Super Rankings: Have your say on the best players from every game in Round 17

His team was comprehensively outplayed but a GWS midfielder was awarded three votes against Richmond. Did the Herald Sun experts get it right? VOTE ON EVERY GAME

His team was comprehensively outplayed, but GWS midfielder Lachie Whitfield was the standout individual player at the MCG against Richmond.

That was the verdict of the Herald Sun’s Gilbert Gardiner, but it has stirred up Tiger fans.

Did he get it right?

Elsewhere, Geelong superstar Patrick Dangerfield played a blinder on Saturday night and Western Bulldogs gun Josh Dunkley sizzled against the Demons.

Our experts had no hesitation giving them the three votes, while Essendon livewire Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti got the Bombers home at Marvel Stadium but was overlooked for the best on ground mantle.

Did the Herald Sun experts get it right?

VOTE ON EVERY GAME IN THE POLLS BELOW

CLICK HERE TO SUBSCRIBE TO THE ‘SACKED’ PODCAST

WEST COAST v COLLINGWOOD

Mark Duffield’s votes: 3. Scott Pendlebury (Coll), 2. Adam Treloar (Coll), 1. Elliot Yeo (WC)

HAWTHORN v FREMANTLE

Adam Smith’s votes: 3. James Worpel (Haw), 2. Nathan Fyfe (Frem), 1. Ricky Henderson (Haw)

SYDNEY v CARLTON

Jon Ritson’s votes: 3. Marc Murphy (Carl), 2. Nic Newman (Carl), 1. Patrick Cripps (Carl)

ESSENDON v NORTH MELBOURNE

Chris Cavanagh’s votes: 3. Ben Brown (NM), 2. Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti (Ess), 1.

Robbie Tarrant (NM)

GEELONG v ST KILDA

Scott Gullan’s votes: 3. Patrick Dangerfield (Geel), 2. Rowan Marshall (StK), 1. Mitch Duncan (Geel)

GOLD COAST v ADELAIDE

Liz Walsh’s votes: 3. Wayne Milera (Adel), 2. Rory Atkins (Adel), 1. Eddie Betts (Adel)

RICHMOND v GWS GIANTS

Gilbert Gardiner’s votes: 3.Lachie Whitfield (GWS), 2. Shai Bolton (Rich), 1. Dion Prestia (Rich)

WESTERN BULLDOGS v MELBOURNE

Jay Clark’s votes: 3. Josh Dunkley (WB), 2. Lachie Hunter (WB), 1. Taylor Duryea (WB)

PORT ADELAIDE v BRISBANE

Andrew Capel’s votes: 3. Jarryd Lyons (Bris), 2. Dayne Zorko (Bris), 1. Charlie Cameron (Bris)

Originally published as Super Rankings: Have your say on the best players from every game in Round 17