NewsBite

Backbenchers challenge Turnbull over Clean Energy Target

MALCOLM Turnbull is staring down backbench unrest over the proposed Clean Energy Target, with more than 20 Coalition MPs raising concerns about the government’s energy policy.

Sharri Markson speaks to Josh Frydenberg about the clean energy target

PRIME Minister Malcolm Turnbull is staring down backbench unrest over the proposed Clean Energy Target, with at least 22 Coalition MPs raising concerns in a closed partyroom meeting tonight.

In a marathon meeting that required a second sitting lasting over three hours, former PM Tony Abbott was among a group Liberal and National MPs who queried the chief scientist’s proposal in various degrees of ferocity.

The energy policy — which would see electricity prices fall by $90 a year — is politically sensitive for Mr Turnbull, who lost the Liberal leadership in 2009 after committing to an emissions reduction scheme.

PM Malcolm Turnbull is facing a CET backlash. Picture Kym Smith
PM Malcolm Turnbull is facing a CET backlash. Picture Kym Smith

The others including Victorian MP Kevin Andrews, West Australians Rick Wilson, Andrew Hastie, Chris Back and Ben Morton, South Australian Tony Pasin and Nationals Ken O’Dowd, Bridget McKenzie, Mark Coulton, Andrew Broad, George Christensen and Andrew Gee raised concerns about the proposals.

About 11 MPs were stridently against those recommendations. Mr Abbott on Monday said it was “effectively, a tax on coal”.

Former prime minister Tony Abbott is among Coalition MPs questioning Dr Alan Finkel’s clean energy target proposals, which he has labelled ‘a tax on coal’. Picture: Stuart McEvoy
Former prime minister Tony Abbott is among Coalition MPs questioning Dr Alan Finkel’s clean energy target proposals, which he has labelled ‘a tax on coal’. Picture: Stuart McEvoy

But Mr Turnbull yesterday rejected that characterisation. He said the proposal would “not penalise coal, it does not prohibit the construction of a coal-fired power station”.

  • READ MORE: LANDMARK ENERGY REVIEW PRESENTED TO COAG
  • Dissident Kevin Anderson.
    Dissident Kevin Anderson.
    Chief CET rebel Tony Abbott. Picture: Kym Smith
    Chief CET rebel Tony Abbott. Picture: Kym Smith

    “What (Dr Finkel) seeks to do there is to provide incentives for lower emission technologies including but not exclusively renewables,” he said.

    Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg last night said it was “too early to say” whether his colleagues would support a Clean Energy Target.

    Australia's Chief Scientist Dr Alan Finkel.
    Australia's Chief Scientist Dr Alan Finkel.

    “Many colleagues want to understand what is the true impact on price of the clean energy target,” Mr Frydenberg told the ABC.

    A handful of MPs also spoke in favour of it.

    Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg commenting on the electricity market review by Chief Scientist Alan Finkel. Picture: AAP Image/Lukas Coch
    Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg commenting on the electricity market review by Chief Scientist Alan Finkel. Picture: AAP Image/Lukas Coch

    Some MPs raising concerns were not opposed to a scheme, with several referring to the Finkel report as a good starting point for an energy policy which could be strengthened with changes.

    The Clean Energy Target would replace the current renewable energy target by 2020 as part of Australia’s commitment to reach the emissions cuts in the Paris climate agreement.

    Labor is open to the plan, but any move to accommodate more coal power would jeopardise that support.

    Add your comment to this story

    To join the conversation, please Don't have an account? Register

    Join the conversation, you are commenting as Logout

    Original URL: https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/news/nsw/backbenchers-challenge-turnbull-over-clean-energy-target/news-story/a02c116c9da3149b25b8d6750f9fd797