NSW Police in embarrassing backdown over alleged tablecloth heist in Barangaroo
Red-faced NSW police are now facing a bill of thousands of dollars in costs over their bungled pursuit of an alleged heist of fine dining tablecloths from a Sydney restaurant in Barangaroo.
NSW
Don't miss out on the headlines from NSW. Followed categories will be added to My News.
Exclusive: An alleged heist of fine dining tablecloths from a flash Barangaroo restaurant has unleashed an extraordinary series of events and exposed an allegedly “improper and unreasonable” police investigation.
Red-faced NSW police are now facing a bill of thousands of dollars in costs over their bungled pursuit of the case, and the man who was at the centre of the case is demanding an apology and an internal investigation into the conduct of the officers involved.
Trouble started in the busy Christmas season last year when an accusation was made that a linen supply and service company had stolen a bundle of their white table clothes and napkins during a service pick-up from a waterfront restaurant.
The restaurant is not involved or responsible in any way for the allegations.
But the target of the complaint Mark McKane who runs local linen supply company, Superior Linen Services, said the accusation was completely wrong.
Mr McKane said the 30 odd tablecloths and accompanying napkins he picked up were his own.
Mr McKane said several companies supply tablecloths and linen to restaurants in the same building and their linen is the same colour and can be easy to mix up.
Mr McKane said a phone call could have resolved any dispute if there was thought to be a mix up instead of calling in police.
When he provided a delivery docket for the tablecloths and napkins to the restaurant, police didn’t take any notice – telling him the docket could have been made up at any time.
He also gave police contact names to corroborate his version of events, but again police failed to follow up those lines of inquiry.
And when police contacted him saying he was to be charged with “larceny”, over the missing tablecloths pick-up, he claims the police reversed the onus of proof – telling the shocked Mr McKane he would have to prove he did not steal the tablecloths rather than the police prove that he did.
The police have since been forced into an embarrassing back down in court, withdrawing the charges without ever even serving a brief of evidence.
Magistrate Erin Kennedy has also ordered the police to pay Mr McKane’s costs.
His lawyer Danny Eid told the Local Court the offence of larceny was serious and required “a reasonably thorough and professional objective investigation”. He said the police conduct in the investigation was very poor and unreasonable.
MORE NEWS
AFP overtime pay scandal hits cops
Crime chief’s rapid rise to power exposed
How watchdog potentially bungled Westpac child sex affair
How a cop on $120K gambled $1m in eight years
“The extent of the investigation seemingly appears to be minimal and misguided… it was clearly insufficient…prior to commencing proceedings,” Mr Eid told the court.
Mr Eid said police did not follow up lines of inquiry despite being given the names of potential witnesses, they misled and lied to Mr McKane by not revealing to him that they had already decided to charge him while at the same time inviting him to give a version of events that police said could influence whether he was charged or not.
Mr Eid said he was also told the constable in charge of the case was directed “not to supply the brief of evidence” to the defence despite a court order to do so.
Mr Eid told the court the reversal of the onus of proof for Mr McKane to prove he didn’t steal the tablecloths was “erroneous and impermissible”.
Mr McKane has lodged a complaint with internal affairs and the law enforcement watchdog demanding an apology and an investigation into the circumstances surrounding the case.
A spokeswoman for NSW police said a complaint was received after the finalisation of the court matter.
“As the assessment of the information provided by the complainant is in its infancy, it would be inappropriate to comment at this time,” said the spokeswoman.