NewsBite

Andrew Bolt: One miserable mercy in Bondi Junction horror is killer wasn’t Jewish or Muslim

At a time when it feels like we are living on a mountain of dynamite, it is a tiny consolation the Bondi Junction killer wasn’t Jewish or Muslim.

Bondi Junction mass stabbing offender had no prior arrests: Qld Police

A nation held its breath. Now we can thank God for a miserable mercy – the Bondi killer was a man called Joel Cauchi.

That’s right. Not Muslim. Not Jewish, either.

It feels we’re living on a mountain of dynamite, that this is actually a tiny consolation in the great grief for the six dead, stabbed on Saturday as they simply went shopping. Is this really how we must now live?

It was on only Sunday morning that police named Cauchi, a mentally ill Queenslander, but social media warriors had already declared the killer must be – in fact was – a Muslim terrorist.

That claim went viral and spread around the world, repeated even by journalists, including British Talk TV presenter Julia Hartley-Brewer: “Another day. Another terror attack by another Islamist terrorist.”

Police enter the Westfield Bondi Junction shopping mall after the stabbing horror.
Police enter the Westfield Bondi Junction shopping mall after the stabbing horror.

But soon another fake claim was trending on Twitter. No, the killer was a Jewish terrorist.

Police had already said the killer, yet unnamed, was 40 years old, but trolls, many with Arabic names, now circulated the photo and name of a 20-year-old computing science student with the most Jewish of names – Benjamin Cohen.

All that Cohen shared in common with Cauchi was a beard, but that was enough.

In the Russian embassy in Sydney, where he’s hiding from police, pro-Putin propagandist Simeon Boikov, calling himself the Aussie Cossack, tweeted: “Unconfirmed reports identify the Bondi attacker as Benjamin Cohen.”

Maram Susli, a viciously anti-Israel YouTuber in Perth known as “Syrian Girl”, tweeted to her 381,000 followers: “Media accidentally leaked the attackers name as ‘Benjamin Cohen’.”

And, indeed, Channel 7 had been sucked in, announcing the killer was “confirmed” as Cohen in a post now deleted.

The explosives had been laid. All that was needed for the detonation was the flame of a name, from police.

Joel Cauchi has been named as the man responsible.
Joel Cauchi has been named as the man responsible.

A Muslim one would have set off an explosion of fear and hate, especially after so many Muslim hate preachers and extremists had exploited the Hamas war on Israel with aggressive protests. Many innocent Muslims would have suffered, and some radicalised.

But a Jewish name would have supercharged the savage anti-Semitism already boosted by pro-Palestinian activists, Israel-hating Greens and a cynical Albanese government.

Heaven help our country that things are now so tense, so dangerous, that to hear the killer was a Cauchi, driven – said police – by mental problems, was a relief. It felt we’d been saved from a disaster.

That danger is far from over. In fact, NSW Police knows it so well that it publicly declared as fast as possible, before Cauchi’s identity was confirmed, they had no evidence of terrorism. That’s code for an Islamist.

Ash Good had a nine-month-old baby. Picture: Supplied
Ash Good had a nine-month-old baby. Picture: Supplied

And who could blame us for privately harbouring suspicions, after all the terrorist attacks already?

But here we now are, relieved – yet still having to deal with a ghastly tragedy, made more perplexing by being mysterious. Less able to “solve” with a slogan.

Mental illness? How do we deal with that?

We’re told Cauchi was “known to police” already, but not for any crime. We’ll of course one day ask how authorities dealt with warning signs, but we know too little yet.

Then there’s Cauchi’s sick “choice” of victims. Every person he stabbed, dead and injured, was a woman, other than a security guard. But are a madman’s victims really an indictment of society’s misogyny?

Now, robbed of easy sound bites to explain and resolve, we’re down to trying to find specks of good in a sea of pain.

A bystander armed with a bollard tries to stop Cauchi. Picture: 9 News
A bystander armed with a bollard tries to stop Cauchi. Picture: 9 News

That means finding heroes, and there are three so far to help light the dark. One is police inspector Amy Scott, seen on video running to confront Cauchi, who came at her with a knife until she shot him dead.

There’s also “bollard man”, if anything braver for having not a gun but just a bollard which he used to threaten Cauchi to stop him coming up an escalator with his knife.

And there’s Ash Good, who pushed her baby, stabbed by Cauchi, into the arms of a stranger, asking him to help, before she herself died from Cauchi’s knife.

Amy Scott is the hero cop who shot Cauchi dead.
Amy Scott is the hero cop who shot Cauchi dead.

Yes, admire them. People who run to danger and not from it. People who save lives other than their own.

Still, I expect Australia to always provide heroes in such crises so refuse to be surprised now. I’m therefore not much consoled.

No, this was a hopeless, senseless, ghastly tragedy caused by something that we know now we’ll probably never really understand. There’s no comfort here, except to know it could have been worse.

But how much comfort is that?

Originally published as Andrew Bolt: One miserable mercy in Bondi Junction horror is killer wasn’t Jewish or Muslim

Andrew Bolt
Andrew BoltColumnist

With a proven track record of driving the news cycle, Andrew Bolt steers discussion, encourages debate and offers his perspective on national affairs. A leading journalist and commentator, Andrew’s columns are published in the Herald Sun, Daily Telegraph and Advertiser. He writes Australia's most-read political blog and hosts The Bolt Report on Sky News Australia at 7.00pm Monday to Thursday.

Add your comment to this story

To join the conversation, please Don't have an account? Register

Join the conversation, you are commenting as Logout

Original URL: https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/news/opinion/andrew-bolt/bolt-one-miserable-mercy-in-bondi-junction-horror-is-killer-wasnt-jewish-or-muslim/news-story/a15cad55e10ee28a22a6fb51b6184f9e