Melbourne edging closer to premiership window but must close gap between its best and worst
MELBOURNE looks on track to crack open its premiership window, but just how quickly can it get there? JAY CLARK on the Demons’ 2017 progress. HAVE YOUR SAY
Melbourne
Don't miss out on the headlines from Melbourne. Followed categories will be added to My News.
MELBOURNE is like a high-performance sports car still in development.
When the engine fires it’s one of the loudest, most powerful cars on the street.
MID-SEASON REPORT: WESTERN BULLDOGS
PATRICK DANGERFIELD: MY PLEA FOR HELP
MICK MALTHOUSE: 10 X-FACTOR PLAYERS
And the patient list build that has delivered a bevy of emerging stars and bona fide guns including Jack Viney, Jesse Hogan, Christian Petracca, Clayton Oliver and Jayden Hunt looks on track to crack open their premiership window, probably from 2019 onwards.
The Demons stunned the competition slamming home nine-straight goals to upset premiership heavyweights Adelaide on its own patch in Round 8.
You could argue it was their best win in almost a decade.
But there have also been some semi-regular tyre blowouts in 2017, testing the white-knuckle faith of the Melbourne supporter base, which is in its 11th year of a finals drought.
Understandably, the fans are thirsty for even a drop of September action, and the lack of urgency in the first term against Hawthorn, in particular, was a major let-down.
When Melbourne plays poorly, the stench wafts across the entire ground.
Clearly, they look more dangerous as the outsider, rather than the favourite, and Demons’ champion Garry Lyon said there was mental frailty at play.
“Their best football is as exciting as anyone’s in the competition, but Simon Goodwin’s greatest challenge is psychological — to get them to buy into psychologically buy into the fact that being a good side and a contender means you deal with expectation,” Lyon said.
In only the fourth year of the Peter Jackson reset, it does remain unclear whether the Demons are yet ready to deal with these increasing expectations.
They remind us of Geelong in about 2003-04, so fans shouldn’t fret too much.
The good has easily outweighed the bad at Melbourne this season considering the heavy injury toll and their age demographic. They’re still one of the four-youngest and most inexperienced teams every week.
And even without star talls Max Gawn (hamstring surgery) and Jesse Hogan (testicular cancer), Melbourne has still won the fourth-most quarters this season.
The return of arguably their two most important players over the next month will provide an enormous boost to a spine that has relied heavily on makeshift ruckmen and forwards such as Cameron Pedersen and Jack Watts over the past few months.
Watts can go back to playing as a third forward and Tom McDonald can slot into a defence that has relied heavily on Oscar McDonald and Neville Jetta.
The no-fuss Jetta has to be one of the most underrated players in the league the way he shuts down the gun livewires each week and Jeff Garlett has had arguably his best start to a season in a forward pocket.
Yet the Dees haven’t made excuses for their up-and-down form, with cool-as-a-cucumber Simon Goodwin talking repeatedly about their education and growth.
The team is still in a maturing period and they will busy at trade time again this year adding another prime big man, probably for the defence.
ROBBO SAYS:
When they’re on they can beat the best sides, but Gawn injured, Lewis suspended and Hogan out (family bereavement then cancer treatment) has meant the Demons are close but not close enough.
Most observers predicted the Demons would play finals. They are 5-5, have lost two games by single figures and can gather the troops for a finals run.
They are good enough, but at this stage of their development, they need their best players on the park, which will happen soon. Reckon they can play finals.
ADAM COONEY SAYS:
There have been games this year where the Dees have had a Simon Goodwin and times where they’ve had a Simon Badloss (see what I did there).
Losses against North, Freo and the Hawks could bite them in the back end down the back end but, similar to the Saints, their best footy is finals material. Staring down the barrel at halftime against the Suns in Alice, Nathan Jones nearly single-handedly breathed life back into the Demons’ season after a trademark Gold Coast fadeout.
Good to see the sloppy rig of Mick Hibberd out there, his form has been terrific. I’m also loving the work of chocolate milk-drinking, owl-loving weirdo Jayden Hunt. His run and line-breaking is critical to their ball movement.
SEASON SNAPSHOT (9th 5 wins 5 losses 111.7%)
SO FAR ...
R1 W30 St Kilda
R2 W22 Carlton
R3 L29 Geelong
R4 L2 Fremantle
R5 L13 Richmond
R6 W28 Essendon
R7 W3 Hawthorn
R8 W41 Adelaide
R9 L14 North Melbourne
R10 W35 Gold Coast
THE RUN HOME ...
