AFL SuperCoach 2024 Rookie Bible: Every cheapie and all the stats you need to know
Our experts have had their say on every SuperCoach rookie, and some opening round cheapies have surged into consideration. Here’s who to buy, consider and avoid.
SuperCoach
Don't miss out on the headlines from SuperCoach. Followed categories will be added to My News.
Cash cows are the backbone of any good SuperCoach team.
But picking the best basement-price options isn’t always easy — and this year we are spoilt for choice.
Luckily, The Phantom and Dan Batten have done the hard work for you with profiles and stats on 73 SuperCoach cheapies in the first Rookie Bible for 2024.
DEFENDERS
Blake Howes
Melb $123,900
Opening round score: 91 (74 per cent gametime)
Official practice match score: 44 (69 per cent gametime)
Christian Salem’s move into the midfield meant Howes was named at half-back for Melbourne’s official practice match. The 191cm defender had a promising start against the Blues, winning two intercepts early but faded out a touch from there. He finished with six touches, four intercept possessions and 44 points from 69 per cent gametime in a solid showing. Howes had an improved second-season at VFL level last year, averaging 22 disposals, six intercepts and 93 points. The athletic backman was the big rookie surprise of opening round with 12 intercepts, three intercept marks and 91 points against Sydney.
Dan Batten’s verdict: MUST-BUY. How good is round zero, hey? A SuperCoach gift given many were going to overlook. Won’t score 90s every week, but you can’t pass him up with that score in his three-round average.
The Phantom’s verdict: MUST-BUY. My No. 1 rookie in defence now with the 91 in his cycle.
Josh Gibcus
Rich $150,700
Opening round score: 76 (89 per cent gametime)
Official practice match score: 62 (81 per cent time on ground)
Gibcus proved to be a fruitful cash cow in his debut season, averaging 65 points in his first eight games as a defender, and he returns two years later at an almost identical price. The athletic key position talent was sidelined for the entire 2023 season with a serious hamstring injury, but he appears to be over those concerns now. With another two pre-seasons to add to his frame, Gibcus has serious appeal as a rookie option with his elite intercepting ability. Chuck him on your field for now. Won nine disposals against Gold Coast and eight of those were won off the opposition, including two contested marks.
Dan Batten’s verdict: BUY. As we saw against the Pies and Suns, his intercept game will ensure he doesn’t have too many stinkers, and the Tigers need to play him.
The Phantom’s verdict: BUY. Not a must-have with the other cheaper options available, but a definite on-field candidate. Doesn’t need a lot of the ball to score well.
Zach Reid
Ess $123,900
Official practice match score: 80 (92 per cent gametime)
Zach Reid in full training is great news for SuperCoaches and Bombers fans alike. The 202cm defender, who is a terrific ball user, played eight games in his first two years on Essendon’s list, scoring 60 points or more in three of his first five. But he’s battled multiple injury issues along the way, with the pick 10 from the 2022 draft managing just two VFL appearances last season. But a fit Reid has caught the eye on the track, with Essendon footy boss Daniel McPherson telling Melbourne radio the club is “really excited about what he could do in the side” ahead of the Christmas break. That impressive pre-season continued with Reid set to be a key part of Essendon’s defence. His display against Geelong was particularly impressive, taking several intercept marks and using the ball at 93 per cent from his 15 disposals, finishing with 80 points.
Dan Batten’s verdict: BUY. Job security is a huge plus and his elite kicking and intercept game will raise his floor. Would be risky fielding him every week, but a very safe bet for your bench.
The Phantom’s verdict: BUY. Great bench pick who might go close to matching the output of Gibcus.
Nick Coffield
WB $123,900
Official practice match score: 51 (82 per cent gametime)
A forgotten man after three seasons in the wilderness, Coffield’s last AFL game was in round 23 of 2021, where he tallied 21 disposals, seven marks and 117 SuperCoach points. Coffield has been cruelled by injury since then, managing just four VFL games in two seasons. He arrives at a Bulldogs side that could use another distributing defender, and his season averages of 79.4 in 2020 (16 games) and 63.2 in 2021 (16 games) shows he has the scoring potential to make some serious cash. But will he be picked in Luke Beveridge’s best side, and even if he is there, can his body be trusted? If he is in the Dogs’ round one side, he’ll be tough to overlook, and he certainly didn't hurt his chances in both practice games against Hawthorn. Coffield had 14 disposals and six marks on his way to 51 points.
Dan Batten’s verdict: BUY. He might not have the same output as he has in the past, but it’s rare you can pick a 24-year-old top-ten talent for $123k.
The Phantom’s verdict: BUY. Likes to kick and there’s a spot for him in the Bulldogs defence. On my field, for now.
Ethan Phillips
Haw $102,400
Official practice match score: 56 (83 per cent gametime)
Can Phillips be the latest SSP SuperCoach marvel? His VFL numbers suggest there is every chance he can. Phillips has been the intercept king of the VFL the past two seasons, beating Luke Ryan’s intercept possession record in 2022 after averaging 11.5 intercepts, 5.1 intercept marks and 112 SuperCoach points on his way to a Fothergill-Round-Mitchell Medal. His numbers were similar in 2023 – 11 intercepts, 4.9 intercept marks and 93 points. Having joined Box Hill this pre-season, the Hawks’ rotten luck down back saw them add him to their senior list. He played the second half of their first practice match and showed some promising signs, and followed that up with 56 points from 10 disposals in their official hitout.
Dan Batten’s verdict: BUY. After watching plenty of his VFL tape before the 2022 draft — yes, I clearly have a busy social life — I am bullish on Phillips. If he’s in round one, I’ll be picking him.
The Phantom’s verdict: BUY.A bench lock, if, as expected, he plays.
Toby Pink
NM $123,900
Official practice match score: 70 (90 per cent gametime)
Pink joined North Melbourne as a delisted free agent, and the key defender is every chance to get opportunity with the state of the Roos’ depleted backline. The former Swan’s numbers have been solid in the SANFL the past two seasons for Glenelg, averaging 73 points, 6.3 intercepts and 2.8 intercept marks in 2023 and 72 in 2022. While he should get plenty of action back there, you wouldn’t back him for an on-field slot – especially with the strength in the defensive rookie line. Pink did post an encouraging total of 70 from 11 possessions against St Kilda, nine of which were intercepts.
Dan Batten’s verdict: BUY. A solid bench pick if you’re running an extra rookie in defence but feel there may be better options at his price.
The Phantom’s verdict: CONSIDER.Another mature-ager ready to go, but is he a better option that Reid or Coffield at the same price, or the $102 Phillips? Probably not.
Jase Burgoyne
Port $179,700
Official practice match score: 67 (63 per cent gametime)
Burgoyne was used on the wing in their practice match with Adelaide and looks to be right in contention for a round one spot. The slender playmaker was a late-season cash cow in 2022 but is back on the radar after playing five games last season, two of those sub affected. Burgoyne is a good ball user but his outside game and job security are slight concerns. However, he is right in contention for round one after winning 20 disposals from 63 per cent time against Fremantle, scoring 67 points.
Dan Batten’s verdict: CONSIDER. Think Burgoyne could come into play as a back-up option for Zac Williams if he isn’t playing round one. But I sitll have doubts over his long-term job security.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS. Might surprise if he’s picked, but there are safer selections.
