‘Control him’: Donald Trump clashes with judge at his civil trial in a New York court

Donald Trump took multiple swipes at the judge during his civil fraud case in New York but

Former US President Donald Trump prepares to testify during his trial at New York State Supreme Court in New York, on November 6, 2023. Picture: AFP.

A combative Donald Trump clashed repeatedly with the judge on Monday as he took the stand in the New York civil fraud case threatening to cripple his real estate empire.

About 20 minutes into the hearing, New York Supreme Court Justice Arthur Engoron appeared fed up with Mr Trump’s longwinded responses to questions that required a simple “yes or no” answer.

At one point, Mr Trump told the court that even if an allegation were outside the statute of limitations, “I’m sure the judge will rule against me, because he always rules against me”.

“You and every other Democratic district attorney, AG, U.S. Attorney were coming after me from 15 different sides. All Democrats, all Trump haters.”

The judge told the former president “this is not a political rally” after admonishing him to keep his answers short.

“Please, just answer the questions, no speeches,” Mr Engoron added before asking one of Mr Trump’s lawyers, Christopher Kise, to “control your client.”

“You can attack me, you can do whatever you want. But answer the question.”

But Mr Trump, who has claimed the judge is politically biased against him, continued to rant off topic, prompting another warning from Mr Engoron.

“That was a simple yes-no question; we got another speech,” the judge said to Mr Kise.

“I beseech you to control him if you can. If you can’t, I will. I will excuse him and I will draw every negative inference that I can. Do you understand that?”

After further tense exchanges between the judge and Mr Trump’s lawyers, the former president remained defiant.

“This is a very unfair trial … I hope the public is watching,” he said.

Mr Trump, the first former US president to take the stand as a defendant in a court case in more than a century, complained in testimony about what he called a “very unfair” and “crazy trial” brought by Democrats “coming after me from 15 different sides.”

The 77-year-old Mr Trump, dressed in a dark blue suit and tie with an American flag on his lapel, was sworn in shortly after 10am local time (2am Tuesday AET) to begin his testimony.

Former US President Donald Trump prepares to testify during his trial at New York State Supreme Court in New York, on November 6, 2023. Picture: AFP.

Mr Trump, his eldest sons Don Jr and Eric, and other Trump Organisation executives are accused of exaggerating the value of their real estate assets by billions of dollars to obtain more favourable bank loans and insurance terms.

Testifying under oath, Mr Trump dismissed allegations that the company’s statements of financial condition were fraudulent, and said “they were not really documents that the banks paid much attention to.” He said the value of the “Trump brand” was also not taken into account in the valuations of his real estate assets.

“I became president because of my brand,” Mr Trump said under questioning from Kevin Wallace, a lawyer for the New York attorney general’s office which brought the case.

Before taking the stand, Mr Trump, the frontrunner for the 2024 Republican presidential nomination, spoke to reporters outside the courtroom, denouncing the case as “election interference.”

“It’s a very sad situation,” he said.

“It usually takes place in third world countries and banana republics.”

Former US President Donald Trump makes a statement as he arrives to testify during his trial in New York State Supreme Court on November 06, 2023 in New York City. Picture: AFP.

‘Numbers, my friends, don’t lie’

New York State Attorney-General Letitia James told reporters before Mr Trump’s arrival that the former president had “consistently misrepresented and inflated the value of his assets.” “Before he takes the stand, I am certain that he will engage in name-calling and taunts and race-baiting and call this a witch hunt,” Ms James said. “But at the end of the day, the only thing that matters are the facts and the numbers.

“And numbers, my friends, don’t lie.”

Mr Trump has repeatedly attacked Ms James, who is Black, as “racist,” and has also gone after Mr Engoron, calling the judge “unhinged” and a “Trump-hating radical left, Democrat operative.” Mr Engoron has responded by slapping Mr Trump with $15,000 (A$23,000) in fines for violating a partial gag order imposed after he bashed the judge’s clerk on social media.

Trump’s testimony follows that of his sons Don Jr. and Eric, who took the stand last week and blamed accountants for any inaccuracies in the financial statements of the company.

According to The Washington Post, the last former president to testify publicly as a defendant was Theodore Roosevelt, who took the stand during a 1915 libel trial.

Mr Trump has already given testimony twice in connection with this case, both times in closed-door depositions.

The 77-year-old once and potentially future president at his civil trial in which he stands accused of fraudulently inflating those famous assets to advance his real estate empire. Picture: AFP.

First of several trials

Mr Trump and his sons do not risk going to jail, but face up to $250 million (A$384m) in penalties and potential removal from the management of the family company.

Even before opening arguments, Mr Engoron ruled that James’s office had already shown “conclusive evidence” that Mr Trump had overstated his net worth on financial documents by between $812 million (A$1.2b) and $2.2 billion (A$3.3b) between 2014 and 2021.

As a result, the judge ordered the liquidation of the companies managing the assets in question, such as the Trump Tower and 40 Wall Street skyscrapers in Manhattan.

That order is on hold pending appeal, but its potentially sweeping consequences highlight the high stakes for the former president.

The tycoon’s daughter, Ivanka Trump, who left the Trump Organisation in 2017 to become a White House adviser, is not a co-defendant in the case but has also been ordered to testify, possibly as soon as Wednesday.

The civil fraud trial is one of several legal battles Trump faces as he seeks to recapture the presidency.

In March, Mr Trump – who was impeached twice while in office – faces a trial on charges that he conspired to overturn the results of the 2020 election, which he lost to US President Joe Biden.

Originally published as ‘Control him’: Donald Trump clashes with judge at his civil trial in a New York court