Merger was once a dirty word in country football — but faced with the harsh reality of joining forces with old enemies or folding entirely, football clubs are leading the way in helping keep South Australia’s regions alive.
AS far as footy games go, this one was meant to be harmless. Friendly, even.
A gentle exhibition match between the old boys from Buckleboo and Kelly to help celebrate the happy amalgamation of the neighbouring clubs on the northern Eyre Peninsula two decades earlier.
“But, you know what — after all those years we still couldn’t do it,” former Buckleboo ruckman Michael Kemp grins.
“This must’ve been 10 years ago now, to celebrate the 20 years since we merged. We decided to get the past players together to have a supposedly friendly game of football.
“These are all blokes 45 and older — and obviously we never got over some of the scraps we had when we were 25. Only took a couple of centre bounces too, barely even five minutes into the game.
“We had a lot of beer and friendly chats afterwards, but there was just too many of us who, as soon as you crossed that white line, all that mattered was Buckleboo winning.
“It was just like the old days again.”
The old days, in this case, are before the 1989 football season, before the Kimba District and County Jervois football associations combined to form the Eastern Eyre Football League.
Back then, Kimba District was a four-team competition, made up of Kimba Football Club, Buckleboo, Kelly and Waddikee.
In the 1989 merger, old rivals Kimba, Buckleboo and Kelly combined to form a new Kimba Districts club, while Waddikee joined up with Darke Peak to create a six-team Eastern Eyre Football League alongside Cowell, Cleve, Rudall and Ports.
In the 30 years since, Darke Peak-Waddikee has dissolved, and in 2012 Cleve and Rudall merged to form Eastern Ranges, leaving today’s four-club league.
“When we merged with Kimba and Kelly there were plenty of people against it,” Kemp says.
“To be honest, it didn’t go very smoothly. But it had to happen. Two of the clubs were in real trouble with players.
“So merging was an inevitable situation.”
Plenty has changed across generations in South Australia’s regions — from wool and grain prices to rainfall patterns and the escalating size of farms.
But one glaring constant is the relationship between a community and its football-netball club.
Today, the social and sporting fabric of South Australia’s regions is being stretched by population decline.
Forget salary caps and sponsorships and stricter drink-driving laws that curtail Saturday night bar-takings — the No. 1 issue threatening towns and country sport is the gradual drain of people from the regions.
The simple maths equates that as farms get bigger, schools get smaller — and, eventually, close.
Technology advances and economies of scale mean one farming family can now work the same land previously occupied by five.
Fewer farms means fewer jobs and fewer families.
Even among those who stay, teenage children are often compelled to move away for school, studies or employment opportunities.
Often, that reality leaves vulnerable sporting clubs facing a difficult ultimatum — merge, or perish.
“Footy and netball, those two sports are the ones that people are still passionate about,” says Eastern Eyre president Andrew Jenner.
“Even if you’re not directly involved you still want to watch. It’s the only glue we really have.
“We all know it — and I think that’s why so many people put so much hard work into it.
“If we didn’t have that, I would be very worried about country towns.”
Sarah Powell spent her childhood at Darke Peak and now lives on a grain and Merino sheep property near Wharminda near Arno Bay on Eyre Peninsula.
In 2015 Powell initiated a Champions Academy to mentor prospective leaders within sporting clubs.
She says the health and success of a town’s footy club is effectively a measure of the vitality of the town itself.
“Sporting clubs are the spirit, or the pulse, of the community,” Powell says.
“And just like in a person, when the pulse stops, vitality is lost — irretrievably.
“That sporting club is not just the social place for people to meet, or to get some relief from the isolation of rural living. For a lot of people, that’s their actual source of social cohesion.
“It’s a place where young people come to kick the ball around or shoot some goals in netball. “But it’s also a place where they learn by observation how to be actively involved in their communities.
“They learn how to become leaders, and those vital life skills that position them really well to go on to other roles in their communities outside of the sporting club.”
Former SA Community Football League chairman and long-time bush footy advocate David Shipway tells of the role a sporting club plays in the life cycle of a typical regional family.
