AFL NAB League crisis: Talent managers silenced, parents seething at trimmed-down programs
NAB League clubs are fuming over the AFL’s cuts to talent programs, with many feeling they aren’t being listened to. And parents aren’t happy either.
AFL News
Don't miss out on the headlines from AFL News. Followed categories will be added to My News.
Frustrated recruiting and list managers are already noticing the detrimental impact of the AFL’s trimmed-down NAB League and talent programs.
The Herald Sun spoke with 12 of the 18 clubs this week and there is significant anger and disenchantment about the changes, including a widespread feeling they weren’t listened to.
Some are more outraged than others, but none are happy and they remain hopeful of a bounce back closer to the pre-COVID-19 situation, believing the cuts to the talent area were too drastic.
The topic sparked genuine passion among recruiters, who agreed to speak on the condition of anonymity but most for background only, fearful of any blowback if they were to go public.
NAB League talent managers have been silenced, while many parents aware of how the program worked previously are seething.
Watch the 2021 Toyota AFL Premiership Season. Every match of every round Live on Kayo. New to Kayo? Try 14-Days Free Now >
There was an acceptance the AFL’s coronavirus-drained finances would result in cutbacks, but talent scouts are warning the decision-makers not to take their Victorian golden goose for granted.
One high-ranking AFL club official told the Herald Sun the NAB League restructure was indicative of where league headquarters was at after the pandemic.
“I’m not sure any part of the AFL is as professional as what it was before COVID,” the official said.
“The NAB League is an issue, but even stuff like flights, the way teams move, and the professionalism on game day are a concern.
“I don’t think they’ve recovered, from a competition standpoint, to be as professional as what they should be.
“The NAB League is a perfect example of where the AFL are resource light and pushing everything back onto the NAB League teams – and they’re just not set up to be doing this.”
In a statement provided to the Herald Sun, the AFL pointed to all NAB League clubs having full-time coaches for the first time and that being possible because of the inclusion of girls’ programs.
However, the view from recruiters is that even with each NAB League club coach having “up to” five assistants, it is still leaving too much to too few, including some inexperienced coaches.
The revamp includes age groups changing from under-16s and 18s to 17s and 19s, an abridged pre-season that paled in comparison to other states, fewer matches, coaches working with both boys’ and girls’ teams, and the AFL Under-19 Championships moving to September.
It’s understood the AFL has also discussed with recruiters the possibility that boys’ prospects won’t be allowed to have their skinfolds taken, at the behest of the league’s mental health gurus.
This ruling is already in place for female footballers.
The four-week NAB League break after Round 4, when most players will scatter across the state to club and/or private school teams is another cause for concern, especially off such a brief pre-season.
There will be two representative games and VFL opportunities for the top prospects, but under-resourced recruiters are still hatching plans for how they will tackle that period.
Full-time recruiters are set to head to Western Australia and South Australia, leaving their part-timers to cover all points of Victoria.
Preparation for the AFL’s mid-season rookie draft will also be impacted, with fewer playing opportunities beforehand a problem for prospects and recruiters alike.
Most believe the top-tier players should be OK, but the fear is the kids who need more attention and development will suffer and potentially be lost to the sport.
One positive raised was the greater focus on the under-17 group would give list management teams a clearer picture on the years ahead, making future draft pick trading more viable.
The state’s most gifted young footballers started their NAB League campaign in the past two weeks without any trial games, apart from intraclub matches, after not resuming until mid-February.
They technically started their pre-season in December, but footballers trained in limited groups and some sessions were more introductory or even online at that stage.
At least one former NAB League coach from last year worked one-on-one with players – for a fee – over the summer to help address the shortfall.
“We’re going to create haves and have-nots, because not all families can afford to do that,” one recruiting manager said.
“I’m more worried about the kids’ lack of development and giving themselves the best chance.
“From a recruiters’ perspective, we’re dealing with the same system as every other club.
“We need to make sure we’re keeping players engaged and the sport strong, because it’s definitely not as good a system as it was and we’re starting to see more and more cracks appear.”
Eyebrows are being raised at the subpar endurance testing results, while several recruiters highlighted the scratchy skills on display in the early NAB League rounds that fell short of the players’ intent.
The worry is players already on the back foot last year and further hampered this season will take far longer to adapt if they make it to AFL level, at a time clubs have smaller list sizes.
The decision to shift the AFL Under-19 Championships from the June-July school holidays to September has also proven polarising.
Some recruiters accused the league of hypocrisy for placing more pressure on players only weeks before school exams, while there is concern about how many players are usually injured at that stage of the year.
The national Combine will again be held in the week after the AFL Grand Final.
The AFL cited a meeting about six weeks ago with head recruiting officers as evidence that clubs were comfortable with the many changes.
This suggestion was met with incredulity from recruiting staff, who said they had already given individual feedback and by then it was too late to have an influence on the direction.
The AFL’s head of talent pathways, Tristan Salter, said in a statement the programs were remodelled and streamlined to offer gender equality on and off-field.
“The AFL remains committed to aligning the national, state and community programs and how it can best benefit the development, skill and pathway for girls and boys,” Salter said.
“The talent pathway program will continue to focus on a holistic football program to best prepare players to make the transition to AFL and AFLW football.
“The AFL will review the 2021 model throughout the year to ensure that the AFL talent pathway program continues to deliver the desired outcomes for our players and the entire AFL industry.”
Originally published as AFL NAB League crisis: Talent managers silenced, parents seething at trimmed-down programs
Gather Round: Crows open again, Ken, Hawks set for blockbuster
One of the biggest moments of the AFL season came after the Power-Hawks final when Ken Hinkley told Jack Ginnivan he wouldn’t be flying to Sydney. Now we know when the rematch is coming.
Ralph: The key Dees developments that could save Goodwin’s job
Melbourne’s public review said it was capable of playing finals, but their game plan had to be refined, now the work begins for Simon Goodwin after a tumultuous 31 months, writes Jon Ralph.