NewsBite

Sydney childcare vacancies: City parents face huge waiting lists while west struggles to fill places

When it comes to childcare in Sydney, it really is a tale of two cities. Exclusive figures reveal where the shortages are and where there are places to spare.

L to R: Jasmine Ringland and her son Lachlan Ringland -2 and at Betty Spears Child care centre and pre-school in Tempe where Lachlan attends. There is a childcare vacancy shortage in the inner city and oversupply in outer suburbs. Picture: John Appleyard
L to R: Jasmine Ringland and her son Lachlan Ringland -2 and at Betty Spears Child care centre and pre-school in Tempe where Lachlan attends. There is a childcare vacancy shortage in the inner city and oversupply in outer suburbs. Picture: John Appleyard

When it comes to finding childcare in Sydney, it really is a tale of two cities.

Exclusive figures obtained from the Department of Education under Freedom of Information laws reveal that while some local government areas are still suffering from a chronic shortage of childcare, others have hundreds of vacancies that go unfilled each day.

The figures show the hardest places to find childcare in Sydney were on the lower north shore, the eastern suburbs, parts of the inner west and Manly including Hunters Hill, Lane Cove, Woollahra, and Strathfield.

Childcare vacancies:Western Sydney (green) has a much higher numbers of places available.
Childcare vacancies:Western Sydney (green) has a much higher numbers of places available.

Centres in these areas typically reported having two vacancies or less each day while waiting lists for the most sought after centres run up to three years.

CHILDCARE COSTS: NEW FIGURES REVEAL WHICH SUBURBS FARE BEST

WESTERN SYDNEY KIDS TAKE THE LONG ROAD TO CARE

Meanwhile, the outer suburbs including Campbelltown, Blacktown, Liverpool, Parramatta and Penrith report between 500 and 1200 vacancies per day and have as many as 120 services per area.

The glut in services has seen some centres struggle to fill vacancies and there are reports that some centres have been forced to close their doors.

Kids at play at Betty Spears at Tempe. Picture: John Appleyard
Kids at play at Betty Spears at Tempe. Picture: John Appleyard

“There’s no doubt there’s a dearth of places closer to the city where the operating costs are much higher but in suburban areas of western Sydney, where real estate may be more accessible, there are pockets of oversupply,” Early Childhood Australia CEO Samantha Page said.

The extent of the problem, revealed today in the comparative data released to NewsLocal, poses a major problem for the Federal Government as it prepares to respond to the Productivity Commission’s report into the childcare system.

Industry insiders blame a lack of coordination between the three levels of government for the worsening situation.

WHAT DO YOU THINK?

Have you had problems finding affordable childcare?

For example, Blacktown has 133 childcare centres, of which 122 report they have a combined total of 860 vacancies each day.

But in Manly, where there are 2972 children aged five and under, there are only 18 childcare centres, most with less than two vacancies each day.

Strathfield, where there are 1924 children aged under five, has only seven childcare centres with five reporting a total of 30 vacancies.

Balgowlah's Aimee Gjeci, and daughters Ivy, 3, and Lola, 2. New data shows that the childcare is much easier to find the further you get from the city centre.
Balgowlah's Aimee Gjeci, and daughters Ivy, 3, and Lola, 2. New data shows that the childcare is much easier to find the further you get from the city centre.

In Woollahra there are 15 long day care centres to cater for 3027 children aged under five. Seven of the centres report that they have 20 vacancies between them.

And the picture may be even more bleak for parents in areas of chronic shortages because many centres continue to report vacancies while at the same time running waiting lists for as many as 200 families.

“This is the complexity of planning for children services and we need to get better at it and try to ensure we provide some sort of incentives to providers to go where the need is and assist them with the barriers that exist in the high density areas,” Ms Page said.

“It is much more costly to set up a centre near the CBD than it is in a suburban area, particularly a new development.”

Cathy McCarthy with students at the Betty Spears centre in Tempe. Picture: Sam Mooy
Cathy McCarthy with students at the Betty Spears centre in Tempe. Picture: Sam Mooy

Ms Page also called on councils to update outdated planning controls to make their areas more attractive and viable for prospective operators.

She said councils should remove caps on the number of places at each centre.

“This is a hangover because we now have national quality standards so there’s no reason why you’d restrict a centre to 40 places, in fact that would be unviable for most,” Ms Page said.

Childcare NSW CEO Brianna Casey said lack of planning coordination is a major issue.

“In some areas you are facing wait lists of years not months, yet the suburb next door you can have no problems getting into,” she said.

“We need councils speaking with state planning departments and the federal government about whether or not services are required in an area.

Jasmine Ringland drops off her son Lachlan, 2, at the Betty Spears childcare centre in Tempe. Picture: John Appleyard
Jasmine Ringland drops off her son Lachlan, 2, at the Betty Spears childcare centre in Tempe. Picture: John Appleyard

“And if they’re not, whether or not they should be granting licences to new operators.”

The data reveals there is a huge difference in the number of services available, with many more centres in suburbs further away from the city.

Hunters Hill has only one centre while Bankstown has 95.

The areas with most vacancies were Liverpool (1240), Campbelltown (1120), Blacktown (860) and Parramatta (560).

Penrith, Fairfield and Gosford reported at least 500 vacancies each day on average.

Director of Betty Spears childcare at Tempe Cathy McCarthy said parents should be able to choose childcare based on indicators of quality.

“But for many families their choices are limited by cost and availability which is tied to where you live and work,” she said

LGA Number of childcare centres No. with vacancies Vacancies (avg daily)
Hunters Hill 1 n/a n/a
Lane Cove 12 7 20
Woollahra 11 7 20
Strathfield 7 5 30
Manly 13 9 40
North Sydney 24 14 40
Botany Bay 13 11 50
Marrickville 21 10 50
Mosman 14 11 50
Waverley 30 18 50
Ashfield 18 14 70
Leichhardt 22 13 70
Blue Mtns 18 15 80
Kogarah 15 8 80
Willoughby 28 20 90
Burwood 11 7 100
Canada Bay 27 13 110
Auburn 21 15 130
Ku-ring-gai 25 18 150
Pittwater 20 17 150
Randwick 43 24 160
Rockdale 33 19 160
Hurstville 33 26 180
Holroyd 31 23 190
Warringah 49 38 230
Camden 21 21 250
Ryde 43 35 290
Hawkesbury 26 22 300
Hornsby 57 40 300
Sutherland 79 47 320
Sydney 70 45 320
The Hills Shire 61 49 390
Bankstown 87 58 410
Canterbury 55 44 420
Gosford 58 53 500
Penrith 73 59 510
Fairfield 62 57 550
Wollindilly 16 15 560
Wyong 51 48 570
Parramatta 87 76 590
Blacktown 122 111 860
Campbelltown 67 64 1120
Liverpool 86 78 1240
TOTAL 11800

Source: Department of Education, September quarter 2013. Long daycare reported vacancies by LGA

Add your comment to this story

To join the conversation, please Don't have an account? Register

Join the conversation, you are commenting as Logout

Original URL: https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/newslocal/competitions/sydney-childcare-vacancies-city-parents-face-huge-waiting-lists-while-west-struggles-to-fill-places/news-story/60603b4df02917b58305b792a0071d53