Mick McGuane questions Carlton’s decision to trade for veteran small forward Eddie Betts

Premiership Magpie Mick McGuane says he hopes Carlton hasn’t been blinded by the romanticism of Eddie Betts’ return, questioning why the Blues have gone after the veteran small forward.

Eddie Betts enjoys a goal against Brisbane Lions during his previous stint at the Blues

Collingwood premiership player and Herald Sun football analyst Mick McGuane has questioned Carlton's decision to reunite with Eddie Betts, saying it goes completely against the club's list build.

He hopes the Blues haven't been blinded by the romanticism of Betts returning or coach David Teague's close relationship with him from their time at Adelaide.

Betts, who is about to turn 33, is desperate to continue his AFL career where it started, and will be traded from the Crows for little more than a late pick.

Adelaide is also likely to pay a significant portion of Betts’ contract, which means it won't cost Carlton much.

But McGuane said he was concerned Betts' recruitment could hinder the in-game development of a younger Blue who might be squeezed out as a result.

Eddie Betts celebrates with Carlton fans after a win against Western Bulldogs.

"There is a bit of a fairytale about Betts coming home to the Blues, but I think it goes against their whole philosophy," McGuane said in his pre-trade assessment of all 18 AFL clubs. "He will be 33 next month."

"Due to his age, I think he played too comfortable and not at the intensity required (for Adelaide) this season.

"He's been a very good player, but on this year's form, his best looks to be past him."

MORE FOOTY NEWS:

Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti shares his story of growing up on Tiwi Islands and how he became an AFL star

James Worpel becomes Hawthorn’s youngest best-and-fairest since Leigh Matthews in 1971

Essendon forward Joe Daniher requests trade to Sydney, but will Bombers budge?

He suggested Teague would have played a significant role in chasing Betts, who has kicked 600 goals from his 316 games. He played 184 for the Blues between 2005 and 2013, before playing a further 132 with the Crows.

Eddie Betts enjoys a goal against Brisbane Lions during his previous stint at the Blues.

"This looks like a coach's decision to me, rather than a list management decision," McGuane said.

"We know Blues coach David Teague's relationship with Betts goes back to their time together at Adelaide.

Stream the full or condensed replay of the 2019 Toyota AFL Grand Final on KAYO SPORTS. Get your 14 day free trial and start streaming instantly >

"If my assumption is right, at some stage, Teague might have to swallow his pride and acknowledge the decision might not be good for the medium to long term.

"It might just hinder the development of a younger player who is kept out of the side."

Originally published as Mick McGuane questions Carlton’s decision to trade for veteran small forward Eddie Betts