Exiled Wallaby Israel Folau declares he has been vindicated by an apology and multi-million dollar settlement
Israel Folau on Wednesday night declared he was vindicated by Rugby Australia’s dramatic cave-in, which included an apology to the former Wallaby and a multi-million dollar settlement. RA boss Raelene Castle is seeing it differently.
NSW
Don't miss out on the headlines from NSW. Followed categories will be added to My News.
A defiant Rugby Australia boss Raelene Castle has declared she won’t be stepping down from her job and denied she had “got it wrong” over sacking star player Israel Folau.
At a media conference today, Ms Castle refused to reveal the cost of the settlement to Rugby Australia, saying the settlement was “for commercial reasons” and she also claimed “we didn’t back down”.
Both Rugby Australia and Folau issued a joint statement with apologies late yesterday after the eight-month saga over his termination following a social media post that gays would go to hell.
Pressed today on if Folau could return to the game, Ms Castle said “never say never right?”.
MORE ON ISRAEL FOLAU
‘NRL can’t stop clubs negotiating with Folau’
Kent: Folau decision in lap of the gods
Israel Folau: ‘I won’t stop spreading word of God’
‘Not a Christian’: Folau’s ugly religious divide
“It would be crazy for me to say that,” she said. “What I’m saying is I think we have the value disalignment and at the end of the day I don’t believe he would sign under the current player contract.
“At the end of the day we just parted ways. That’s not a discussion. At the end of the day his contract has been terminated. It’s clear to see our values are not aligned.”
Ms Castle said she had not spoken to the board about her future. Asked if she would be stepping down, she replied: “No, this is a commercial decision we’ve made that everyone’s comfortable with.”
She also denied she had concerns about the future of her job, saying “no, these jobs are not easy”.
Asked if she had got it wrong, Ms Castle said: “No we didn’t get it wrong. We stood up for the values of Rugby Australia, the person who chose to breach the code of conduct was found guilty, his contract was ultimately terminated because of that. That stands up and continues to say this is an inclusive sport.”
“It gave us cost certainty, it allowed us to not have the uncertainty of a trial.”
Asked if things could have been handled differently, she said “we tried”.
“We tried all along to try and handle this in a way that gets the game…I’m personally really sad we found ourselves in this situation.”
“We stand by our decision and the process we went through.”
She said the RA had insurance but wouldn’t reveal how much of it would cover the settlement.
“It has been really difficult for everyone involved, it has not been easy,” she said. “The main reason we are here today is because Rugby Australia stood up for its values.”
Ms Castle’s comments on Thursday follow exiled Wallaby star Folau saying on Wednesday he felt ‘vindicated’ after extracting an apology and a multi-million dollar payout from Rugby Australia.
Rugby Australia apologised and was forced into an out-of-court settlement with the former Australia fullback, who was seeking $14 million compensation for his “wrongful termination” by the Aussie rugby union body over his April social media post saying hell awaits gay people.
While the amount of money has not been disclosed, it is understood that after 14 hours of mediation the payout is $8 million.
However, Rugby Australia is said to be privately saying the payout figure is only half what has been reported although it is unclear how much of the settlement would include the covering of Folau’s legal costs.
Rugby Australia apologised, saying it “acknowledges and apologises for any hurt or harm caused to the Folaus”.
Folau also apologised in a joint statement, saying he does not condone discrimination on the grounds of sexuality and his original comment “reflected Mr Folau’s genuinely held religious beliefs, and Mr Folau did not intend to harm or offend any person when he uploaded the social media post”.
Later, in a joint video statement with his wife Maria, Folau said they were “extremely pleased” with the settlement and apology.
“We have been vindicated and can now move on with our lives to focus on our faith and our family,” he said.
“We started this journey on behalf of all people of faith to protect their rights of freedom of speech and religion.
“We now look forward to the federal government enacting the legislation necessary to further protect and strengthen these rights for all Australians.”
WHERE NEXT FOR CASTLE?
Questions are now being raised about the judgment of Rugby Australia chief executive Raelene Castle, who has presided over a year of turmoil, including the Wallabies’ humiliating World Cup loss against England and the subsequent resignation of coach Michael Cheika.
In a letter to Rugby Australia stakeholders, Ms Castle said: “The terms of the settlement are confidential but importantly Israel’s legal claim has been withdrawn and whilst we were very confident in our legal position, this outcome provides certainty for Rugby Australia and allows us to avoid incurring ongoing legal costs and the risks and distractions of a lengthy trial.”
Free speech advocates and religious groups welcomed the outcome but also warned an “increasingly censorial culture” was making it impossible to express religious views freely and that the federal government’s proposed new religious laws were not enough to protect people of faith.
The Australian Christian Lobby, which donated $100,000 to Folau for his legal fees after he was black-listed by GoFundMe, says people of faith need clear protections to speak openly about their beliefs.
“We look forward to the federal government producing reforms that prevent taxing and drawn-out legal processes like this in future,” managing director Martyn Iles said.
“We trust that this sets a clear precedent for every bureaucrat, manager, or person in a position of power, that they cannot ruin someone’s career because they don’t like what they believe.
“It is disproportionate in the extreme to end someone’s career simply because they have said something controversial.”
One Nation Upper House MP Mark Latham said the case does have implications as a test case for religious freedom because “essentially Rugby Australia didn’t get away with it” and also called on the NRL to lift its recently announced ban on the former Kangaroos rugby league representative.
“It’s clear by having to apologise and settle, it hasn’t been upheld, they didn’t get away with it and that makes it an important test case, it’s a win for religious freedom,” he said.
“Now that Rugby Australia has apologised, the NRL must lift its ban on Folau which clearly stands as a disgraceful example of religious discrimination.
“What right does any sporting code have to control the religious beliefs and views of players well away from the workforce?
“The NRL have had people playing the game who have been guilty of domestic violence, bashing women, bashing police and drug peddlers playing the game under the banner of rehabilitation and a second chance. Well Folau deserves a first chance.”
Centre for Independent Studies director of the culture, prosperity and civil social program, Peter Kurti said the case showed compromise was required and “you can’t have complete freedom”.
“When it comes to religion and freedom of speech in a country like ours there has to be an element of give and take,” he said.