NewsBite

Buzz Rothfield: How to pick the top 50 NRL players

BUZZ Rothfield names his long list of players which will be whittled down into the NRL’s top 50 and revealed on Thursday.

How to pick the top 50 NRL players.
How to pick the top 50 NRL players.

PICKING my best 50 players in the NRL is an almost impossible assignment.

You weight up past form, statistics, potential and good old fashioned footy judgment.

The first thing I did was analyse the top 17 in each club’s roster and focus on those players that have the biggest impact week in and week out.

That’s the easy part. I finished up with 104 names.

What it does show is the incredible strength of the Penrith Panthers who managed 12 out of the 104 contenders and also why the Newcastle Knights, with only Dane Gagai making the list, will struggle.

You then look for the obvious top 10 candidates such as Johnathan Thurston and Cameron Smith. But along with rewarding sustained excellence over a number of seasons, there is a need to allow for some new blood. Of course that means, for every new face, one has to drop out.

Below is my long list of 50, we will be revealing 50 to 26 on Wednesday afternoon with the top 25 announced on Thursday, the opening day of the 2017 season.

Broncos - 7 nominations
Darius Boyd
Sam Thaiday
Anthony Milford
Matt Gillett
Ben Hunt
Adam Blair
Corey Oates
Raiders - 7 nominations
Jordan Rapana
Joey Leilua
Jarrod Croker
Blake Austin
Josh Papalii
Shannon Boyd
Josh Hodgson
Bulldogs - 7 nominations
Brett Morris
Will Hopoate
Josh Reynolds
Josh Jackson
David Klemmer
James Graham
Aiden Tolman
Sharks - 8 nominations
Valentine Holmes
Jack Bird
James Maloney
Paul Gallen
Andrew Fifita
Wade Graham
Matt Prior
Luke Lewis
Titans - 6 nominations
Jarryd Hayne
Ash Taylor
Chris McQueen
Kevin Proctor
Ryan James
Nathan Peats
Sea Eagles - 6 nominations
Tom Trbojevic
Jake Trybojevic
Dylan Walker
Daly Cherry-Evans
Nate Myles
Martin Taupau
Storm - 7 nominations
Billy Slater
Will Chambers
Suilasi Vunivalu
Cooper Cronk
Jesse Browmwich
Cameron Smith
Cameron Munster
Knights - 1 nomination
Dane Gagai
Cowboys - 7 nominations
Michael Morgan
Johnathan Thurston
Matt Scott
Gavin Cooper
Jason Taumololo
Ethan Lowe
Kalyn Ponga
Eels - 7 nominations
Bevan French
Josh Hoffman
Clint Gutherson
Corey Norman
Beau Scott
Semi Radradra
Michael Jennings
Warriors - 6 nominations
Roger Tuivasa-Sheck
Kieran Foran
Shaun Johnson
Issac Luke
Ben Matulino
Tuimoala Lolohea
Panthers - 12 nominations
Matt Moylan
Josh Mansour
Tyrone Peachey
Dean Whare
Dallin Watene-Zelezniak
Te Maire Martin
Trent Merrin
Nathan Cleary
Bryce Cartwright
Reagan Campbell-Gillard
James Tamou
Peter Wallace
Rabbitohs - 6 nominations
Greg Inglis
Adam Reynolds
Cody Walker
Sam Burgess
George Burgess
Robbie Farah
Dragons - 5 nominations
Josh Dugan
Tyson Frizzell
Gareth Widdopp
Euan Aitken
Joel Thompson
Roosters - 8 nominations
Latrell Mitchell
Blake Ferguson
Boyd Cordner
Mitch Pearce
Jake Friend
Jared Waerea-Hargreaves
Dylan Napa
Connor Watson
Tigers - 4 nominations
James Tedesco
Mitchell Moses
Aaron Woods
Luke Brooks

Add your comment to this story

To join the conversation, please Don't have an account? Register

Join the conversation, you are commenting as Logout

Original URL: https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/nrl/buzz-rothfield-how-to-pick-the-top-50-nrl-players/news-story/533e3fdb1c4c1a41b9bfbdf680b30ba1