For any country lad, Shipway says, Mum and Dad probably met at the footy club. They likely “wet the baby’s head” there after his birth.
The clubrooms were where he staged his 18th and his 21st birthdays. In adulthood he likely met a netballer, and the pair celebrated their own engagement and wedding there.
It’s where he spent Saturdays in winter, playing or coaching, or just sipping cans in support from the sidelines.
And at the end of it all, it’s where his family and mates gathered for his wake.
This use of sporting clubs’ facilities for social gatherings is also essential to a community’s economic health, insists Jenner.
Jenner, a freight driver, says a new $1.5-million project to finally rebuild the Cleve clubrooms damaged by storms in January, 2016, is long overdue.
Winter sport has not been played at Cleve for the past three seasons while the clubrooms have stood roofless.
Jenner says the promise of state government funding to help bring a new facility to life is crucial not only for weekend sport, but to cater for residents and social activities currently lost to bigger centres.
“We’re aware that if we can do anything that attracts people to live in the towns and district, we’ll do that as well,” Jenner says.
“It’s not just completely footy focused, it’s the whole package that clubs do and we’re trying our hardest.
“With our clubrooms, we’ve designed them to be a little bit bigger than our old ones because we were losing people that were maybe having weddings and big shows, like 21sts, out of town.
“A lot would go down to Lincoln because we had no facility here to fit a 150 or 200-guest wedding.
“For us, it’s not just about football and netball and cricket. It’s about what we an provide to our community and for a town like ours that’s one of the big things — a facility to have functions and events.”
In these areas where isolation, drought and sale prices add extra pressures to mental health, latest figures show that suicide rates among rural and regional men aged 15-24 are as much as 40 per cent higher than in cities.
Signalling the vital role sporting clubs play in combating that scourge, research by La Trobe University has found that every $1 spent on a community football club returned $4.40 in social value.
The figure factors in social connectedness, wellbeing and mental health status, employment outcomes, personal development, physical health and civic pride.
SANFL community football manager Matt Duldig says the inextricable link between regions and their sporting clubs was central to the league’s ongoing push to secure the sustainability of teams and leagues.
“That’s a real driver for SANFL,” Duldig says.
“We understand the importance of the role of clubs in their local communities. If the clubs fail, the communities suffer — which is another reason why we invest so much time and so many resources in our community football program.
“It’s that important.
“The La Trobe University study also found that the self-reported mental health of people aged 18-24 associated with a football club is substantially higher than the general population, which is why SANFL has partnered with organisations such as the Breakthrough Foundation to mental health awareness through community footy clubs across SA.”
It used to be that “merger” was a dirty word in bush footy.
To many, amalgamation was a sign of failure, and pairing with another team risked diluting a club’s identity and its achievements.
Now, increasingly, joining forces is recognised as a lifeline — not just for a sporting club and its supporters, but for the community, its people and its history.
Peter Meyer, president of the North Eastern Football League in the Clare region, said while the decision to merge could be a difficult, the implications stretched much wider than Saturday sport.
“That’s the alternative — if you don’t merge, the town will die,” Meyer says.
“You lose your footy club and all of a sudden the hotel shuts down, the post office closes and then you haven’t got any facilities left.
“The perfect example is Yacka — once footy finished there, that was the end of that town. The pub closed, the shop closed. There’s houses there still but the people living there all have to go to either Clare or Port Pirie to get anything.
“Once the football team’s gone, that’s it. They disappear.”
Meyer’s North Eastern league is arguably SA footy’s most visible success story of towns and communities fighting to retain their identities through their merged sporting clubs.
As many as 17 clubs are represented in the names of the eight teams that contest the North Eastern competition.
There’s three-way mergers in Burra-Booborowie-Hallett, Riverton Saddleworth Marrabel United and Brinkworth-Spalding-Redhill.
And two-way combinations through Eudunda-Robertstown, playing under the Southern Saints banner, Mintaro-Manoora and Blyth-Snowtown.
Even within Brinkworth-Spalding-Redhill, that combine is the result of a 1987 merger between Brinkworth-Yacka-Spalding and Gulnare-Redhill.