Dan Curtin
Adel $175,800, Mid
Official practice match score: DNP
It’s true, the 197cm Curtin scored 138 and 136 SuperCoach points playing as a midfielder at the national under-18 carnival – but it’s in defence where the No. 8 pick could have an immediate impact at West Lakes. Adelaide is short on tall defenders and the neat-kicking left-footer, who has settled in well on the track, averaged 17 disposals, six intercepts and 86 points in six impressive senior games for Claremont, showing he can more than hold his own against the bigger bodies. He took a nice intercept mark late in their first practice game after coming on at quarter time and played on a number of opponents including Jeremy Finlayson and Sam Powell-Pepper. But he didn’t feature in their official practice match.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Would be tempted to pick if he was playing, but that seems unlikely.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS. At least to start with. The Crows unlikely to rush their prized early pick.
Marty Hore
Melb $117,300
Official practice match score: DNP
A sense of KFC SuperCoach deja vu here given Hore was one of the top cash cows of 2019, where he averaged 70.6 points from his 14 games. Now, he is back on the radar half a decade later after being picked up by the same team that delisted him at the end of 2021. Hore’s 2020 and 2021 seasons were wiped out by injury and he has been an intercept king in the VFL since. Last season Hore averaged a whopping 10.4 intercept possessions, 5.5 intercept marks, 23.1 disposals and 122 KFC SuperCoach points for Williamstown, and he went at 116 points per game the previous season at North Melbourne VFL. However, Hore played limited minutes in the AFL contingent of Melbourne’s first practice game and didn’t feature at all in their official hitout against Carlton.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Put a line through him for our starting sides, but he could be a juicy downgrade option when injury strikes.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS. Unfortunately we won’t be starting with him, but get ready for when the mature-age Demon gets a chance – again.
Charlie Dean
Coll $123,900
Opening round score: 55(96 per cent gametime)
Official practice match score: 47 (37 per cent gametime)
Could this finally be the 2021 Fothergill-Round-Mitchell Medallist’s year? After winning the award as the VFL’s best young player, Dean landed at the Pies in that year’s rookie draft and SuperCoaches pencilled him – and his standout intercept marking – in as a basement price rookie. But both of his first two seasons on the Magpies list were wiped out by injury, with Dean only managing three VFL games. One of those, however, was a 93-point performance, on the back of 15 disposals, seven spoils and four intercept marks, on return from injury in the 2023 preliminary final. After tallying 10 disposals, eight marks and 47 points against the Tigers after coming on at halftime, he was handed his debut after Jeremy Howe was unable to get up for opening round. It was a baptism of fire for Dean as the Giants’ forward line dominated, but he still scored 55 points from nine disposals which is a solid effort.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. With Howe to come back in and a lot of cheap defenders around, it’s probably best to overlook.
The Phantom’s verdict: CONSIDER. Scored OK on debut might job security appears shaky.
Kallan Dawson
North $183,300
Official practice match score: 45 (82 per cent gametime)
North Melbourne’s key defensive injuries to its already thin backline has boosted Dawson’s job security, with the 194cm Roo poised to play early. Dawson was plucked in the mid-season draft in 2022 after impressing as an interceptor for Williamstown, and he went on to play four AFL games that season where he averaged 63 points. However, he managed just the one match in the final round last year where he scored 45. He may be forced to play more of a lockdown role because of the Roos’ shortage, which could impact his scoring, but his job security appears sound. Dawson’s intercepting was promising against St Kilda but his disposal was poor, giving up two big turnovers early as he scored 45 points from 11 touches.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Too expensive for a key defender with other cheaper options around.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS. Liked him earlier on, but enough other options around now to not spend $183k.
Tom Brown
Rich $154,200
Opening round score: DNP
Official practice match score: 55 (75 per cent gametime)
Brown made an encouraging debut in the final round of last year and has had a promising pre-season. The first round pick from the 2021 draft started in Richmond’s first-choice line-up in its practice match against Melbourne and he has earned selection again in the club’s official pre-season clash with Collingwood. Brown finished with 16 disposals, six intercepts and 69 points on AFL debut and averaged 77 points at VFL level. He was solid against Collingwood in their official practice match with nine disposals, eight contested possessions and 55 points.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Didn’t get a run in opening round and there are cheaper options around.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS. Not yet.
Leek Aleer
GWS $123,900
Opening round score: DNP
Official practice match score: 37 (71 per cent gametime)
Aleer had an injury interrupted campaign last season, managing just six VFL games. The Giants’ rock-solid is hard to break into but Aleer can provide a point of difference with his extraordinary leap and intercepting. The 22-year-old was given a full game for the Giants in their second practice game and scored 37 from nine disposals. He averaged 51.5 points per game from his four AFL games back in 2022.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Looks like he is still behind in the queue.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS. Like his game, but I have others well ahead in SuperCoach.
Sam Clohesy
GC $102,400
Opening round score: DNP
Official practice match score: DNP
It’s a given, the Fothergill-Round-Mitchell Medallist – the VFL’s best young player – as a basement price rookie is an automatic inclusion to the SuperCoach pre-season watchlist. And while Clohesy might be a little less developed than previous winners, after only committing to state league footy completely last year, the 21-year-old is one to keep an eye on. The 189cm rebounding defender uses the ball well by foot, is strong overhead and was a standout in Werribee’s preliminary final win, tallying 26 disposals, 12 marks, six intercepts and 120 SuperCoach points against the Lions. A week later in the grand final, Clohesy found the target with 19 of his 22 disposals. Clohesy showed some positive signs in Gold Coast’s first practice match against Brisbane but there’s plenty of competition for the half-back and wing spots, and he wasn’t selected for their second practice game.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. One to watch in-season at that price.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS. Downgrade alert. Hopefully.
Connor O’Sullivan
Geel $162,300
Official practice match score: DNP
O’Sullivan said on draft night that he is eyeing a round one start and he has already impressed his teammates in pre-season training. The versatile tall was used on a wing for a period and down back in their practice match against Carlton, and proved in his draft year he can play at either end. SuperCoaches should be hoping he is used as a defender, though, given he averaged 99 points at the national champs and 110 at Coates Talent League level playing primarily down back. However, you would need to be certain of his spot in the 22 given his high asking price, and he was named emergency for their second practice match despite receiving big wraps this pre-season.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. But keep an eye on him as a downgrade option.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS.But one for the future.
Billy Wilson
Carl $117,300 Def-mid
Opening round score: DNP
Official practice match score: 8 (24 per cent time on ground)
The lightning quick defender earned a surprise call-up for Carlton’s community series match, suggesting he isn’t too far down the pecking order. However, Wilson only played 24 per cent gametime and managed the three disposals. Wilson had a strong finish to the Coates Talent League season for the Dandenong Stingrays, posting scores of 130, 128, 128 and 106 in his last four matches. He averaged 102 points for the season for the Stingrays and 50 points for Vic Country at the national championships.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Needs a couple of pre-seasons under his belt before we can consider him in SuperCoach.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS.Not this year.
Will Graham
GC $117,300 Def-mid
Opening round score: DNP
Official practice match score: 24 (20 per cent time on ground)
He may be the least hyped of the Sun’s four Academy selections in the draft but given his athletic traits, versatility and toughness, Graham might surprise in 2024. The teenager held his own in four VFL games last season and averaged 95 SuperCoach points in the Coates League, featuring through the midfield and in defence. He got a run late in their official practice game, attending four centre bounces and racking up six disposals and 24 points from 20 per cent gametime.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Could play a role at some stage for the Suns, though.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS.For now. But he could surprise a few later in the year.
Bodhi Uwland
GC $137,100 Def
Opening round score: 41 (82 per cent gametime)
Official practice match score: 28 (24 per cent time on ground)
Uwland got a quarter of gametime against GWS, winning eight disposals — five of those intercepts — and scoring 28 points. Most famous for being our DEF-MID emergency and captaincy loophole in his first season, the strong-bodied defender played the first two games of last season for scores of 59 and 32. He then scored 1 as the activated sub in round 12. Got a start against the Tigers and scored 41 points from eight disposals, six of which were effective.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. More of a stopper as his first game showed.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS.Hard to pick him with better options around.
