NewsBite

Sports Editor-at-large Phil Rothfield reveals his top 50 NRL players: 25-1

HOW did it come to this? Not a single NSW Blues player has made our top dozen NRL players this season.

Aaron Woods is one of the best big men in the game. Picture: Gregg Porteous
Aaron Woods is one of the best big men in the game. Picture: Gregg Porteous

NOT one NSW Blues star has made the top dozen players in the game this season.

In naming my top 50 players in the NRL for 2016, I have Paul Gallen as the highest-placed Blue — at 14th on the list.

The next best NSW player is Wests Tigers fullback James Tedesco, who hasn’t even played for the Blues. In a worrying sign for NSW coach Laurie Daley, the top dozen players in the game are all Queenslanders and Kiwis — along with Englishman Sam Burgess.

Maroons dominate the head of the list. Cowboys superstar Johna­than Thurston is clearly ahead of the rest at No.1 after his grand final heroics and fourth Dally M award last year.

Johnathan Thurston, Anthony Milford, James Tedesco, Kieran Foran.
Johnathan Thurston, Anthony Milford, James Tedesco, Kieran Foran.

He is now rated alongside — or even better — than Team of the Century halfback Andrew Johns.

Thurston’s Queensland teammate Cameron Smith comes in second, while fellow Maroons Greg Inglis (third), Cooper Cronk (sixth), Billy Slater (eighth) and Daly Cherry-Evans (11th) also make the top 12.

CHECK OUT 50-26 HERE

Little wonder the Maroons will start as red-hot favourites for this year’s State of Origin shield as they chase their 10th series win in 11 years, even allowing for the fact we have two home games at ANZ Stadium.

Despite an injury-plagued season in 2015, when knee issues slowed him down, I can see Inglis having a big year and I rate him the best among a hot crop of fullbacks.

His Rabbitohs teammate Sam ­Burgess is in at fourth, even though he has been out of the game for more than a year.

The 18-month “holiday” in rugby union will only make Burgess a better player and he will come back keen and hungry to make an impression — starting with the big local derby against the Roosters on Sunday afternoon at Allianz.

Sam Burgess is back in the NRL this year.
Sam Burgess is back in the NRL this year.

Shaun Johnson is returning from a badly broken leg last season but showed enough in the recent Auckland Nines to suggest he is right back to his devastating attacking best. He just shades fellow halfback Cronk, who at 32 is now in the latter stages of his glittering career, for fifth spot.

Ball-running dynamo Jason Taumalolo came of age in the Cowboys’ charge to the premiership last year and that performance will give him the confidence to realise his amazing potential. I’ve put him at No.7.

Several big names have missed out, headed by Broncos playmaker Ben Hunt. On his day, Hunt is a match-­winner, but I think last year’s grand final “shocker” will leave deep mental scars on him and he’ll struggle to play consistent football.

Plus there are too many halfbacks ahead of him — Thurston, Cronk, Johnson and Cherry-Evans.

Souths halfback Adam Reynolds has also missed the cut.

Ben Hunt is looking to recover from a grand final shocker. Picture: Darren England
Ben Hunt is looking to recover from a grand final shocker. Picture: Darren England

He’s a good general but there are just too many class halfbacks ahead of him at this stage.

The hardest part of naming the top 50 was leaving out some outstanding players.

Ryan Hoffman, Greg Bird, James Maloney and Trent Merrin didn’t get a start because there are so many outstanding youngsters coming through of the calibre of Jack Bird, Valentine Holmes and Bryce Cartwright.

Gareth Widdop is all class at the Dragons.
Gareth Widdop is all class at the Dragons.

25 Gareth Widdop

Age: 26

Games: 118

2015 Best Stat: 20 try assists, 21 forced drop outs.

24 Josh Dugan

Age: 25

Games: 120

2015 Bests Stat: Averaged 166m per game and had 107 tackle busts.

23 Anthony Milford

Age: 21

Games: 69

2015 Best Stat: 23 linebreak assists, 19 linebreaks, 100 tackle busts.

Young superstar Anthony Milford.
Young superstar Anthony Milford.

