‘Totally unacceptable: Marise Payne joins calls for Bettina Ardnt to be stripped of Order of Australia honour
A Coalition Minister has ripped into Bettina Arndt after her shock commentary on Hannah Clarke and her children’s murders, as calls grow for the men’s rights activist to be stripped of her OAM.
National
Don't miss out on the headlines from National. Followed categories will be added to My News.
- Hannah’s text reveals desperate effort to stay alive
- Hannah’s brother: System was gamed by ‘a sadistic person’
Foreign Minister Marise Payne has taken aim at Bettina Arndt as calls grow for the men’s rights activist to be stripped of her Order of Australia honour.
It comes after the Senate on Tuesday overwhelmingly voted in favour of Labor frontbenchers Penny Wong and Kristina Keneally motion on Tuesday condemning Ms Arndt’s “reckless and abhorrent” comments about the recent murders of Queensland woman Hannah Clarke and her three children.
Following the horrific murder of the Queensland mother and her children, Ms Arndt congratulated Queensland Police for “keeping an open mind and awaiting proper evidence, including the possibility that Rowan Baxter (Ms Clarke’s estranged husband) might have been ‘driven too far’.”
“They (the comments) are totally unacceptable. There’s no way that we can accept language that’s ever trivialises or distorts the reality of domestic violence and murders like this. Every single one is an individual atrocity,” Ms Payne told ABC radio.
“But I would say that in relation to the order of Australia, the council is an independent body. It’s up to the council as to whether an order should be rescinded in any case.”
The Foreign Minister described domestic violence as a “national challenge”, adding funding had increased in recent years.
MORE NEWS:
Sick predators using baby monitors to spy on kids
What’s keeping Weinstein from jail
Royal kids caught up in virus scare amid fresh spread fears
Harry drops royal title as Meghan is a no-show
“But still we see these awful, awful events,” she said.
“So I’ll be working very hard with my colleagues in the coming weeks to look at what options there are for us to pursue further actions in this area.
“Nothing is off the table in terms of what we need to look at.”
Congratulations to the Queensland police for keeping an open mind and awaiting proper evidence, including the possibility that Rowan Baxter might have been “driven too far.†But note the misplaced outrage. How dare police deviate from the feminist script of seeking excuses...
— Bettina Arndt (@thebettinaarndt) February 20, 2020
...and explanations when women stab their partners to death, or drive their children into dams but immediately judging a man in these circumstances as simply representing the evil violence that is in all men. https://t.co/gCMCn1kma1
— Bettina Arndt (@thebettinaarndt) February 20, 2020
COALITION BACKS CALL FOR ARNDT TO LOSE OAM
In their motion on Tuesday, Senator Kenally and Senator Wong said: “The values that underpin Ms Arndt’s views on this horrific family violence incident are not consistent with her retaining her Order of Australia.”
Senator Keneally urged her upper house colleagues to “stand firm” and make it clear there was no excuse for family violence.
“There is no excuse for what happened to Hannah Clarke and her three children, it was a murder plain and simple, but there is nothing plain and simple about the tragedy that is domestic violence,” she told reporters.
“And there is nothing plain and simple about using your position with an Order of Australia to spread comments that could be seen to be inciting violence, that seem to be condoning violence.”
Coalition backing came after Liberal Senators James Paterson spoke in favour of it, saying she had brought the Order of Australia awards into disrepute.
The motion went to a division, where Senator Pauline Hanson was one of two senators to vote against it.
Opposition Leader Anthony Albanese earlier called for support from all sides of parliament.
“This must be above politics - and Bettina Arndt’s comments must be condemned,” Mr Albanese said.
“Today Labor will move to have her Order of Australia withdrawn. Because victims of family violence should never, never be blamed for family violence.” Senior government minister Peter Dutton condemned Ms Arndt’s remarks but would not say whether her award should be revoked.
“I don’t agree with the comments,” he told reporters.
Liberal senators Sarah Henderson and Hollie Hughes have also spoken out against Ms Arndt’s comments.
Ms Arndt drew scrutiny last week after tweeting “Congratulations to the Queensland police for keeping an open mind and awaiting proper evidence, including the possibility that Rowan Baxter might have been ‘driven too far’.”
Governor-General David Hurley has forwarded complaints about her Order of Australia to the body that manages the awards.
It comes as Federal Labor MP Anne Aly opened up about her experience of domestic violence and is pushing for more action on the issue.
She wrote the personal column in the West Australian on Tuesday, a day after parliament reflected on the murder of Hannah Clarke and her three children.
Dr Aly said it had been difficult for her to talk about the murders carried out by Ms Clarke’s estranged husband Rowan Baxter in Brisbane last week, as she was a survivor of domestic violence at the hands of her former spouse and father of her children.
“I have known men like that. Men who see their partners and their children as their possessions and nothing more,” she wrote.
“Abusers who explode with rage when their power is taken away and they can no longer control their partners.”
The MP said she had followed “age-old” advice passed down on how woman should deal with such violence.
“Advice that warned me not to be rash and that cautioned me that leaving my husband and provider would make me destitute – not to mention unattractive and alone,” she said.
“I’ve been patient. I’ve stayed. I’ve nursed my bruises and I’ve hidden my pain. And I’ve stayed silent.
“For a long time I stayed silent. But no more.”
Dr Aly said no amount of talking would stop domestic violence.
She said Australia needed a national campaign to reach into every home with the clear message such violence was a criminal offence and would not be tolerated.
Dr Aly said women who wanted to leave violent relationships also needed support, including safe housing.
“Despite all the pain and abuse I suffered, leaving the father of my children was the hardest decision I have ever made,” she said.
“Until we start taking action on domestic violence, nothing will change.
“Words and gestures in parliament are nice but they don’t solve problems or create the urgent change needed to help women today.”
Prime Minister Scott Morrison said countering domestic violence was a priority for his government every day.
The federal government continues to implement the fourth national domestic violence action plan and the issue will be raised at a COAG meeting in a few weeks time.
“This issue doesn’t know politics. It just knows that there is hurt and pain and tragedy and devastation to families and every day addressing that is a priority for me and my government,” he told reporters.
If you or you know of somebody in need of help, due to problems at home, phone 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) Lifeline 13 11 14.
Originally published as ‘Totally unacceptable: Marise Payne joins calls for Bettina Ardnt to be stripped of Order of Australia honour