MIDFIELDERS
Colby McKercher
NM $202,800
Official practice match score: 55 (78 per cent gametime)
“Holy crap”. That was the reaction of North Melbourne captain Jy Simpkin when watching McKercher’s eye-catching pre-season to date. Defensive coach Jed Adcock added that a role in defence looms for the speedy Tasmanian: “You saw it with Nick Daicos and Sheezel and you might see it with Colby”. That is enough to make a SuperCoach’s eyes pop out of their head, particularly after McKercher averaged 150 points (U18 champs) and 144 points (Coates Talent League) at under-18 level. He only strengthened his standing in their intra-club clash and practice match against Collingwood, where he delivered the ball with precision out of defence and even took some kick-ins. McKercher’s second practice game was less impressive, yielding 55 points from 18 disposals, but don’t let that deter you.
Dan Batten’s verdict: MUST-BUY. Get the deadlock out.
The Phantom’s verdict: MUST-BUY. Simple.
Ryley Sanders
WB $184,800
Official practice match score: 86 (80 per cent gametime)
There has been plenty of buzz around Sanders this pre-season, making an immediate statement by finishing second in the club’s 2km time trial. Sanders was a ball-magnet at all levels in his draft year: He score more SuperCoach points than any other player at the national championships, averaging 170 points along with 35.8 disposals, and 143 SuperCoach points and 30.6 disposals in the Coates Talent League. The only question mark was over magnet-man Luke Beveridge and his ideal midfield mix, but he has played as a midfielder in both practice matches. Sanders kicked a long-range goal and dominated early in their opening practice game, and won possessions at will in their second clash with Hawthorn. Sanders finished with 30 disposals, 10 contested possessions and 86 points, capping a stellar pre-season.
Dan Batten’s verdict: MUST-BUY. Slot him straight onto your field and let him win possessions for fun.
The Phantom’s verdict: MUST-BUY. Again, simple.
Jhye Clark
Geel $123,900
Official practice match score: 86 (69 per cent gametime)
Clark came to the Cats with plenty of fanfare but injury restricted him to just one game, where he debuted as the substitute. That would be the last we saw of him in 2023 after the Cats detected a navicular stress reaction in his foot days later – a good result for SuperCoaches with the top-10 pick’s price taking a hit. Clark averaged 64 points per game in six VFL games earlier in the year and is closing in on senior opportunity after impressing in match simulation. He was among Geelong’s top centre-bounce attendees in their first practice match and with Cameron Guthrie in doubt, his job security has been boost. His second pre-season match was even more impressive as his defensive pressure and midfield nous impressed, tallyin 17 disposals and 86 points in just 69 per cent gametime. And notably he attended a team-high 16 centre bounces.
Dan Batten’s verdict: MUST-BUY. Have watched him very closely down at the Cattery this pre-season and I think he is in for a strong second year. A potential on-field option with his midfield role.
The Phantom’s verdict: BUY. Attended more centre bounces than any other Cat against Essendon and his desire to hunt the ball and body should make for a higher SuperCoach floor. On-field candidate, depending on your structure.
Matt Roberts
Syd $156,800
Opening round score: 76 (84 per cent gametime)
Official practice match score: 100 (79 per cent gametime)
One of The Phantom’s favourites from over in South Australia, Roberts is back as a cash cow – and this time he has a new role. The third-year Swan has been moved into defence and has impressed this pre-season – so much so that he appears to be in their first-choice side. Four of Roberts’ six AFL games last season were sub-affected, so don’t be alarmed by his average of 31.2 last year. He could easily double that across half-back and he shapes as one of the better midfield rookie options. Roberts edged closer to must-have status by raising the bat for a ton against Brisbane, tallying 18 disposals, six intercepts and 100 SuperCoach points — even taking a couple of kick-ins. He looked very assured against Melbourne in opening round with 19 disposals, eight marks and 76 points.
Dan Batten’s verdict: BUY. Has an attractive role, as we saw in round zero, and SuperCoach scoring in his blood. Slot him on your bench — or even on-field.
The Phantom’s verdict: BUY. Almost a must-buy for me, given his ball-winning ability, SuperCoach junior career and new role across half-back. Just super efficient.
Jeremy Sharp
Frem $123,900
Official practice match score: 51 (77 per cent gametime)
According to the Fremantle’s website, the SSP signing’s “work ethic and running ability have been a standout during his short time at the club” – and it appears to have really come to the fore in recent match sim where he went head-to-head with Nathan O’Driscoll. There are good early signs for the former Sun who averaged 84 and 113 SuperCoach points in the past two VFL seasons. His official practice match performance was solid, scoring 51 points from 10 touches but O’Driscoll’s setback on the eve of round one, undergoing surgery to remove a blood clot in his knee.
Dan Batten’s verdict: BUY. Not a lock by any means but shapes as a rookie pick similar to Oskar Baker last season. Not sure I’ll be able to fit in, though.
The Phantom’s verdict: BUY. I’m stacking the bench this year but if you’re not, Sharp is a worthy option. Just don’t pick him ahead of Clark.
Henry Hustwaite
Haw $184,400
Official practice match score: 84 (72 per cent gametime)
Will Day’s injury has left the door open for a midfield spot for the early rounds, and Hustwaite is right in the mix to fill it. The 195cm midfielder’s quick hands and sidestep in congestion were super impressive against the Western Bulldogs and he managed to hit the scoreboard with two goals. He then went on to score 84 points from 17 disposals and five tackles against the same opposition in their official hitout, attending the fourth-most centre bounces of any Hawk. Hustwaite showcased his scoring potential in his AFL debut in round 23 last year against Melbourne with a promising total of 83 which featured two majors, also scoring 49 the next week to close out the season.
Dan Batten’s verdict: BUY. With Will Day set to miss at least the first few rounds, Hustwaite will get plenty of time to shine. A reliable on-field option.
The Phantom’s verdict: BUY. SuperCoach star in the making.
Jack Carroll
Carl $123,900
Opening round score: 65 (35 per cent gametime)
Official practice match score: 12 (45 per cent time on ground)
Any SuperCoaches considering Carroll when he was named in the 23 for opening round would have put a line through him after the news he would start in the green vest. However, the fourth-year Blue helped his side completely swing the momentum when he came on in the third quarter, scoring 60 points in that term alone and 65 for the match. He also attended 10 after being injected, which is a good sign — especially after Sam Docherty’s season-ending blow.
Dan Batten’s verdict: CONSIDER. His stellar quarter has put him in the equation as a midfield bench pick. But I have others ahead, even with the 65 in his system.
The Phantom’s verdict: CONSIDER. One of the surprises of opening round but is it enough to go on?
Jacob Wehr
GWS $123,900
Opening round score: 48 (78 per cent gametime)
Official practice match score: 55 (89 per cent gametime)
Wehr was a profitable rookie for us in 2022 when he averaged 62.5 points across 10 games and he returns to bargain basement price after an injury-affected season. The 25-year-old’s averaged of 26.5 last year was a result of being subbed out of one match with an AC joint injury which sidelined him for several months, and subbed into another late in the year where he scored just eight points. Wehr booted a goal and finished strongly in their first match simulation against the Swans with plenty of the footy late, suggesting he could be around the mark for round one. He did his chances no harm with another solid outing in their official practice match against Gold Coast, reaching 55 points from 12 touches in 89 per cent gametime. It was slightly lower numbers for him against the Giants with 11 possessions and 48 points.
