Putin Ukraine peace plan slammed as ‘offensive’ and ‘absurd’

The Russian leader has set out Moscow’s most detailed Ukraine peace plan yet – but it’s immediately been called “absurd” and “offensive”.

Russian President Vladimir Putin has floated a possible peace plan for the conflict in Ukraine but it has already been rubbished as “offensive”.

Under Moscow’s ceasefire proposal, Russia would be left with far more territory than it has been able to conquer.

It comes a day before a peace summit on the war is due to kick off in Switzerland - to which Russia has not been invited.

In a combative speech in Moscow, Putin said Russia would halt its offensive only if Ukraine fully withdraws its troops from the east and south and drops its bid for NATO membership.

The plan states Ukraine effectively surrender to Moscow if it wants to open peace talks, drawing anger and rebukes from Kyiv and the West.

The countries have been locked in bloody conflict for more than two years, and no direct peace talks have been held since the first weeks of Russia’s campaign, when it was advancing on the Ukrainian capital.

Russia's President Vladimir Putin meets with the Russian Foreign Ministry leadership in Moscow on June 14, 2024. (Photo by NATALIA KOLESNIKOVA / AFP)

Kyiv has called for Russia’s full withdrawal from its internationally recognised territory, including the annexed Crimean peninsula, as part of any peace deal.

President Volodymyr Zelensky, who hopes to marshal international support for that position this weekend, slammed Putin’s demands as a territorial “ultimatum” reminiscent of Adolf Hitler.

“Ukrainian troops must be completely withdrawn from the Donetsk People’s Republic, the (Luhansk) People’s Republic, Kherson and Zaporizhzhia regions,” Putin said in a televised address to Russian diplomats in Moscow.

Russia claimed to have annexed the four regions in 2022, despite not having full control over any of them.

The regional capitals of Kherson and Zaporizhzhia are still in Ukrainian hands — meaning Putin is demanding Ukraine cede swathes of territory under its control as a precondition for negotiations.

“As soon as Kyiv says it is ready to do this and begins really withdrawing troops and officially renounces plans to join NATO, we will immediately, literally that very minute, cease fire and begin talks,” Putin said.

Russia was seeking “Ukraine’s neutral, non-aligned, non-nuclear status, its demilitarisation and de-Nazification,” he added.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky and Pope Francis during a bilateral meeting on the sidelines of the G7 Summit hosted by Italy at the Borgo Egnazia resort in Savelletri, Apulia. (Photo by Handout / VATICAN MEDIA / AFP)

‘Ultimatum’

Kyiv immediately attacked the demands.

“These messages are messages of ultimatum... it’s the same thing Hitler did,” Mr Zelensky told Italy’s Sky TG24 TV channel on the sidelines of the G7 summit.

“Nazism has already arrived and now it has Putin’s face,” he added.

Ukraine’s foreign ministry said the “absurd” demands showed Russia wanted “the occupation of Ukraine, the destruction of the Ukrainian people”.

Presidential adviser Mykhailo Podolyak said Putin’s plan was a “complete sham” and “offensive to common sense”.

And Ukraine’s Western backers also blasted Russia over the proposals. At the end of a NATO meeting in Brussels, US Pentagon chief Lloyd Austin said: “Putin has occupied, illegally occupied, sovereign Ukrainian territory. He is not in any position to dictate to Ukraine what they must do to bring about peace.”

A firefighter trying to stop a fire at an industrial facility damaged following an air strike, in the Kyiv region this week. (Photo by Ukraine Emergency Service / AFP)

Jens Stoltenberg, the alliance’s chief, said Putin was not acting in “good faith”.

“This is a proposal that actually means that Russia should achieve their war aims, by expecting that Ukrainians should give up significantly more land than Russia has been able to occupy so far,” he said.

Ukraine has said it will only countenance peace if Russia fully withdraws. It sees any halt in fighting on Moscow’s terms as a chance for Russia to regroup for another attack, with the goal of capturing the entire country.

Putin on Friday said Moscow could let Ukraine keep “sovereignty” of the southern Kherson and Zaporizhzhia regions, “on the condition that Russia has a strong land link with Crimea”.

Military analysts have long said Russia wanted to control a “land bridge” between Russia and the Crimean peninsula, along the southern coast of Ukraine.

In public, Putin and top Russian officials have typically tried to justify their offensive by saying they were protecting ethnic Russians and Russian speakers in eastern Ukraine from a “neo-Nazi” regime in Kyiv, rather than attempting to conquer territory.

Ukraine and the West have always rejected those allegations as baseless and say Russia’s military actions are naked imperial-style aggression.

Russia’s foreign ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova said later on Friday that rejecting Putin’s demands was “depriving the citizens of Ukraine of a real chance of peace”.

US President Joe Biden and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky arrive to sign a bilateral security agreement at the Masseria San Domenico on the sidelines of the G7 Summit. (Photo by Mandel NGAN / AFP)

‘Trick’

Putin’s comments came a day before heads of state and senior officials from some 90 countries and organisations are set to gather in Switzerland for a major summit on peace in Ukraine.

Kyiv will use the forum to outline its own peace agenda and rally international support behind it.

Russia was not invited and Putin on Friday dismissed the initiative as a “trick” to distract attention.

Ukraine has struggled on the battlefield in 2024, facing shortages in manpower and ammunition as well as hold-ups to Western military aid.

Soldiers near the front lines in the eastern Donetsk region told AFP of an intensification of Russian attacks over the last two weeks.

Moscow last month launched a new ground assault on the northeastern Kharkiv region, further stretching Ukrainian forces.

Originally published as Putin Ukraine peace plan slammed as ‘offensive’ and ‘absurd’