Tom Brady gets mixed reviews after finally making $560m debut

The jury is well and truly out after Tom Brady and his $560m contract finally made a long-awaited NFL commentary debut.

Legendary quarterback Tom Brady had a mix of ups and downs in his highly anticipated Fox Sports announcing debut on Monday (AEST).

Fox signed Brady to a 10-year deal worth a total of US$375 million ($562m) more than two years ago and the sports world has been waiting with bated breath to see how he’d perform in the NFL booth, as the New York Post reports.

Watch an average of 3 games each week during the regular season, plus every game of the NFL Postseason including the Super Bowl, LIVE on ESPN with Kayo. New to Kayo? Start your free trial today >

The game wound up being a dud as the Cowboys won 33-17 in a contest that was effectively over at halftime, so we will have to wait at least a week longer to assess how Brady handles truly big moments.

TV networks covet the aura of former players and coaches who had Hall of Fame careers and won titles.

Fox in particular places an emphasis on this for NFL analysts, with past colour commentators including John Madden and Troy Aikman, plus studio talents Terry Bradshaw, Jimmy Johnson, Howie Long, Rob Gronkowski and Michael Strahan.

Tom Brady with broadcaster partner Kevin Burkhardt prior to the game in Ohio. (Photo by Nick Cammett/Getty Images)

Brady brings that in spades as the most accomplished quarterback in NFL history, having won seven Super Bowl championships with the Patriots and Buccaneers.

When Fox cut to him and play-by-play partner Kevin Burkhardt for the pregame introduction, it immediately felt like a big game.

Brady appeared to be cognisant of letting the game breathe, heeding the advice of Phil Simms, the former top CBS analyst and Giants great, who told The Post last week that nobody has ever complained about an announcer who talks too little.

In key moments, Brady paused to let the viewer hear the crowd reaction at Huntington Bank Field in Cleveland before weighing in.

Crucially, he finished his thoughts concisely, passing the proverbial baton back to Burkhardt before it was time to call new plays.

Brady came across as warm — he had a graceful tone, striking a balance between showing enthusiasm for the action on the field while remaining relaxed and at ease.

Jerry Jones (right), owner of the Dallas Cowboys, speaks with Brady before the game. (Photo by Nick Cammett/Getty Images via AFP)

He had a sense of humour, chiding Browns star pass rusher Myles Garrett for jumping off-side in the second quarter.

“You don’t need to go that far — you already beat everybody off the line on that little burst move you’ve got,” Brady said with a smirk.

He was at his strongest when he spoke with first-hand experience about the “mental gymnastics” Cowboys defensive coordinator Mike Zimmer put quarterbacks through, as Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson was flummoxed and under duress from a relentless pass rush all game.

One area for big improvement was on display during the many times he paused mid-sentence as he collected his thoughts.

The smoothest broadcasters talk in perfectly formed paragraphs, with pauses immaculately pegged to punctuation marks, like a news anchor reading a script.

Brady seemed to be playing possum in the sense he knows people are waiting for him to be hypercritical, but he never broke out the sharp knives for any Browns players or coaches as they were getting pummeled.

Brady finished his career in Tampa Bay. (Photo by Mike Ehrmann/Getty Images via AFP)

He could’ve been a lot harder on Watson, whom the Browns paid US$230 million, fully guaranteed, after they traded three first-round picks to acquire him from the Texans in 2022.

If Brady went 24-for-45 for 169 yards, one touchdown and two interceptions in a 16-point season-opening loss, you can bet your house he would’ve been awfully hard on himself.

Brady also at times leaned on announcer cliches. On a play when the Browns lost yardage, he remarked that it’s harder to move forward once you’ve gone backward.

Brady entered his broadcasting career with considerable pressure, not only because of his pedigree and record salary, but also because he was replacing Greg Olsen as Fox’s top analyst.

Olsen, who was relegated to the second announcing team, had excelled in the role since replacing Aikman in 2022.

While many industry observers argue announcers don’t impact TV ratings, Fox was home to the crew — Madden and Pat Summerall — that has been cited over the years as the exception, with fans sticking around to hear them even in blowouts.

The network is hoping Brady, with his pedigree and high Q-Score among casual viewers, can give them a marginal boost in games like Sunday’s squash match.

There was a wide range of reactions to Brady’s debut in the box on X.

One wrote: “I thought he was fine, more pleasing to the ear than (Tony) Romo. Still not as good as Greg Olsen though.”

Another posted: “What was Fox thinking hiring Tom Brady for the A-Team and paying him 375 million? It was AWFUL.”

Another was more encouraged, writing: “Tom Brady is good enough. He’ll get better as time goes on, never liked that Greg Olsen as an analyst.”

A fourth had issued with the call, stating: “Brady was, at many times, boring and blasé and sometimes, I could barely hear what he was saying. Olsen, on the other hand, is clear and concise and very analytical without being pedantic.”

This article originally appeared in the New York Post and was reproduced with permission

Originally published as Tom Brady gets mixed reviews after finally making $560m debut