Dan Batten’s verdict: BUY... If you’re strapped for cash. Looks to have a wing spot sewn up and is at basement price, but I think I’m going to be paying up for an option with greater upside — like Hustwaite.
The Phantom’s verdict: CONSIDER. Neat ball-user looks to be in the Giants’ plans, but I’ve got others ahead.
Josh Sinn
Port $123,900
Official practice match score: DNP
Sinn has had numerous injuries and been thrown all over the ground since he joined the Power, but he looks to have settled across halfback this pre-season. The No.12 pick of the 2021 AFL Draft turned heads in their intra-club clash but then didn’t enter Port Adelaide’s practice match against Adelaide until the fourth quarter. And he wasn’t picked for their official pre-season clash against Fremantle. Sinn averaged 87 SuperCoach points across 11 SANFL games last year and he should score well if he plays. However, job security still remains a concern.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Will get his chance at some point, but when will that be?
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS. To start with. But one to watch early this season.
Lachie Sullivan
Coll $102,400
Opening round score: DNP
Official practice match score: DNP
The mature-age recruit has been a ball magnet in the VFL, posting season averages of 131 in 2023 and 124 in 2022. Sullivan fell below 100 just twice last season and eclipsed the 150-point mark on six occasions. He put in a promising intra-club display to earn a list spot through the supplemental selection period and also kicked a goal against North Melbourne in their first practice game. It might be more of a forward role that Sullivan ends up playing at AFL level, but the 25-year-old will likely score well regardless. However, that may not be round one after being selected as an emergency to face Richmond in the community series.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. If injuries strike up forward or in the midfield, Sullivan could get a look in.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS. Great price but, nah, not yet.
Jake Rogers
GC $148,800
Opening round score: DNP
Official practice match score: DNP
Forget the height – the 170cm Gold Coast Academy gun ticks a lot of SuperCoach boxes. The tough and clean midfielder averaged 25 disposals, 14 contested possessions, seven clearances, six tackles, five score involvements and 134 SuperCoach in four huge Coates Leagues game early last year, before posting a SuperCoach ton in each of his four national carnival appearances. Rogers also impressed against the big bodies in the AFL Academy’s showcase games and he’s been compared to his new captain Touk Miller. Looked an early Opening Round contender but a back injury has kept him out this pre-season.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Another to track during the season.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS. But when he’s picked, look out.
Josh Fahey
GWS $136,500
Official practice match score: 49 (79 per cent time on ground)
Fahey’s either started or finished four of his seven AFL games in the green vest last year, but his VFL numbers were strong. Playing off half-back and on the wing, Fahey averaged 29 disposals and 108 SuperCoach points for GWS’ reserves side in 2023. The young playmaker didn’t look out of place in their official practice match, finishing with 16 disposals and 49 SuperCoach points from 79 per cent gametime.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Didn’t get a run in opening round and the Giants won’t change a winning formula.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS. Keep him on the watchlist.
Corey Warner
Syd $123,900
Opening round score: DNP
Official practice match score: 60 (80 per cent gametime)
With Chad Warner not out there, his younger brother Corey was given an opportunity in their second practice match against Brisbane. He put in a solid showing, finishing with 13 disposals, a goal and 80 SuperCoach points from 80 per cent gametime. The outside midfielder had some strong games at VFL level last season, averaging 22 disposals ad 96 points. But he remains at bargain basement price because he averaged 21 points from his three senior games last year – brought down by a score of 1 as the sub.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Not sure his job security or scoring potential is high enough.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS. Still down the pecking order, given his place in the emergencies, despite Sydney’s injuries.
Caiden Cleary
Syd $117,300
Opening round score: DNP
Official practice match score: DNP
Contested ball, tackles and clearances are in Cleary’s DNA. That’s what we like in SuperCoach, especially in a basement price rookie. Cleary put up big numbers at the national champs, averaging the fourth-most SuperCoach points per game – behind popular cheapies Ryley Sanders, Colby McKercher and Daniel Curtin. The Swans Academy graduate was also given VFL exposure with Sydney and didn’t look out of place, averaging 18 disposals and 76 SuperCoach points, including a ton against the Giants. His elite endurance and ready-made frame could help him earn a debut this year.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Might be a downgrade option down the track.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS.
Jaxon Binns
Carl $123,900
Opening round score: DNP
Official practice match score: 12 (45 per cent time on ground)
The running power of Ollie Hollands was lauded last year as Carlton’s top pick played 19 games in his debut season. But it’s the club’s third pick from the 2022 draft, Binns, who head of development Luke Power described as “the best runner over distance at the club”. In his first year of senior football, the wingman won the Blues’ reserves best-and-fairest and was named in the VFL team of the year after averaging 29 disposals, eight marks and 115 SuperCoach points. Can he push Hollands and Blake Acres for a wing spot in 2024? After standing out in the VFL periods of their unofficial practice match against the Blues, the hard-running wingman played a half against Melbourne. But his seven touches yielded just 12 SuperCoach points from 45 per cent gametime.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Keep him on your radar as a debut should come at some stage this season.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS. Huge VFL numbers last year and the Blues like him. Watch closely early in the season.
Billy Dowling
Adel $123,900
Official practice match score: DNP
In his draft year of 2022, Dowling averaged a huge 160 SuperCoach points in the SANFL under-18s, breaking the 140-point barrier on seven occasions. He may have started forward in the Crows’ reserves side last season, but he finished the year in the midfield, posting four scores of 119 or more and averaging 98 points across the final 10 games. The Crows have high hopes for the 187cm Dowling, and his height fits the needs of Adelaide’s engine room.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. A lot of midfielders competing for spots at the Crows, and he isn’t in the frame.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS. Not yet.
Ed Allan
Coll $123,900
Opening round score: DNP
Official practice match score: DNP
Despite being tipped to see action in his debut season, following an impressive summer, the tall midfielder with serious speed failed to break into the Collingwood side last year. But after a solid VFL campaign, and Taylor Adams’ departure, it might be a different story in 2024. The 194cm Allan averaged 23 disposals and 80 SuperCoach points in the Magpies’ final three state league matches, including the wildcard round win and elimination final and, despite spending most of his time on wing, might yet develop on the inside.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Hard to break into that Pies side.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS. Not yet.
RUCKS
Sam Naismith
Rich $123,900
Opening round score: 93 (76 per cent gametime)
Official practice match score: 87 (69 per cent time on ground)
Naismith was cursed at Sydney but luck might finally be going his way after joining Richmond, with Toby Nankervis in a race against time to be fit for the start of the season. It means the No.1 ruck spot – and R3 position in our sides – could be there for the taking for the 31-year-old, who showed some good signs in the ruck in their opening practice game against Melbourne. Naismith put up strong numbers in the VFL for Port Melbourne last year, averaging 37 hitouts 14 disposals, five clearances and 98 SuperCoach points, which led to him being given a lifeline by the Tigers. There is the obvious injury risk given he played two games in five seasons with three knee reconstructions, but he will difficult to ignore if Nankervis’ is sidelined for the early rounds. As the No.1 ruckman up against Mason Cox and Darcy Cameron in the official practice game, Naismith’s follow up work was on show, racking up 13 contested possessions along with 11 hitouts and 87 points. And despite getting shown up early against Jarrod Witts, Naismith posted great numbers against the Suns — 93 points from 25 hitouts, 11 disposals, nine contested possessions and seven clearances.
Dan Batten’s verdict: BUY. But will the Tigers play him and Toby Nankervis in the same side? Looks to be the only playing ruck rookie, so keep an eye out for round one selection.
