Broncos fail to meet expectations against the Titans, Tyrone Roberts soars as skipper
Was Brisbane’s loss to the Gold Coast another costly stumble for a young, rebuilding team or a desperate case of a lack of motivation, asks ROBERT CRADDOCK.
Opinion
Don't miss out on the headlines from Opinion. Followed categories will be added to My News.
Each week, The Courier-Mail’s chief sportswriter Robert Craddock looks at the big talking points coming out of the NRL.
OFFSIDE
SUNDAY ROAST
THE Broncos’ shock loss to the Titans has divided critics over the cause of their Sunday sleep in.
Is this simply a matter of a young team unable to cope with the stresses of the Origin period?
Is it the cost a team has to pay during a rebuilding period?
Or is it a case of a team yet again having its motivational levels dipping when it faces a battling rival?
It’s probably all of the above but none of the three excuses such a timid performance in front a decent home crowd. Most critics felt the Broncos were a top four team at the start of the season.
One of the reasons Melbourne Storm are so special is that when they see a lower ladder team out of form they go for the kill. The Broncos often slip into cruise mode.
MAKE A WISH
What a shame it would be if Cowboys prop Jordan McLean is denied a State of Origin debut for NSW after being the victim of one of rugby league’s ugliest sights — the wishbone tackle.
McLean’s left leg was hoisted high and he left the field in agony after a tackle by Manly young gun Manase Fainu.
BENNETT”S BIG TEST
ARE Wayne Bennett’s Rabbitohs all they are cracked up to be?
We are about to find out. With two successive losses, Sam Burgess gone for two weeks with a shoulder injury, Adam Reynolds out for a month and mystery man James Roberts appearing from nowhere to test their robust culture, Souths face a stern examination of their depth and character.
NO MORE JOSHING
WHAT is wrong with Josh McGuire?
We love the passion and high standards he brings to the game for Queensland and the Cowboys but the facial massage he gave Dylan Walker on Saturday night was the latest in a sequence of unacceptably unsavoury acts.
McGuire was fined $3,400 by the NRL who are watching him closely and tiring of his antics.
WELCOME BACK COTTER
It could and should been one of most uplifting moments of the weekend.
After two knees reconstructions, Mackay’s 20-year-old star Reuben Cotter swoops on a chip kick within seconds of making his NRL debut on Saturday and the cameras cross to his jubilant parents as he scores a try.
And then it gets called back because of a lightweight and clearly disputable obstruction call. What a let down.
ONSIDE
A REAL TITAN
Tyrone Roberts had to sneak off to his car to shed a tear when he was named Titans captain recently, so much did it mean to him.
That’s just the sort of passion the club needs and his performance against the Broncos was just the sort of wholehearted contribution the club needs as it negotiates the stormy seas of Ash Taylor’s absence. It’s hats off to the Titans for the spirit they showed after a tough week.
THE GREATER GOOD
Ash Taylor’s decision to take leave from the game as he deals with the cruel pressures of social media criticism has not surprised sportsmen from all codes who are glad he took a stand.
At Eagle Farm races on Saturday there were stories of two young jockeys struggling to cope with vicious social media taunts. Education for the challenges of social media is improving by the year but even the experts agree there is no set cure for handling it.
NIGHT OF KNIGHTS
WHEN the Newcastle Knights are riding high in the saddle so is rugby league.
The Knights’ six-match winning streak has added an electric edge to the competition and taken us back to the days when Andrew Johns was running amok with the vibe in the steel city as good as it has been for too many years. Great stuff.
BARGAIN BUY … BUT
NEWCASTLE pulled off one of the great bargain buys of the decade when they signed Kalyn Ponga to a five-year deal with $600,000 a season. But was he too cheap?
The pressure on Newcastle is to play him a top up fee but some club officials argue that a contract is a contract and he would not be handing money back if he was going poorly. It’s a deceptively complex debate.
TURPIN TIME
In an era when so many young players gain rich long-term contracts, Broncos rake Jake Turpin continues to plan with the rousing desperation of a youngster on small bickies playing for a bigger feed. Soon enough he will get one.
Originally published as Broncos fail to meet expectations against the Titans, Tyrone Roberts soars as skipper
Locker Room: Giant self-inflicted wound unleashes tsunami of pain
GWS are a sporting club that no other franchise in Australia would want to be right now, a club struggling for a pulse up against a thriving NRL and dealing with a wholly avoidable scandal, writes David Riccio.
Gutherson chase risks Dragons being labelled hypocrites
St George Illawarra’s open pursuit of Clint Gutherson risks giving the Dragons’ wantaway star Ben Hunt all the ammunition he needs in his own battle against the club, writes BRENT READ.