“With a lot of those small towns the stock agents like Elders and Landmark were basically the population and when all those mergers happened everything was shutting,” Meyer said.
“We just didn’t get any incoming population to keep those clubs going so that led people to think, ‘if we’re going to keep our identity, we’re going to have to go together’.
“They could see the writing on the wall; that if they didn’t do it, they’d be folding up — and then they wouldn’t have any sport in town.”
Club and league evolution is no new phenomenon in South Australian football.
Research into Eastern Eyre’s heritage shows as many as 43 teams dating back to 1894 — names including Carpa, Elbow Hill, Union Jacks, Carrow and Smeaton — have effectively melted down to the current four clubs.
More widely, research suggests there are as many as 112 leagues across South Australia that once operated but are now consigned to history.
They came and went in both long and short lifespans; born in boom times for farming, scrub-clearing, mining and railway expansion, and fading away through mergers, absorptions and collapses as a region’s industry and workforce shifted.
Some retain a name presence today, such as the Kowree Naracoorte and Tatiara leagues, which merged after the 1992 season to form the Kowree-Naracoorte-Tatiara competition in the South-East and crossing the Victorian border.
Others were gone in a blink, such as the Rocky River association, which ran only for the 1945 season, and the Martindale association, which failed to survive beyond its 1927 maiden year.
To combat a repeat of that dire fate, clubs are using creative and adaptive techniques to ensure their viability.
Measures include junior matches using smaller teams, and allowing under-age players to switch sides to even up contests.
Some leagues within close driving distance of Adelaide have formed relationships with metropolitan junior clubs, where players struggling to get a regular match with their home team can enjoy more game time by playing on exchange with country sides.
At senior level, a group as large as 42 Adelaide-based players from teams in the North Eastern league have trained together as part of a midweek truce before facing off in their weekend clashes.
The quirk of football amalgamations is that mergers usually occur between clubs that are nearest geographically.
The challenge in that convenience is that those clubs closest by road are inevitably the biggest enemies.
They carry generations of rivalries, tussling on the field for points, off the field for players and the endless pursuit of regional bragging rights — and suddenly they are forced to come together in a cohesive union.
“But the good thing here (Cleve and Rudall) was a lot of people embraced it right from the start,” Jenner says.
“It is funny — Cleve and Rudall were the biggest enemies, we didn’t really have a lot of time for one another. But the simple fact was that on their own, the clubs weren’t going to survive long-term.
“Plus, we’d seen how it worked for Kimba Districts, so that helped as well.
“You will always have people who want to keep what they’ve had, but sometimes that just isn’t going to work.
“You just have to do what you can to battle that population decline.”
SOUTH AUSTRALIA’S FORMER FOOTY LEAGUES
Albert District Football Association 1920-1923
Alexandra Football Association 1913-1923
Barossa & Light Football Association 1908-1986 (Merged with Gawler and District Football Association)
Barossa & Murray Valley Football Association 1947-1956
Belalie District Football Association 1929-1949
Blue Lake Football Association 1931-1937
Booboorowie Football Association 1925-1933
Border Downs Football Association 1930-1932
Boundary District Football Association 1928-1934
Broughton Football League 1910-1980
Broughton Central Football Association 1912-1939
Brown’s Well Football Association 1920-1968
Brown’s Well Line Football Association 1913-1914
Bundaleer Football Association 1939-1940
Burra Football Association 1905-1940
Cardwell Football Association 1945-1954
Carrow Football Association 1920-1932
Central Football Association 1926-1937
Central Areas Football Association 1946-1956
Central Peebinga Line Football Association 1928-1937
Central South Eastern & Border District Football Association 1924-1927
Central Yorke Peninsula Football Association 1909-1921
Cleve & Districts Football Association 1909-1961
County Eyre Football Association 1931-1946
County Jervois Football League 1962-1988 (merged with Kimba Football Association)