The Phantom’s verdict: BUY. Nankervis might not be far off but he’s still the top R3 option if you’re not playing a loophole.
Toby Conway
Geel $180,000
Official practice match score: DNP
In his first full pre-season after an injury-interrupted start to his career, Conway has closed the gap between him and premiership ruckman Rhys Stanley. It is unclear who is ahead at this stage – the pair split the ruck duties during their practice match against Carlton where both spent extended minutes on the bench, and even in match simulation they have swapped between the ‘probables’ and ‘possibles’ sides. Geelong footy boss Andrew Mackie pondered the possibility of playing both, but with Mark Blicavs and Shannon Neale also able to spend time in the ruck, this may be unlikely. final VFL game of the year – where he registered 21 disposals, 26 hitouts, 13 contested possessions and 134 points – and his promising AFL debut up against Tim English means he is definitely worth considering if picked. But that might not be round one after he was left out of their second practice game.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS... for now. Stanley looks to have the No.1 spot but keep him mind in-season.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS. Not yet – or at the price.
Jordon Sweet
Port $158,700
Official practice match score: 61 (43 per cent gametime)
There was hope at the beginning of the pre-season that Sweet could overtake fellow ruck recruit Ivan Soldo, but the former Tiger looks to be ahead. Soldo certainly got the points in their first practice game, with this publication noting that Sweet had a “rough evening”. However, he played a half against the Dockers and showed some much better signs — admittedly against Fremantle’s ruckman. Sweet tallied 11 hitouts, seven contested possessions and 62 points in 43 per cent gametime. If Sweet does get a call-up at some stage, the ready-made ruck is definitely worth looking at. He dominated in the VFL last year, amassing 42 hitouts, 12 hitouts to advantage, 13 disposals, five tackles and 120 SuperCoach points per game for Footscray.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Barring a surprise round one call-up, Sweet is probably one we can look at in-season if Soldo goes down.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS. Even if he’s picked, he’ll play in tandem with Ivan Soldo.
Coen Livingstone
WCE $102,400, Fwd
Official practice match score: -4 (28 per cent gametime)
Taken by West Coast as an Next Generation Academy prospect last year, Livingstone was thrown to the wolves against Reilly O’Brien in the second practice game. In 28 per cent gametime Livingstone had one hitout and two frees against. The raw ruck-forward was the joint best-and-fairest winner of the WAFL Colts last season, averaging a formidable 142 points, 16 disposals 22 hitouts and kicking 20 goals. But SuperCoaches are more interested in Livingstone as a R3 loophole. Eight of West Coast’s games up to their round 14 bye fall on a Sunday, with just one Saturday early game in that time.
Dan Batten’s verdict: BUY. Looks to be the best option for captaincy loophole. Can also swing Luke Jackson from your forward line to the ruck.
The Phantom’s verdict: BUY. With Luke Jackson coming into my forward line, it’s a loophole at R3 for me after all.
Finnbar Maley
NM $102,400, Fwd
Official practice match score: DNP
The perfect R3 captain loophole with RUC-FWD status at basement price, but don’t be shocked if Maley gets a look-in. From a basketball background, Maley was plucked from the Northern Bullants in the rookie draft after just 11 VFL games, with his athleticism his standout attribute.
Dan Batten’s verdict: BUY... but only as an R3 loophole. Livingstone looks to have a better fixture, though.
The Phantom’s verdict: CONSIDER. If you are after a loophole in your starting team.
Will Verrall
Melb $123,900
Opening round score: DNP
Official practice match score: 7 (12 per cent time on ground)
The second-year ruckman was given some opportunity during both practice matches after an injury-interrupted season last year at VFL level. Verrall averaged 16 hitouts, 10 touches and 66 points per game across nine VFL games in 2023. Somewhat undersized at 199cm, Verrall is Melbourne’s most recognised ruckman behind Gawn and may have to be called upon at some stage in 2024.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Won’t be playing unless Max Gawn goes down.
The Phantom’s verdict: PASS.
FORWARDS
Harley Reid
WCE $207,300, Mid
Official practice match score: 88 (73 per cent time on ground)
The debate rolls around each year about whether we should fork out the big bucks for the top pick. But Reid was just about sign, sealed and delivered as a SuperCoach lock halfway through his draft year. Reid averaged an impressive 102 SuperCoach points and 19.3 touches from his three VFL games against senior bodies. While spending extended stints up forward, he also went at 135 points per game Coates Talent League and averaged 112 at the national championships. Still not convinced? West Coast coach Adam Simpson has already flagged that he will play primarily as a defender, where he starred at the national championships as a bottom-ager and averaged 113 SuperCoach points. A possible season-keeper at $207k — don’t let one underwhelming practice game sway you.
Dan Batten’s verdict: MUST-BUY. Your funeral if you leave him out.
The Phantom’s verdict: MUST-BUY. Don’t fade him.
Shaun Mannagh
Geel $117,300, Mid
Official practice match score: 44 (27 per cent time on ground)
Mature-age recruits are worth their weight in gold in SuperCoach, especially when they are proven points scorers at state league level and come in at a bargain basement price. The 26-year-old tore the VFL to shreds last year, averaging 25 disposals, 5.6 tackles, 4.7 clearances and 117 SuperCoach points, along with kicking 40 goals. His dominant season included seven 130-plus totals, with three consecutive monsters of 160, 163 and 153 in the back-half of the year. However, the fact he only came on in the third quarter of Geelong’s first practice game against Carlton raised a big red flag. Mannagh might not be the lock we thought he was, but he showed what he is capable of in limited gametime against Essendon with eight touches and a goal.
Dan Batten’s verdict: WAIT. If he is named in the 22, I reckon he is a risk worth taking despite his questionable job security. If not, consider him in-season.
The Phantom’s verdict: CONSIDER. Watch and wait with interest because if he’s playing, he’s probably scoring well.
Finlay Macrae
Coll $152,600
Opening round score: DNP
Official practice match score: 29 (36 per cent time on ground)
Taylor Adams out, Fin Macrae in? That’s the dream scenario for SuperCoaches at Collingwood this year. The younger brother of Bulldog Jack, Macrae couldn’t do much more at state league level, averaging 26 disposals, 10 contested possessions, six tackles, six score involvements and 102 SuperCoach points in 2023, following on from a 106-point average in 2022. And that was despite an injury-interrupted pre-season. There have been glimpses at AFL level, too, but his time in the senior side has been severely sub-affected. We saw it on show in their intra-club and practice games, suggesting Macrae has lifted his game. The Pies have continually said that are happy with his development, but we may have to scratch him off our plans after he sat out the entire first half against Richmond. He performed strongly once he did get a run, though, tallying 10 disposals, six contested possessions, four clearances and 29 points from 36 per cent gametime. But he was an emergency for their opening round encounter.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Even if he does get picked for round one, his job security is far too shaky.
The Phantom’s verdict: CONSIDER. Winning the footy and scoring are not Macrae’s problems, just getting in the team is. A risky selection even if named for Friday night.
Zane Duursma
NM $193,800, Mid
Official practice match score: 81 (84 per cent gametime)
Duursma lit up games in his draft year and his talent suggests he could make an instant impact in North Melbourne’s forward half in a similar vein to Connor Rozee’s first season. The top-five pick doesn’t need much of the pill to score well, either. In one match for Vic Country last year, Duursma scored a whopping 191 points from just 22 disposals after booting four goals and setting up another six scores. But North Melbourne’s forward line is starvation corner. His official practice match display put his high-impact per possession game on full display, scoring 81 points from 14 disposals and two goals.