22 Aidan Guerra

Age: 27

Games: 109

2015 Best Stat: Averaged 31 tackles, 10.3 runs per game.

21 Aaron Woods

Age: 24

Games: 105

2015 Best Stat: Averaged 149m, 25 tackles per game.

Aaron Woods is one of the best big men in the game. Picture: Gregg Porteous
Aaron Woods is one of the best big men in the game. Picture: Gregg Porteous

20 Blake Ferguson

Age: 25

Games: 121

2015 Best Stat: 15 linebreaks, 59 tackle busts.

Blake Ferguson against St Helens.
Blake Ferguson against St Helens.

19 Corey Parker

Age: 33

Games: 323

2015 Best Stat: Averaged 130m, 30 tackles per game.

Broncos veteran Corey Parker. Picture: Adam Head
Broncos veteran Corey Parker. Picture: Adam Head

18 Matt Scott

Age: 30

Games: 208

2015 Best Stat: Averaged 125m, 24 tackles per game.

17 James Graham

Age: 30

Games: 90

2015 Best Stat: Averaged 115m, 29 tackles per game.

16 Matt Moylan

Age: 24

Games: 50

2015 Best Stat: 11 linebreak assists, 10 try assists in his 11 games last year.

Matt Moylan is one of the bright young stars of NRL.
Matt Moylan is one of the bright young stars of NRL.

15 James Tedesco

Age: 23

Games: 52

2015 Best Stat: Busted 157 tackles last year, the most in the NRL.

14 Paul Gallen

Age: 34

Games: 259

2015 Best Stat: Averaged 196m per game, made 36 offloads.

Paul Gallen comes in at 14. Picture: Jenny Evans
Paul Gallen comes in at 14. Picture: Jenny Evans

13 Jesse Bromwich

Age: 26

Games: 132

2015 Best Stat: Averaged 16 runs for 144m per game.

Jesse Bromwich of the Storm.
Jesse Bromwich of the Storm.

12 Jarred Waerea Hargreaves

Age: 27

Games: 135

2015 Best Stat: Averaged 108m and 24 tackles per game.

11 Daly Cherry Evans

Age: 27

Games: 127

2015 Best Stat: 20 try assists.

Daly Cherry-Evans is one of the NRL’s premier halves. Picture: Brett Costello
Daly Cherry-Evans is one of the NRL’s premier halves. Picture: Brett Costello

10 Roger Tuivasa-Sheck

Age: 22

Games: 84

2015 Best Stat: 5795 total run metres, first player on record to run over 5000m in a season.

9 Kieran Foran

Age: 25

Games: 147

2015 Best Stat: 16 try assists.

Kieran Foran has moved to the Eels. Picture: Mark Evans
Kieran Foran has moved to the Eels. Picture: Mark Evans

8 Billy Slater

Age: 32

Games: 277

2015 Best Stat: 8 linebreak assists, 4 linebreaks in his 7 matches.

7 Jason Taumalolo

Age: 22

Games: 86

2015 Best Stat: 70 tackle busts, averaged 144m per game.

Jason Taumalolo busted 70 tackles last year. Picture: Gregg Porteous
Jason Taumalolo busted 70 tackles last year. Picture: Gregg Porteous

6 Cooper Cronk

Age: 32

Games: 275

2015 Best Stat: 21 try assists, four 40/20 kicks.

5 Shaun Johnson

Age: 25

Games: 101

2015 Best Stat: made 15 linebreaks (most for any halfback).

Warriors superstar Shaun Johnson.
Warriors superstar Shaun Johnson.

4 Sam Burgess

Age: 27

Games: 96

2014 Best Stat: Made more runs (514) and more metres (4258) than any player in 2014.

3 Greg Inglis

Age: 29

Games: 221

2015 Best Stat: 16 linebreak assists, 77 tackle busts.

Greg Inglis comes in at No. 3. Picture: Jerad Williams
Greg Inglis comes in at No. 3. Picture: Jerad Williams

2 Cameron Smith

Age: 32

Games: 309

2015 Best Stat: 11 try assists, 13 forced drop outs.

1 Johnathan Thurston

Age: 32

Games: 268

2015 Best Stat: League high 37 try assists, Dally M medallist, Clive Churchill medallist.

Johnathan Thurston is the best player in rugby league. Picture: Phil Hillyard
Johnathan Thurston is the best player in rugby league. Picture: Phil Hillyard

Add your comment to this story

To join the conversation, please Don't have an account? Register

Join the conversation, you are commenting as Logout

Original URL: https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/nrl/sports-editoratlarge-phil-rothfield-reveals-his-top-50-nrl-players-251/news-story/828f5ee9afeeb0d94572f4142732da3e