Crows legend Mark Ricciuto slams ‘ridiculous’ Brownlow Medal rule
Adelaide Crows legend Mark Ricciuto has taken aim at the league and called for a change to the Brownlow Medal voting system.
AFL
Don't miss out on the headlines from AFL. Followed categories will be added to My News.
Brownlow Medal winner Mark Ricciuto has taken aim at the AFL and called for the umpires to be allowed to access stats from the games.
Calls for changes to the voting system have been going on for years, but they reached new heights following Patrick Cripps 2024 win.
Watch the biggest Aussie sports & the best from overseas LIVE on Kayo. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited time offer.
The Blues skipper obliterated Dustin Martin’s previous record of 36 votes when he polled an astonishing 45 votes.
Collingwood’s Nick Daicos, who finished runner up, also surpassed Martin’s mark by polling 38 votes.
Ricciuto won the prestigious award in 2003 when he finished tied with Sydney’s Adam Goodes and Collingwood’s Nathan Buckley.
The three men that year won the Brownlow Medal with only 22 votes to their name. They wouldn’t have placed inside the top 10 in the 2024 count.
In the wake of Cripps’ monster tally, debate ignited surrounding changes being needed to the system.
Ricciuto said the umpires need to be given access to player statistics following games so they can assess the impacts players had before casting their votes.
“I think it is ridiculous that umpires can’t get stats after the game,” Ricciuto said to The Advertiser.
“I’ve done Triple M and Fox Footy commentary since I have finished playing and whenever I have had the responsibility of picking the best on ground I always look at the stats because when you are commentating or when you are umpiring a game of football you need to double check yourself.
“Sometimes you are surprised that someone kicked three, four or five goals, sometimes you are surprised that someone had 12 tackles, sometimes you are surprised that someone had 53 hit-outs.
“It is not as simple as you look at the stats and because a midfielder got 35 touches you give them best on ground, clearly the umpires are looking at the midfielders without the stats and thinking they have dominated.”
Despite the Crows legend’s plea, the league ruled out changes to the system with umpires to remain voting without having access to stats.
AFL chief executive Andrew Dillon had originally noted, in the wake of Cripps’ win, the league would consider allowing umpires to look at post-game statistics.
But those plans were thrown out the window with Dillon confirming no changes to the 2025 voting system would be implemented.
“We trust our umpires implicitly. They are professional, elite athletes (and) incredible decision-makers,” Dillon said to the Herald Sun.
“We spoke to the umpiring group at the end of last season and the consensus from the umpires was that they were comfortable making the calls on the 3-2-1 without access to statistics.”
Originally published as Crows legend Mark Ricciuto slams ‘ridiculous’ Brownlow Medal rule
AFL’s former chief psychiatrist on why drugs policy is life and death
Footy’s illicit drugs policy has never been short of controversy. The AFL’s former chief psychiatrist Rajit Menon says while the league’s approach might not be perfect, it’s saved countless lives.
Proof young Roo is a SuperCoach lock; verdict on top ten draftees
SuperCoach watchers may have been concerned by watching Finn O’Sullivan end up on the bench for the end of the Roos’ clash on Saturday, but it only cemented his spot in JON RALPH’s team.