Dan Batten’s verdict: BUY. If you are after upside, Duursma is your guy. But picking him comes with an element of risk given his scores are likely to be inconsistent.
The Phantom’s verdict: BUY. Did you watch this kid against the Saints? In spurts, did exactly what he did against kids his own age last year – be far too good in the air and in space. Fit him in if you can.
Darcy Wilson
St K $139,300, Mid
Official practice match score: 106 (79 per cent gametime)
Ross Lyon loves players who can run all day and Wilson can certainly do that, finishing second in the 2km time trial at last year’s draft combine. Wilson, who averaged 125 points per game for the Murray Bushrangers in 2023, has the running and attacking attributes to be a solid SuperCoach scorer in his first season and his price isn’t too expensive. He impressed in St Kilda’s first practice match against Essendon playing as a high-half forward. Wilson then posted one of the top rookie totals of the official practice matches, scoring 106 points from 24 disposals and 10 marks in a superb showing.
Dan Batten’s verdict: MUST-BUY. His scoring potential may be even better than we thought judging by his display against the Roos. Lock him in.
The Phantom’s verdict: MUST-BUY. Pick him, even if you can’t get Wilson on field. Running machine looks like he’ll fit nicely in St Kilda’s mix.
Alex Sexton
GC $133,400
Opening round score: 73 (78 per cent gametime)
Official practice match score: 125 (87 per cent gametime)
SuperCoach never fails to surprise. Did we ever think Sexton would be a SuperCoach option, let alone highly sought after? Sexton has been transformed into a rebounding defender in Damien Hardwick’s first pre-season at the helm and it has been the change the fringe Sun needed with his career at the crossroads. The 29-year-old told this publication that Hardwick has given him licence to use his speed and ball-use off half-back, which works well for SuperCoaches – especially if he is entrusted with the kick-ins. With that role and price-tag, he shapes as one of the top value for money cash cows, and his stunning practice match display against GWS highlighted his scoring potential. Sexton finished with a game-high 125 points, 31 disposals and 11 marks, taking six kick-ins. Only took the one kick-in against Richmond in opening round but still had 21 disposals, eight marks and five intercepts on his way to 71 points.
Dan Batten’s verdict: MUST-BUY. His ownership skyrocketed after his performance against the Lions. Forget the early bye, Sexton is going to make us a heap of cash.
The Phantom’s verdict: MUST-BUY. Rookie of the year? That’s weird to say, but we’re living in a weird world, friends. Lock him in on your field.
Caleb Windsor
Melb $180,300, Mid
Opening round score: 58 (81 per cent gametime)
Official practice match score: 77 (66 per cent time on ground)
Windsor epitomises the term “smooth mover”. The No.6 pick bolted after draft boards in the back-half of last year with his silky skills and speed-endurance mix wowing recruiters, showing his impact per possession by averaging 98 SuperCoach points from 19 disposals for the Eastern Ranges. Windsor has carried that form into his first pre-season at Melbourne, impressing in their first practice match against Richmond on the wing where he provided outside run and found plenty of the footy. Wing roles are often not conducive with SuperCoach scoring but Windsor’s attacking style of play and elite ball-use works in his favour. His spot looks assured after exciting practice match outing against Carlton and the news that wingman Lachie Hunter will be sidelined early in the season. Windsor kicked two superb goals on the run where he put on the afterburners and showed off his express pace. He finished with 11 touches and 77 SuperCoach points from just 66 per cent time on ground, a performance that will see his ownership rise. Was picked in the 22 over Jack Billings against Sydney and showed good signs on debut with 13 touches, four tackles and 58 points.
Dan Batten’s verdict: BUY. His high impact per possession game means he doesn’t need a lot of it to score well, but Charlie Lazzaro and Jackson Mead look to have more prominent midfield roles.
The Phantom’s verdict: BUY. Love the way he moves, but can he hit the scoreboard every week? He’s good enough to do it often, but there might be some low scores.
Charlie Lazzaro
NM $181,100, Mid
Official practice match score: 68 (84 per cent)
Lazzaro underlined his SuperCoach rookie credentials by racking up 26 disposals, five clearances and 87 SuperCoach points in the final round of last year. The young midfielder has kept the momentum going this pre-season as he makes a strong case for a senior spot in the midfield. Lazzaro stood out in their intra-club and attended the fourth-most centre bounces of any Roo in their unofficial practice match against Collingwood. He averaged 26 disposals, six tackles and 106 points at VFL level season, so there is plenty of potential there.
Dan Batten’s verdict: BUY. Have him marginally ahead of Windsor because of the midfield minutes he is set to receive. But is his job security as high?
The Phantom’s verdict: BUY. Big numbers to finish last season – in the VFL and the seniors. Has shown he can win enough of the ball in a midfield-forward role alongside the other North young guns. In my team.
Lachie McNeil
WB $159,100
Official practice match score: 98 (78 per cent gametime)
After nine sub-affected appearances in 13 games last year, McNeil looks to have a spot in the star-studded Bulldogs forward line after some very impressive pre-season form. He managed to score 97 points from 16 disposals and two behinds in their official hitout against Hawthorn and his display in their unofficial clash with the Hawks was even better. In that game McNeil booted four goals and has clearly stepped up his game in the off-season.
Dan Batten’s verdict: CONSIDER. Weighing up McNeil as an option but he has scored above 60 just twice in his career. But will 2024 be different?
The Phantom’s verdict: CONSIDER. Worth some thought, but ahead of the others above him on this list? Not for me.
Oliver Dempsey
Geel $148,800
Official practice match score: 97 (85 per cent)
Dempsey has been the surprise packet of Geelong’s pre-season. Named in the VFL team of the year last season after averaging 101 SuperCoach points, Dempsey appears all but certain to play early after two strong practice matches. In the first he kicked a goal and took a big screamer and he followed it up with 15 disposals, a goal and 93 points against Essendon. The 21-year-old pushed high up the ground in both games, suggesting he won’t be stuck in starvation corner.
Dan Batten’s verdict: BUY. Tossing up between him and couple of others in the forward line. Another I’ve watched closely down the highway and I think he can be worth the extra coin. The only question mark is the Cats’ strong forward line which has Gary Rohan still sidelined.
The Phantom’s verdict: CONSIDER. Pre-season surprise packet has some weight in the SuperCoach rookie conversation.
Jackson Mead
Port $199,800, Mid
Official practice match score: 112 (72 per cent gametime)
We heard about Ollie Wines getting more midfield time. But what about Mead? Power coach Ken Hinkley said Mead plays his best footy as an on-baller, and he was thrown in for eight centre-bounces against Fremantle. The result was 21 disposals and a SuperCoach ton, scoring 112 points in an eye-catching showing. Whether that role remains to be seen but his scoring potential is clear from that effort. His SANFL numbers last year as a mid-forward were promising, averaging 98 SuperCoach points, 22 disposals, four clearances and six tackles.
Dan Batten’s verdict: CONSIDER. Is his long-term job security strong? It would be a risk to pick him over other options but there’s certainly upside, as his practice game score showed.
The Phantom’s verdict: BUY. Could get his opportunity in the early-season absence of Sam Powell-Pepper and, if he takes it, Ken Hinkley won’t drop him just because he was last man in.
Bigoa Nyuon
North $123,900
Official practice match score: 87 (86 per cent gametime)
Nyuon has moved clubs and moved back into defence this off-season and performed strongly in their second practice game. The athletic 197cm big man had 15 disposals and seven intercepts on his way to 87 SuperCoach points, also using the ball at an elite 93 per cent efficiency. Nyuon spent most of his time as a forward-ruck last season in the VFL, averaging 71 points per game. At 22, Nyuon looks set to be a senior regular at North Melbourne with the club’s depleted backline. Will earn FWD-DEF dual position status as well in round six if he holds his spot.