Cummins Football Association 1931
Drainage Areas Football Association 1920-1926
East Murray Football Association 1921-1970
Eastern Eyre Peninsula Football Association 1920-1962
Eastern Yorke Peninsula Football Association 1913-1935
Far Northern Football Association 1925-1962
Far West Football Association 1924-1960
Fleurieu Peninsula Football Association 1934
Flinders Football Association 1912-1978
Forster On Murray Football Association 1923-1929
Franklin Harbour Football Association 1900-1961
Gawler and District Football Association 1889-1986
Gilbert Football Association 1921-1934
Golden Vale Football Association 1924-1928
Gordon Football Association 1923-1929
Great Northern Football Association 1936-1960
Hills Football Association 1902-1961
Hills Central Football Association 1923-1966
Karte & District Football Association 1926-1937
Kimba Football Association 1920-1988 (Merged with County Jervois Football League)
Kooringa Football Association 1925-1930
Kowree Naracoorte Football League 1936-1992 (Merged with Tatiara Football League)
Lake Albert Football Association 1946-1948
Lakes District Football Association 1945-1954
Lameroo & Districts Football Association 1925-1993
Lameroo & Western Football Association 1923-1924
Le Hunte Football League 1919-1987
Lower North Football Association 1925-1952
Loxton Brown’s Well Football Association 1926-1931
Loxton & District Football Association 1932-1940
Loxton Line Football Association 1909-1925
Marble Range Football Association 1934-1936
Martindale Football Association 1927
Mid Murray Football Association 1910-2009
Mid North Football Association 1910-1975
Mid Western Football Association 1913-1955
Millicent Football Association 1907-1914
Mount Gambier Football Association 1894-1914
Mount Lock Football Association 1921-1933
Mount Lofty Football Association 1921-1938
Murray Bridge Football Association 1922-1925
Murray Downs Football Association 1920-1940
Murray Lands Football League 1923-1993
Murray Mallee Football Association 1932-1940
Murray Ranges Football Association 1922-1935
Murray River Football Association 1919-1931
Murray Valley Football Association 1921-1934
Naracoote Football Association 1935
Narracoote Football Association 1912-1913
North Gambier Football Association 1931-1934
North West Goldfields Football Association 1935
North Western Football Association 1911-1963
Northern Districts Football Association 1979-1984
Northern Football Association 1889-1889
Olary Ridge Football Association 1935-1935
Orroroo Football Association 1914-1923
Peake & District Football Association 1925-1940
Peterborough & Districts Football Association 1911-1961
Pinnaroo & Border Football Association 1910-1954
Port Augusta Football Association 1912-1934
Port Pirie Football Association 1893-1960
Port Pirie Shiftworkers Football Association 1923-1930
Quorn Football Association 1918-1954
Rocky River Football Association 1945
Rudall Centre Football Association 1929-1947
Rudall District Football Association 1935-1940
South East & Border Football League 1946-1963
South Eastern Country Football Association 1929-1930
South Eastern Football Association 1926-1935
Southern Ports Football Association 1928-1965
Southern Yorke Peninsula Football Association 1908-1993
Spalding Football Association 1924-1926
Stanley Football Association 1915-1936
Streaky Bay Football League 1923-1987 (merged with Le Hunte Football League to form Mid West Football League)
Tatiara Football League 1911-1992
Torrens Valley Football Association 1921-1966
Wakefield Football Association 1925-1939
Wakefield, Light & Gilbert Football Association 1904-1905
Warratta Football Association 1910-1914
Western Areas Football Association 1908-1961
Western Flinders Football Association 1924-1938
Willochra Football Association 1920-1936
Wooroora Football Association 1909-1925
Yackamoorundie Football Association 1912-1924
Yackilowie Football Association 1914-1921
Yorke Peninsula Football Association 1887-1960
Yorke Valley Football League 1910-1993
Add your comment to this story
To join the conversation, please log in. Don't have an account? Register
Join the conversation, you are commenting as Logout
Dual premiership coach nabs top Norwood position
Norwood has turned to a dual SANFL premiership coach to replace Fremantle-bound Jade Rawlings, writes Andrew Capel.
Rumour Mill: Ex-AFL, SANFL stars who could play local SA footy
Local SA footy silly season is here and a number of big name players could be set to join a community club for 2025. Read everything we’ve heard through the rumour mill.