R12 Collingwood MCG
R13 Western Bulldogs ES
R14 West Coast S
R15 Sydney MCG
R16 Carlton MCG
R17 Adelaide TIO
R18 Port Adelaide MCG
R19 North Melbourne BA
R20 GWS Manuka
R21 St Kilda MCG
R22 Brisbane MCG
R23 Collingwood MCG
HITS AND MISSES
MONEY MAN
Former Bomber Michael Hibberd has been outstanding gathering at least 27 possessions in five of his six games. Despite an early Achilles injury, the tough and hard-running defender could still be the trade of the year (for pick No. 29) and win the Dees’ best and fairest. Great pick-up.
STOCKS RISING
Clayton Oliver has stormed into Brownlow Medal calculations with a sensational start to his second season. Inside the centre square, his speed and bravery to scoop up the ball in congestion has won All-Australian acclaim. His handballing and vision in exquisite. Only 19.
IT’S A BUST
Angus Brayshaw has played only two senior games this year due to repeated head knocks that has put his career on hold. The hard nut midfielder will aim to play in another month or so, depending on medical clearance.
TRADE FORECAST
GOING, GOING?
Melbourne looks to be going places under new coach Simon Goodwin, so it’d be surprising if anyone wanted out of the club. There may again be speculation on Jack Watts’ future at the end of the year.
COMING?
Zak Jones. All eyes are on the emerging Swan’s contract status, but the Dees would love the younger brother of co-captain, Nathan. The hard-running defender would add another string to the midfield run. The Dees may also be in the hunt for a big man to bolster their growing defence.
STATS LEADERS
SuperCoach Points (Ave)
Clayton Oliver 112
Nathan Jones 104
Michael Hibberd 101
Cameron Pedersen 99
Jack Viney 99
Disposals (Ave)
Clayton Oliver 30.9
Michael Hibberd 28.8
Nathan Jones 27.4
Jordan Lewis 27.1
Dom Tyson 25.6
Kick Rating (Ave)
Jayden Hunt +8.1%
Neville Jetta +6.6%
Christian Salem +6.4%
Sam Frost +3.7%
Alex Neal-Bullen +3.7%
Contested Possessions (Ave)
Clayton Oliver 14.9
Jack Viney 11.9
Jordan Lewis 10
Nathan Jones 9.5
Christian Petracca 9.4
Uncontested Possessions (Ave)
Michael Hibberd 20.8
Nathan Jones 18.6
Jordan Lewis 17.6
Dom Tyson 17.4
Clayton Oliver 16.3
Metres Gained (Ave)
Michael Hibberd 554
Jayden Hunt 441
Nathan Jones 436
Dom Tyson 383
Jake Melksham 360
Intercept Possessions (Ave)
Sam Frost 7.6
Michael Hibberd 7.3
Bernie Vince 6
Neville Jetta 5.2
Jayden Hunt 5
Goals
Jeff Garlett 25
Jack Watts 14
Mitch Hannan 13
Christian Petracca 13
Nathan Jones 10
Score Involvements (Ave)
Nathan Jones 7.2
Cameron Pedersen 7
Christian Petracca 6.3
Jack Watts 6.2
Jeff Garlett 6.1
Pressure Points (Ave)
Jack Viney 61.3
Clayton Oliver 53.1
Alex Neal-Bullen 49.4
Jeff Garlett 43.5
Cameron Pedersen 40.5
FINALS ANALYSIS
Top 8 — $2.10
Flag — $26
It’s a challenging draw that confronts Melbourne over the next two months but the Dees have a big-game appetite. It’s the lower-placed teams, strangely, which can test them the most. The two games against Collingwood will determine whether they take Fremantle’s spot in the eight.
Odds: TAB
Originally published as Melbourne edging closer to premiership window but must close gap between its best and worst
Dees coach Goodwin addresses ‘uncomfortable’ Oliver trade talks
After a year marred by injuries and trade talks, Simon Goodwin says we may not see the best of Clayton Oliver early in 2025, which may have sparked a midfield move for a premiership hero.
The emotional moment Petracca truth became clear
There is no doubt what Christian Petracca went through last year had the star questioning his future. But Simon Goodwin knew in December – his star was back and ready to get even better.