NewsBite

Expert Opinion

Gary Buckenara analyses St Kilda's list.
St Kilda

Buckenara: One huge question facing Saints

St Kilda was one of the biggest winners of the trade period, improving its list considerably despite losing stars Jack Steven and Josh Bruce. But the Saints won’t return to finals unless they can solve one big puzzle, writes list expert Gary Buckenara.

Will the Suns finally show signs of turning the corner in 2020?
AFL

Buckenara: Suns were right to refuse Martin trade

Gold Coast is stuck in a doom loop that can only be broken by hanging on to the talented players on its list. But the club did the right thing by refusing to trade Jack Martin, writes list expert Gary Buckenara.

Gary Buckenara analyses Sydney's list and looks at the club's needs.
Sydney

Buckenara: We haven’t heard end of Daniher to Swans

Sydney failed to strike a deal to get Joe Daniher to the club but we haven’t heard the end of this. Ex-Hawthorn recruiter Gary Buckenara knows all about how the Swans can poach stars (remember Lance Franklin’s big move) and he writes they’ll set the wheels in motion now to do it again.

More Stories

Was Kelly’s the best midfield game of 2018?

Was Kelly’s the best midfield game of 2018?

IT TAKES a lot to top Lance Franklin when he’s in full flight but a smooth moving Giant did just that and produced arguably the best midfield game of the season. SEE ROUND 20’s TOP 20 PERFORMERS

The Tackle: Simple fix to free agency circus

The Tackle: Simple fix to free agency circus

GILLON McLachlan is taking the Sergeant Shultz approach to clubs talking to rival players during the season: I know nothing. But if the AFL doesn’t like it — and it shouldn’t — it should take action. Robbo’s best and worst of Round 20 plus his take on Andrew Gaff’s ‘unheroic’ hit.

Punish the player, not the game

Punish the player, not the game

THE AFL needs to be harsh in its punishment of Eagles star Andrew Gaff after his unprovoked attack on Andrew Brayshaw, writes Chris McDermott. But, as Bone recalls three similar footy incidents, he says there can’t be any knee-jerk reactions.

Score review needs more technology

Score review needs more technology

AFL score review was introduced to avoid major controversy on goal scoring calls. But with limited technology and a lack of transparency, there is more controversy than confidence.

Expert Opinion
Football - Sydney Swans vs West Coast Eagles match - Barry Hall king hits Brent Staker 15 Apr 2008.

Gaff hit as bad as Barry Hall’s

ANDREW Gaff will be sent straight to the tribunal for his brutal punch to the face of Andrew Brayshaw and the tribunal should suspend him for seven matches — the same penalty Barry Hall received for his hit on Brent Staker.

Gibbs well worth wait for Crows

Gibbs well worth wait for Crows

THE Crows were made to wait in their efforts to bring Adelaide boy Bryce Gibbs home from Carlton, but their patience is being rewarded by his superb on-field form. See where your team sits in this week’s Power Rankings.

Mitchell storming to Brownlow

Mitchell storming to Brownlow

HAWTHORN’S Tom Mitchell on Saturday recorded his 11th 40-plus-possession game of the season, eight more than in 2017 when he finished third in the Brownlow.

Sport
04/08/18 - AFL - Showdown 45 - Adelaide Crows v Port Adelaide at Adelaide Oval. Jasper Pittard waits for the score review on Josh Jenkins winning goal. Picture SARAH REED

Great game needs different review

A superb run of five AFL games, each decided by less than a goal, should give AFL football boss Steve Hocking reason to rethink where the game has its real problems

The ’80s: A decade of champions and characters

The ’80s: A decade of champions and characters

FOOTY in South Australia during the ’80s was a mixture of good, bad and ugly. But what stood out more than anything were the characters and emerging superstars, writes Chris McDermott as he takes another walk down memory lane.

Original URL: https://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl/expert-opinion/page/181