a further three times by host Leon Compton, the senator stood firm.

“What I will say is that I've been contacted by parents of girls who have realised how despondent their girls have become competing in sport, in situations where they’re competing against males and feeling like they’re not good enough to be in the game.”

“Is it possible, Claire Chandler, that this isn't an issue at all; the fact that you can’t name a single group,” Mr Compton quipped back.

“Leon, like I said, I'm not going to get into specifics with you,” she responded.

She added she had been contacted by “sporting administrators” who have been concerned about the legal action that could be taken against them if they do exclude a transgender person from a single-sex sport.

“You look at what is happening with Leah Thomas in the United States, where this trans woman, I should say, swimmer, who’s beating her female counterparts by seven seconds in the pool. That is just madness,” Senator Chandler said.

The Prime Minister on Tuesday revealed he was backing the Bill. Picture: Adam Taylor
The Prime Minister on Tuesday revealed he was backing the Bill. Picture: Adam Taylor

Senator Chandler’s bill came back into the spotlight after Prime Minister Scott Morrison revealed he had encouraged her to pursue it.

“I support it, as Claire knows. I think it’s a terrific Bill and I’ve given her great encouragement,” Mr Morrison told reporters on the hustings in Tasmania.

“Claire is a champion for women’s sport and I think she’s been right to raise these issues in the way that she has. Well done, Claire.”

But it remains to be seen if Mr Morrison’s backing will translate into broader support.

To have the bill introduced to the upper house, Senator Chandler had to do so as a private members bill, meaning she did not have support of the wider cabinet to put it on the agenda.

“If it was such a great bill, why isn‘t it endorsed by the cabinet?” Mr Compton pressed repeatedly.

“I've had a number of conversations with the Prime Minister obviously and with my colleagues about this issue. And look, if it’s something that the cabinet wants to consider, then that is obviously a matter for them,” Senator Chandler retorted.

With only three days left in the parliamentary sitting calendar, it is unlikely the Bill will pass, or even make it to the lower house, before the election.

Originally published as Senator Claire Chandler unable to answer question on who is calling for ban of trans women in single sex sports

Original URL: https://www.goldcoastbulletin.com.au/breaking-news/senator-claire-chandler-unable-to-answer-question-on-who-is-calling-for-ban-of-trans-women-in-single-sex-sports/news-story/f4f12cd688a06506a4f8b3cb868f343c