Dan Batten’s verdict: BUY. He’s cheap, he has good job security and as we saw in the final practice game, he can produce strong scores. In the mix for my forward bench.
The Phantom’s verdict: CONSIDER. Bench option.
Seth Campbell
Rich $123,900
Opening round score: 70 (80 per cent gametime)
Official practice match score: 20 (77 per cent time on ground)
Campbell surprisingly started from the first quarter over Steely Green in Richmond’s official practice match against Collingwood, but he was unable to have much of an impact. The small forward finished with nine touches, a behind and 20 points. After earning a surprise debut against Gold Coast, Campbell was one of the Tigers’ shining lights, finishing with nine disposals, four tackles, two goals and 70 points. As a junior he amassed a whopping 213-point total for the Tasmania Devils after racking up a lazy 32 disposals and 6.3. He averaged a more modest 35 points in five VFL games for the Tigers in an injury-interrupted first season in 2023.
Dan Batten’s verdict: CONSIDER. His opening round total puts him ahead of some other $123,900 options, but I suspect that will be his ceiling.
Bailey Laurie
Melb $125,200
Opening round score: 20 (42 per cent gametime)
Official practice match score: 58 (73 per cent time on ground)
After five games last year – four of those sub affected – Laurie appears ready to become a senior regular, particularly with Melbourne’s forward-half injuries. The half-forward played in Melbourne’s first choice side – albeit with plenty of outs – in the club’s first pre-season game and was busy, pushing up the ground and even getting some midfield minutes. He had also received some centre-bounce time during Demons match simulation. Laurie averaged 96 SuperCoach points, 23 disposals and four tackles at VFL level last year and looks to be a promising bench option entering his fourth season. He showed he has no trouble finding the footy in a forward against Carlton, winning 17 possessions on his way to 58 points. But Laurie found the going tough against Sydney, managing eight touches before being subbed out of the match in the third quarter with 20 points to his name.
Batten’s verdict: PASS. I was bullish on Laurie as a F8 option but with Kysaiah Pickett back from suspension, Laurie might be back in the VFL.
The Phantom’s verdict: CONSIDER. But after being subbed out in opening round, there are better options.
Patrick Voss
Frem $123,900
Official practice match score: 73 (86 per cent gametime)
Essendon fans were calling for Voss to debut last year but he ended up being delisted despite a promising couple of seasons at the club. Training with Fremantle over the summer and eventually earning a rookie spot, Voss played posted a promising total of 73 from 11 disposals and a goal in their official practice match against Port Adelaide.
Dan Batten’s verdict: CONSIDER. Matt Taberner had a poor game in the practice match and it’s unclear whether Voss can stay ahead long-term. But there may be better options at the price anyway.
The Phantom’s verdict: WAIT.
Buku Khamis
WB $123,900
Official practice match score: 59 (96 per cent gametime)
Khamis has challenged for a spot as a tall in the Bulldogs defence and he has put forward a compelling case. His second practice game against Hawthorn was particularly impressive, winning seven of his 10 possessions off the opposition on his way to 59 points. Khamis was one of the top forwards in the VFL last season, booting 41 goals and averaging 89 points, but good luck getting a spot in that forward line. A plus with Khamis is the likely DEF-FWD status he will receive if he maintains his spot.
Dan Batten’s verdict: CONSIDER. I like the potential DEF-FWD flexibility, but is his job security or scoring potential enough in this crowded forward rookie field?
Reef McInnes
Coll $123,900
Official practice match score: 15 (36 per cent time on ground)
There are two holes Collingwood coach Craig McRae needs to fill this year – Dan McStay in the forward line and the grunt of Taylor Adams through the middle. And McIness, drafted by Collingwood at pick 23 in 2022, has the ability fill both. But while the 21-year-old impressed as a big-bodied 194cm midfielder in his draft year, it’s as a forward-line X-factor where McInnes could make his mark in 2024. He booted 32 goals in 15 VFL games last season and posted three SuperCoach scores of 120 or more. And, more importantly, has already caught McRae’s eye over summer. After kicking three goals in their practice match against North Melbourne, McInnes was able to hit the scoreboard with all three of his disposals in their second game. He finishing with 1.2 and 15 points from 36 per cent time on ground.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Appears to be better options for a forward rookie spot, and his lack of gametime in the final game suggests his job security is shaky.
Harvey Thomas
GWS $117,300, MID
Opening round score: 40 (82 per cent gametime)
Official practice match score: 72 (72 per cent gametime)
Thomas has bolted into contention for a round zero — and more importantly for SuperCoaches, round one — spot. The first-year Giant has impressed in both practice games as a small forward, kicking a goal against Sydney and tallying 14 disposals, nine contested possessions, six tackles and 72 points in their official practice match hitout. Thomas’ promising draft year flew under the radar last season, averaging 125 points at Coates Talent League level and 86 points for the Allies, playing all over the ground. His nine disposals netted 40 points in opening round.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Don’t think he is going to be scoring enough in his small forward role.
Aaron Cadman
GWS $127,600
Opening round score: 55(77 per cent gametime)
Official practice match score: 43 (86 per cent time on ground)
After booting four goals against Sydney in their first practice match, Cadman put in a solid showing in their official practice game. The No.1 pick from the 2022 draft kicked a goal and tallied 13 disposals and 43 points. The most encouraging part of his game from a SuperCoach standpoint was his use as a back-up ruckman, a role he also performed against Sydney. He attended three centre bounces and nine ruck contests in total in opening round but showed good signs inside 50, finishing with 10 disposals, two goals and 55 points.
Dan Batten’s verdict: CONSIDER. Don’t mind him as a slow-burn rookie for your forward bench if you are strapped for cash, but feel there are other options with greater upside like Nyuon or even Khamis.
The Phantom’s verdict: CONSIDER. Had some nice moments in opening round but, as talented as he is, the role is unlikely to result in consistent SuperCoach scores – yet.
Tom Berry
GC $163,500
Opening round score: 66 (60 per cent gametime)
Official practice match score: 54 (78 per cent gametime)
Damien Hardwick is a fan of Berry and he looks set to get more opportunity this season after six games — three of those subbed in or out — in 2023. He only managed six disposals against Richmond but he managed to reach a solid score of 66, also tallying three one-percenters and three tackles.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. On a bad day that six disposal game could be a sub-30 total.
Nick Watson
Haw $189,300
Official practice match score: 53 (81 per cent time on ground)
‘The Wizard’ can have a lot of the ball, as his 34-disposal, 12-contested possession, 12 score involvement, 166-point Coates League performance proved early last year. But, in an important attribute for first-year players in SuperCoach, Watson doesn’t need a lot of the ball to have an impact. He finished with 116 points from 13 disposals later in the season and tallied 146 points against WA at the under-18 carnival, on the back of another 13 touches. He did kick five and play a direct hand in three others that day – but that’s just what he does. Could be worth paying up for, given what might be reasonably high job security. Was inaccurate with three behinds in their official practice match against the Western Bulldogs but still managed to score 53 points from 10 disposals.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. A miraculous talent who will be a joy to watch this year, but there are better options with more favourable roles at the price up forward.
Orazio Fantasia
Carl $175,900
Opening round score: 35 (71 per cent gametime)
Official practice match score: 36 (82 per cent time on ground)
The new Blue has played just 22 home-and-away matches in the past four seasons – and 13 of them were in his first year at Port in 2021. But he started that campaign with a 90 and 74 and booted 38 goals and averaged 73 SuperCoach points in a career-best 19-game season in 2017. There are a lot of ‘what ifs’ – and that’s an understatement – but those numbers mean the skilful forward has to, at least, be on the pre-season watchlist at $175k – especially given Carlton need a forward of his type. He showed some promising glimpses in the first game and finished with nine touches and 36 points in Carlton’s official practice match. Fantasia posted the second lowest score — behind the subbed Sam Docherty — for the Blues against Brisbane with 35 points from 11 disposals.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Better options at the price — and options who aren’t made of paper.
Darcy Jones
GWS $123,900
Official practice match score: DNP
Jones missed the first practice match with soreness but from all reports the helmet-headed small forward is the frame to debut early. That was the case 12 months ago before an ACL blow last April. Jones averaged 73 points in three WAFL senior games during his draft year and his crafty ball-use and running ability should help his scoring in what would likely be a forward role. However, he wasn’t picked for their second practice game.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Another to track when he does debut.
Sam Darcy
WB $123,900
Darcy said ‘pick me’ in the Dogs’ first practice match, booting three goals and showing good signs in the ruck up against Lloyd Meek and Ned Reeves. It was without Tim English, who played in the second half of the eight-period match, but it was an eye-catching showing nonetheless for Bulldogs fans and SuperCoaches alike. If Darcy manages to break into the Dogs’ side and plays as a back-up ruck, it enhances his appeal as a bench forward. However, he was demoted to a VFL practice match for their next outing despite that impressive outing.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Should only be a matter of time until Darcy knocks Rory Lobb out of the side, but round one appears a long-shot.
Cooper Simpson
Frem $117,300, MID
Official practice match score: 33 (78 per cent time on ground)
Simpson lit up a pre-season intra-club clash which saw him enter the SuperCoach rookie conversation. The dynamic draftee eclipsed 120 SuperCoach points in four of his eight games for the Dandenong Stingrays last year as a midfielder but he appears set to start his career as a forward flanker. He had an impact coming on after halftime in Fremantle’s practice match against West Coast, kicking a goal after winning a holding the ball free kick. Keep him in mind. Managed to hit the scoreboard in their official practice game but scored just the 33 points from 12 touches.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Rate him as a talent but there are better forward options around for SuperCoach.
The Phantom’s verdict: CONSIDER. Hard to start with confidence but he might surprise.
Tom Emmett
Frem $182,300
Official practice match score: DNP
Few would remember Emmett’s scores of 65 and 98 in the final two games of last year but it showed Emmett’s capabilities as a medium forward. It has been a steep progression for the 22-year-old who was playing SANFL reserves midway through 2022. Two years later and he is in the mix to fill Lachie Schultz’s spot in the Fremantle forward line. Emmett booted a goal and impressed with his work rate against West Coast in their practice match and is one to keep in mind given his scoring last year. But he didn’t feature in their final hitout against Port Adelaide.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Lots of forward around his price with greater job security.
Kai Lohmann
Bris $150,6000
Opening round score: 33 (36 per cent gametime)
Official practice match score: 99 (76 per cent time on ground)
Lohmann had an eye-catching second practice match with 16 disposals, six tackles and 99 SuperCoach points against Sydney, putting his hand up for a round one berth. Four of Lohmann’s six AFL games last season were sub affected, which sees him available at $150 in SuperCoach. The first round pick turned heads in the VFL last year, averaging two goals per game and 93 SuperCoach points. Started as the sub against Carlton and had an impact in limited gametime, finishing with eight disposals, four marks and 33 points.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Great to watch but probably too inconsistent for SuperCoach considering he is a fringe player.
ntom’s verdict: PASS. Hard to pick after he was the sub against the Blues.
Steely Green
Rich $123,900
Official practice match score: 15 (28 per cent time on ground)
Green bolted into round one contention after kicking four goals in an intra-club clash. The crafty small forward followed up that display with a lively performance against Melbourne where he kicked two goals, earning him a spot against Collingwood in their community series clash. He is small in stature but he has two years of state league football under his belt, playing for South Fremantle’s WAFL senior side in his draft year. Richmond dubbed him a Liam Baker clone in his first pre-season – and we know how highly Baker is regarded at Punt Road. Seth Campbell started ahead of Green at the beginning of their second match, with Green not getting much of a chance. In 28 per cent gametime he managed four disposals and 15 points.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. I am a fan of Green and was impressed by his first practice game, but job security is the concern.
Kynan Brown
Melb $102,400, MID
Opening round score: DNP
Official practice match score: 6 (12 per cent time on ground)
Brown burst onto the scene in Melbourne’s practice game, kicking two goals including a stunning finish tucked up on the boundary. The fact Brown impressed while starting in Melbourne’s first choice team in that games means an early debut could be on the cards – especially with the Demons’ injury woes in the attacking 50. The son of former Demon Nathan averaged 121 SuperCoach points in the Coates Talent League and 105 points for Vic Metro and would be a tantalising M11-F8 option at his price if he gets a run. Unfortunately he was given little opportunity to prove himself against the Blues, on or just 12 per cent gametime and managing to collect three touches and six points.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. He could be a handy downgrade option later in the year.
Mykelti Lefau
Rich $102,400
Official practice match score: -2 (23 per cent gametime)
Lefau is certainly ready physically for the rigours of senior footy if given the chance. Training with the Tigers over the summer, the 25-year-old man mountain was signed after a solid one-goal showing against Melbourne in their first practice match. The 194cm rugby convert has steadily developed through the VFL and had a career best season in 2023 as a key forward, averaging 12 disposals, six tackles and 77 SuperCoach points, including scores of 88, 116, 115 and 88 to finish the season. However, he didn’t exactly fire in his official practice game against Collingwood, score -2 from a quarter.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. But that emotional video of Lefau informing his parents he had been picked up by the Tigers will give you reason to barrack for him in 2024.
Koltyn Tholstrup
Melb $153,300
Opening round score: DNP
Official practice match score: 8 (13 per cent time on ground)
After more than holding his own in 10 senior WAFL matches last season, the strong and aggressive Tholstrup looks ready to step straight in and play a role at AFL level. Tholstrup makes things happen at the contest and around goal and, in another big tick for his SuperCoach cash cows prospects in 2024, scored well as a junior despite not being a consistently-high ball winner.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Ready-made frame should see him play at some stage, but round one seems a long shot.
Jacob Konstanty
Syd $123,900
Opening round score: DNP
Official practice match score: DNP
Konstanty was in the headlines for all the wrong reasons in September after a Mad Monday wrestle gone wrong left Callum Mills with a devastating shoulder injury. But 12 months ago Konstanty was in the mix for a round one before an injury blow delayed his start to 2023. The small forward managed 11 VFL games last season, averaging 53 points. He should score better than the average rookie small forward when he with his relentless tackling, laying 11 tackles on his way to a 115-point return in round 21 last year. But Konstanty didn’t feature for the first-choice Swans side in either practice game.
Dan Batten’s verdict: PASS. Should get his chance eventually, but it won’t be round zero.
More Coverage
Originally published as AFL SuperCoach 2024 Rookie Bible: Every cheapie and all the stats you need to know
Join the conversation
Five moves that won me $50,000 in SuperCoach
The 20-year-old winner of SuperCoach AFL 2024 reveals the tactics that led him to the game’s top prize, beating out more than 180,000 players across the country.
Read more
SuperCoach wrap: Norm-worthy stars and grand final flops
Who stood up on the biggest SuperCoach stage and who disappointed when it counted most? Check out round 24’s heroes and villains – and some hot tips for 2025.
Read more